Supreme Court won’t block order directing Peter Navarro to turn over emails

The Supreme Court on Monday declined to weigh Peter Navarro’s bid to reverse a court order directing him to turn over hundreds of emails sent during his tenure as an adviser in the first Trump administration.

The former trade adviser to President-elect Trump, who will join his second administration in a similar role, was sued in 2022 by the Justice Department for emails sent from a personal encrypted account after he refused to produce them to the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA).

The Presidential Records Act requires any records generated or received while working in an official capacity — including those sent or received on unofficial accounts — be turned over at the end of an administration.

Navarro wrote in his petition to the justices that he initially planned to comply with NARA’s request but later sought immunity to produce the documents after he was indicted for evading a congressional subpoena.

"Given the related nature of the documents sought by NARA and the allegations against him, Dr. Navarro sought immunity for the production of Presidential records to avoid their use against him in the pending criminal matter,” his lawyers said in the petition.

Navarro was charged with two counts of contempt of Congress for refusing to comply with a subpoena from the House committee that investigated the Jan. 6, 2021, Capitol attack. He was convicted last year and sentenced to four months in prison, which he completed in July.

Two lower courts ruled against Navarro and ordered him to turn over the records. A three-judge panel on the District of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals found “no public interest” in his retention of the records.

In February, U.S. District Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly threatened to hold Navarro in contempt of court for defying her order to turn over the documents.

The Justice Department waived its right to respond to Navarro’s petition.

Topics

Supreme Court won’t hear ex-New York lieutenant governor’s appeal in bribery case

The Supreme Court will not consider throwing out bribery charges against New York’s former lieutenant governor, allowing his case to move forward. Ex-New York Lt. Gov. Brian Benjamin (D) was in ...
The Hill - 3h
Supreme Court declines to block Biden coal waste rule

The Supreme Court has declined to halt a Biden administration rule that seeks to prevent legacy toxic waste from now-shuttered coal plants from leaking out and contaminating nearby groundwater. In ...
The Hill - 4d
Supreme Court Won’t Decide Nvidia Securities Fraud Case After All

In an unsigned order, the justices dismissed the case against the tech giant as “improvidently granted,” meaning they had concluded that it had been a mistake to take it up.
The New York Times - 5d
Supreme Court Turns Down Cases on Admissions, Gender Identity and Guns

Conservative justices voiced objections and concerns about the court’s failures to take up a series of cases on major social controversies.
The New York Times - Dec. 9
Supreme Court turns away challenge to Hawaii handgun license law

The Supreme Court on Monday declined to take up a defendant’s Second Amendment challenge to Hawaii laws that make it a crime to carry handguns or ammunition in public without a license. In written ...
The Hill - Dec. 9
Supreme Court turns away case over Boston high school admissions criteria

The Supreme Court on Monday turned away a challenge to race-neutral admissions criteria at three Boston high schools that aimed to increase racial and economic diversity.
CBS News - Dec. 9
Trump picks Peter Navarro as top trade advisor

President-elect Donald Trump announced that Peter Navarro will serve as "Senior Counselor for Trade and Manufacturing" in his next White House term.
CNBC - Dec. 4
Trump nominates Peter Navarro as senior economic adviser

China hawk who served in president-elect’s first term was imprisoned for contempt of Congress over 2021 Capitol attack
Financial Times - Dec. 4
Supreme Court divided over FDA block on kid-friendly flavored vapes

With e-cigarette sales booming, the Supreme Court heard arguments over whether the FDA unlawfully blocked approval of more than a million new flavored nicotine products.
ABC News - Dec. 2