Supreme Court declines to hear Kari Lake voting machine lawsuit
The Supreme Court declined Monday to take up a case brought by Republicans Kari Lake and Mark Finchem over the use of voting machines in Arizona elections, the latest blow to the duo of GOP candidates who have seen their lawsuit rejected several times.
Lake and Finchem asked the Supreme Court to review a federal appellate judge’s decision to dismiss their case last October. The suit sought to block electronic voting machines from being used in the state, questioning their accuracy and reliability.
Lawyers for Lake, who is running for a Senate seat in Arizona this cycle, and Finchem, who is seeking a state Senate seat, argued in a court filing to the Supreme Court that they had sufficiently argued that “[a]ll Arizona-certified optical scanners and ballot marking devices, as well as the software on which they rely, have been wrongly certified for use"; Arizona’s voting machines had been “hacked” and “manipulated”; and that there were apparent discrepancies in the Maricopa County’s vote count after the 2020 election.
The lawsuit was filed ahead of the November 2022 midterms, when Lake was running for governor and Finchem was running for secretary of state. Both lost their elections.
Their lawsuit had been rejected by a federal judge in 2022, and that dismissal was affirmed by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals last year.
“On appeal, Plaintiffs conceded that their arguments were limited to potential future hacking, and not based on any past harm,” the 9th Circuit wrote.
“In the end, none of Plaintiffs’ allegations supports a plausible inference that their individual votes in future elections will be adversely affected by the use of electronic tabulation, particularly given the robust safeguards in Arizona law, the use of paper ballots, and the post-tabulation retention of those ballots,” it added.
The Supreme Court’s decision to decline to revisit the federal court’s decision puts a cap on Lake’s and Finchem’s lawsuit.
"We are obviously disappointed that the U.S. Supreme Court decided not to review the decisions of the Arizona district court and the Ninth Circuit, and order that our challenge to the 2022 election procedures be heard on the merits," said Kurt Olsen, one of the attorneys that sought to get the Supreme Court to consider the case, in a statement, who argued new information came to light after their case was dismissed by the circuit court.
"Although the Supreme Court grants review in less than 1 percent of cases presented on petition, we believe we presented a case."
"The Kari Lake and Mark Finchem case was dismissed based on a purported lack of standing to assert an injury," Olsen wrote. "Therefore, the courts, even now, have not ruled on the merits of our case. We will continue to raise these issues especially in light of the upcoming 2024 election."
Republicans including Lake, Finchem and former President Trump have sought to cast doubt about the 2020 and 2022 election results in states including Arizona, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania, though those election results have consistently been upheld.
Updated: 12:16 p.m. ET
Date: |
Topics
Filter
-
Panama Supreme Court rejects challenge to candidacy of presidential frontrunner days before vote
Panama’s Supreme Court has rejected a constitutional challenge to the candidacy of leading presidential contender José Raúl MulinoABC News - World -
Civil rights leaders blast Supreme Court at their doorstep
Civil rights leaders from around the nation gathered in Washington, D.C., Friday to protest book bans and rising attacks on diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI), saying limitations on education were hurting teachers, students and democracy as a ...The Hill - Politics -
Cambodia's Supreme Court upholds the 2-year prison sentence of a casino strike leader
Cambodia’s Supreme Court has upheld the two-year prison sentence of a labor union leader who led a long-running strike against the country’s biggest casinoABC News - World -
Former Supreme Court justice Stephen Breyer: ‘Are you kidding? You’ll get more cases than ever!’
The American lawyer on the problem of overturning of Roe vs Wade, the ‘psychological difficulty’ of retirement — and what ‘Macbeth’ tells us about WashingtonFinancial Times - Business -
Cas to hear Algerian appeal in Morocco map row
The Court of Arbitration for Sport will hear an appeal about a map of Morocco on a football shirt which has angered Algerians.Yahoo Sports - Sports -
In Super Metroid, No One Can Hear You Scream
Super Metroid recently celebrated its 30-year anniversary. Below, we look back at how it used and helped to create horror game tropes.It begins with a benign pulse over black. An otherworldly synth shriek interrupting. Random shots of dead ...GameSpot - Tech -
15 Best Baby Gear (2024): Diaper Bags, Baby Wraps, and Sound Machines
From a sound machine to a smart sensor, here’s what made life easier during my infant’s first year (and a few things I could’ve lived without).Wired - Tech -
Best rowing machines in 2024 for low-impact workouts that blend cardio and strength training
These top-rated rowing machines from NordicTrack, Hydrow and more deliver a full body workout.CBS Sports - Sports
More from The Hill
-
‘America First’ conservatives aren’t putting American workers first
We know these senators aren’t on the side of the American worker, which begs the question — whose side are they on? The answer is obvious: people and corporations with money.The Hill - Politics -
Education secretary condemns 'abhorrent' antisemitic incidents on campus
Education Secretary Miguel Cardona sent a letter Friday to college and university presidents condemning what he called “abhorrent” antisemitic incidents on campus, the latest response from the Biden administration to the ongoing nationwide ...The Hill - Politics -
Chris Christie: ‘More likely than not’ Stephen A. Smith runs for president
Former GOP presidential candidate and New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie claimed that its “more likely than not” that sports commentator Stephen A. Smith runs for president in the future. “I don’t think it’s imminent, but will he run someday? I think ...The Hill - Politics -
White House shakes up its immigration team
The White House is shaking up its roster of immigration advisers, bringing in a top border enforcement policy leader and a development expert to round out its team. Blas Nuñez-Neto comes to the White House from the Department of Homeland Security ...The Hill - Politics -
Jean-Pierre: 'Admirable' for UNC students to hold up American flag during campus protest
The White House on Friday praised the actions of a group of University of North Carolina students who held up the American flag at a protest on campus over the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza. Press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre was asked during a ...The Hill - Politics