Supreme Court rejects Mark Meadows's push to move Georgia election case to federal court
The Supreme Court refused Tuesday to hear former Trump White House chief of staff Mark Meadows’s appeal seeking to move to federal court his Georgia criminal charges related to efforts to overturn the 2020 election.
Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis (D) charged Meadows, President-elect Trump and more than a dozen others over accusations they unlawfully attempted to overturn President Biden’s 2020 victory in Georgia.
Refusing to hear Meadows’s bid to move courts marks a win for Willis, who has attempted to keep the defendants together for a singular trial in state court.
Trump’s election as president Tuesday has complicated that goal, however. His attorneys are expected to argue the Constitution prohibits Trump’s charges from moving forward while he is in the White House.
It remains unclear how any pause would impact the Trump allies charged alongside him. The trial proceedings already are on indefinite pause amid an appeal by some defendants seeking to remove Willis over her once-romantic relationship with a top prosecutor on the case who has since stepped aside.
In his appeal to the Supreme Court, Meadows cited a provision that allows federal officials to move their criminal prosecution to federal court if it relates to an act taken “under color of such office.” Meadows signaled he was making the gambit to assert immunity from his charges.
Lower courts rejected Meadows’s contention he was acting in his capacity as White House chief of staff, and the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals further ruled that the protections don’t extend to former officials, as opposed to current ones.
Paul Clement, a veteran conservative Supreme Court advocate who represented Meadows, said that holding contradicts the proposition behind the court’s landmark decision in July carving out criminal immunity for former presidents.
“Just as immunity protection for former officers is critical to ensuring that current and future officers are not deterred from enthusiastic service, so too is the promise of a federal forum in which to litigate that defense,” Clement wrote in his petition.
Fulton County prosecutors urged the justices to turn away Meadows’s appeal, arguing the lower court arrived at the right conclusion.
“The opinion below applied long-established principles of statutory interpretation to arrive at its holding, and review is neither necessary nor urgent,” prosecutors wrote in court filings.
The 11th Circuit’s decision has doomed similar efforts mounted by four other defendants in the case — Trump Justice Department official Jeffrey Clark, and three pro-Trump individuals who signed documents purporting to be Georgia’s electors despite Biden’s victory — to move their charges to federal court.
Their efforts have proceeded on a slower timetable, and they still retain the option of going to the Supreme Court, too.
Meadows has also mounted an effort to move to his charges in Arizona over the 2020 election to federal court, but he has so far been unsuccessful there, too.
The Fulton County district attorney's office declined to comment. The Hill has reached out to Meadows's attorney for comment
Updated at 9:48 a.m. EST
-
Supreme Court rejects Meadows' bid to move Georgia election case to federal court
Top stories - CBS News - November 12 -
Supreme Court rejects Mark Meadows' appeal in Georgia election interference case
Top stories - NBC News - November 12 -
SCOTUS rejects Mark Meadows' bid to move Georgia election case into federal court
Top stories - ABC News - November 12 -
Trump nominates Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy to lead new efficiency department to ‘restructure federal agencies’ – live
World - The Guardian - November 13 -
2024 election updates: Musk asks to move $1 million lottery case to federal court
Top stories - ABC News - October 31 -
Elon Musk skips hearing as $1m election giveaway case moves to federal court
World - The Guardian - October 31
More from The Hill
-
Republican senator predicts Gaetz wouldn't win Florida governorship after he teases run
Politics - The Hill - 45 minutes ago -
Democratic rep tells Americans to 'calm down' amid concerns over Trump Cabinet picks
Politics - The Hill - 1 hour ago -
Dana Carvey says he can't impersonate Elon Musk 'very well' after SNL appearance
Politics - The Hill - 2 hours ago -
Bernice King 'glad' Trump inauguration taking place on MLK day
Politics - The Hill - 2 hours ago -
Auchincloss: Senate must reject ‘dangerous’ RFK Jr. as HHS head
Politics - The Hill - 3 hours ago