Supreme Court lets law stand that allows for ticketing of homeless people camping
![Supreme Court lets law stand that allows for ticketing of homeless people camping](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/06/scotus_062824gn05_w.jpg?w=900)
The Supreme Court ruled Friday that cities can ticket homeless people for camping in public even when there is no alternative shelter available, a decision that could drastically alter the lives of hundreds of thousands of Americans without a permanent place to live.
The justices sided 6-3 with the Oregon city of Grants Pass, which had asked the high court to review a lower court’s decision blocking the enforcement of a public camping ordinance after determining that banning camping where shelter beds were limited amounts to cruel and unusual punishment.
Grants Pass officials argued that the restrictions imposed by the decision from the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals prevented them from implementing “common sense” laws against camping in certain public places. The justices agreed.
“Yes, people will disagree over which policy responses are best; they may experiment with one set of approaches only to find later another set works better; they may find certain responses more appropriate for some communities than others,” Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote for the majority. “But in our democracy, that is their right.”
“The Constitution’s Eighth Amendment serves many important functions, but it does not authorize federal judges to wrest those rights and responsibilities from the American people and in their place dictate this Nation’s homelessness policy,” he continued.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor, joined by liberal Justices Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson, sharply rebuked the majority’s decision, suggesting it focused “almost exclusively” on local governments’ needs while leaving “the most vulnerable in our society” with a choice between staying awake or being arrested.
She read her dissent from the bench.
"For people with no access to shelter, that punishes them for being homeless," Sotomayor said of the city's law. "That is unconscionable and unconstitutional. Punishing people for their status is 'cruel and unusual' under the Eighth Amendment."
Justice Clarence Thomas, in a brief concurring opinion, wrote that “modern public opinion” is the wrong metric with which to interpret the Eighth Amendment clause, claiming that many of the high court’s other precedents under the amendment “make the same mistake.”
The Grants Pass anti-camping law would fine homeless people $295 per night for sleeping in the city’s public parks. Attorneys representing the city’s homeless population had argued that allowing the rule to stand would essentially criminalize the existence of homeless people.
During oral arguments in April, the justices acknowledged the complicated issue of homelessness in the U.S.
Sotomayor raised that sleeping is a biological necessity and that some people may be forced to do it outside if other shelter isn’t available, a concern she reiterated in her dissent. Justice Brett Kavanaugh questioned whether ticketing people for sleeping outside helps solve the issue if there isn’t an alternative. And Justice Neil Gorsuch pointed to the sanitary risk posed by allowing encampments to stand.
Theane Evangelis, who represented Grants Pass, said in a statement that the Supreme Court’s decision delivered “urgent relief” to communities that have struggled to address “the growing problem of dangerous encampments.”
“The Court has now restored the ability of cities on the frontlines of this crisis to develop lasting solutions that meet the needs of the most vulnerable members of their communities, while also keeping our public spaces safe and clean,” she said. “Years from now, I hope that we will look back on today’s watershed ruling as the turning point in America’s homelessness crisis.”
Rates of homelessness remain at record-high levels as housing prices continue to soar. There are about 650,000 homeless people in the country, according to the Department of Housing and Urban Development, with about a third of them living on the West Coast.
The justices previously declined to consider a similar appeal of the lower court’s 2019 ruling, which found that sleeping outdoors on public property — when there is no option to sleep indoors — can’t be criminalized “on the false premise they had a choice in the matter.”
The Associated Press contributed.
Updated at 10:43 a.m.
Date: |
Filter
-
CBS News - Top stories
Supreme Court allows camping bans targeting homeless encampments
The 6-3 decision from the court in the case known as City of Grants Pass v. Johnson is its most significant involving homelessness in decades. -
NBC News - Top stories
Supreme Court allows Oregon city policy that punishes homeless people for sleeping on public property
The Supreme Court rejected a constitutional challenge to ordinances enacted by a small city in Oregon that punish homeless people for sleeping on public property when they have nowhere else to go. -
CBS News - Top stories
Supreme Court allows cities to enforce bans targeting homeless people sleeping outside
The Supreme Court has decided in favor of a small Oregon town that placed civil punishments on homeless people for sleeping in public spaces, finding 6-3 the punishments don't violate the Eighth Amendment. Former federal prosecutor Scott ... -
ABC News - Top stories
Supreme Court says city's homeless camping ban not 'cruel and unusual' punishment
The Supreme Court ruled an Oregon city's ordinance to bar anyone without a permanent residency from sleeping outside doesn't amount to “cruel and unusual” punishment. -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Supreme Court Expands Cities' Power to Remove Homeless Camps
Justices rejected a claim that penalizing people with nowhere else to sleep is unconstitutionally cruel. -
ABC News - Health
Iowa’s Supreme Court tells lower court to let strict abortion law go into effect
Iowa’s Supreme Court tells lower court to let strict abortion law go into effectAbortion -
NBC News - Top stories
Iowa's Supreme Court tells lower court to let strict abortion law go into effect
The Iowa Supreme Court said the state’s strict abortion law is legal, allowing Iowa to ban most abortions after about six weeks of pregnancy.Abortion -
CBS News - Politics
Iowa's Supreme Court tells lower court to let strict abortion law go into effect
Iowa joins more than a dozen other states with restrictive abortion laws following the U.S. Supreme Court's overturning of Roe v. Wade in 2022. Three other states currently ban abortions at about six weeks.Abortion -
The New York Times - Top stories
Supreme Court Allows, for Now, Emergency Abortions in Idaho
A majority of the justices voted to dismiss the case, reinstating a lower-court ruling that paused the state’s near-total abortion ban. The ruling mirrored a version inadvertently posted a day earlier.Abortion
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Can Biden recover from the debate? Don’t bet on it.
The more one analyzes the road ahead, the more obvious it is that a continued Biden candidacy is a kamikaze mission sure to wreck the Democratic Party.Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Trump says Supreme Court delivered 'high level spanking' to Jack Smith
Former President Trump said early Tuesday that the Supreme Court’s presidential immunity decision delivered a “high level SPANKING!” to special counsel Jack Smith, whose independent probe of the former president led to two criminal indictments ...Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Hungarian prime minister arrives in Kyiv for Zelensky meeting
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban on Tuesday arrived in Kyiv, where he is set to meet with Ukrainian President Volodomyr Zelensky amid tensions between the two European leaders over Russia's war in Ukraine. Orban, a key ally of Russian leader ...Ukraine -
The Hill - Politics
Desperately seeking Biden's replacement and finding … not much
Democrats face a tough decision on who would replace President Biden if he steps down. Kamala Harris, Michelle Obama, and other options are considered.Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Ukraine is taking the fight to Russia in Africa, Syria
Ukraine's military intelligence has been conducting operations in Africa and the Middle East to reduce Russian military potential, and Maj. Gen. Kyrylo Budanov has been leading the charge to fight Russia anywhere it can be found.Ukraine