Supreme Court rules against New York crime family associate over ‘crimes of violence’

The Supreme Court on Friday ruled that crimes committed through inaction can still be violent, rejecting a New York crime family associate’s claim that his conviction in a foiled murder-for-hire plot wasn't a “crime of violence” because he used no physical force.

Salvatore Delligatti, a Genovese crime family associate also known as “Fat Sal,” was found guilty of charges including racketeering and attempted murder after plotting to kill a local “bully.” He hired members of a street gang and gave them a gun and getaway car, but police intervened before the plot ensued.

Delligatti was also convicted of possessing a firearm in furtherance of a “crime of violence,” which carries a mandatory minimum sentence of five consecutive years in prison. He was sentenced to 25-year prison term in total.

Delligatti contended that a crime requiring death or bodily injury like murder, but committed through inaction, cannot be deemed a “crime of violence." The justices in a 7-2 decision rebuffed that claim.

"Intentional murder is the prototypical crime of violence,’ and it has long been understood to incorporate liability for both act and omission," Justice Clarence Thomas wrote in the majority opinion.

At oral arguments in November, the justices hypothesized any number of potentially violent crimes committed through inaction, from dropping poison in a drink or serving food gone dangerously bad to failing to feed a child.

Thomas called back to those scenarios in his opinion. He wrote that a mother who purposely kills her child by deciding not to step in as they drink bleach is still “making ‘use’” of the bleach’s poisonous properties. Or, if a person “sprinkles poison” in a victim’s drink, force is still used by “employing poison knowingly as a device to cause physical harm,” despite the act of sprinkling not involving force.

Justice Gorsuch wrote a dissenting opinion, which Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson joined, which argues that the majority “reworks” the definition of a “crime of violence” at the government’s request but that it’s new definition does not align with the statute.

The minority justices offered their own hypothetical: A lifeguard spots a swimmer struggling against the waves, but instead of leaping into action, he chooses to “settle back in his chair, twirl his whistle, and watch the swimmer slip away.”

"The lifeguard may know that his inaction will cause death. Perhaps the swimmer is the lifeguard’s enemy and the lifeguard even wishes to see him die. Either way, the lifeguard is a bad man,” Gorsuch wrote. “In many States, he may be guilty of a serious crime for failing to fulfill his legal duty to help the swimmer. But does the lifeguard’s offense also qualify under (the law) as a ‘crime of violence’ involving the ‘use...of physical force against the person...of another’?”

“The Court thinks so,” he continued. “I do not.”

Federal appeals courts were split over how to apply the gun charge to other cases, with two of 10 appeals courts that have weighed the matter having determined that use of force is not an element of such crimes if the crime can be committed through inaction, as Delligatti contended.

Despite opposing Delligatti’s appeal, the government agreed that the justices should consider the matter to give lower courts better clarity.

Updated 10:46 a.m.

Topics

NYC Subway Crime Report Shows Random Assaults Outnumber Robberies

While crime remains rare in the New York City subway, a surge in unpredictable attacks, not motivated by theft, signals a worrisome shift.
The New York Times - Mar. 14
8 alleged "GoodFellas" gang members, associates charged with violent crimes

The Department of Justice referred to the "GoodFellas" as a "violent gang" that recruits from the Atlanta area.
CBS News - Mar. 14
Trump asks Supreme Court to take up birthright citizenship plan

The Trump administration wants the Supreme Court to limit the scope of lower court rulings against his executive order that would end automatic birthright citizenship. NBC News' Lawrence Hurley ...
NBC News - Mar. 13
Former Philippines President Rodrigo Duterte arrested over accusations of crimes against humanity

Former Philippines President Rodrigo Duterte has been arrested after the International Criminal Court accused the 79-year-old of crimes against humanity for his administration's deadly "war on ...
CBS News - Mar. 11
Two men convicted of murder-for-hire plot against Iranian American journalist in New York

Masih Alinejad had incurred the wrath of Tehran by campaigning for Iranian women to reject strict dress codes. Two men have been found guilty of plotting to assassinate the Iranian American ...
The Guardian - 22h
North Dakota Senate rejects resolution asking Supreme Court to reverse same-sex marriage ruling

The North Dakota Senate on Thursday rejected a resolution that would have asked the Supreme Court to revisit its landmark 2015 ruling on marriage equality. Senators voted 31-16 against the ...
The Hill - Mar. 14
'Happy Face' looks at ripple effects of true crime

The new Paramount+ series “Happy Face” has all the elements of a gripping true-crime yarn: A serial killer, his estranged daughter, a race to get an innocent man off death row
ABC News - 2d
North Dakota Senate rejects resolution asking Supreme Court to overturn gay marriage ruling

The North Dakota Senate rejected a measure that would have asked the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn its landmark 2015 ruling that legalized same-sex marriage nationwide.
NBC News - Mar. 14
Duffy threatens to withhold funds over NYC subway crime

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy threatened to withhold federal transit funds from the New York Metropolitan Transit Authority (MTA) in a Tuesday letter urging city leaders to reassess their ...
The Hill - 2d