Supreme Court appears split in San Francisco water lawsuit against Biden administration
The Supreme Court appeared split Wednesday on a challenge from the city of San Francisco to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency over federal wastewater rules.
In its lawsuit against the federal agency, the city argued regulations around discharge of untreated sewage were unclear, including the potential price tag for violations, and that they could leave the city on the hook for factors beyond its control, such as the quality of water that enters the San Francisco Bay from elsewhere.
The high court agreed to hear the case after the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against the city 2-1 last summer.
In oral arguments Tuesday, Tara Steeley, an attorney for the city, told the court that under the status quo, “they might as well have said: Do not violate the Clean Water Act. It doesn't tell us anything.”
The court’s liberal minority appeared broadly skeptical of the city’s argument, with Justice Sonia Sotomayor pushing back on Steeley’s characterization that the city was expected to “shift on a dime.”
“No one's asking you to shift on a dime. What they're asking you to do is to become responsible for doing what's necessary, not on a dime, but to take the steps necessary to control situations that develop,” Sotomayor said.
However, Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Brett Kavanaugh appeared receptive to the city’s arguments.
“What the permit system was designed to do was give some notice to the different dischargers about what was going to be required of them, [but] your water quality system gives you complete discretion in which who’s going to bear the burden and who's not,” Roberts said to Assistant to the Solicitor General Frederick Liu.
Kavanaugh, meanwhile, asked Liu if “you can go after an individual entity, like the City of San Francisco, based on the past when they didn't know what the relevant limitation on them was and seek retroactively, without fairness, huge penalties, including criminal punishment, based on something that they didn't know what they could discharge or not discharge.”
“You're suing San Francisco separately for a lot of money, based on a standard that they had no idea [of], at least that's the theory,” Kavanaugh added.
The court’s conservative supermajority has repeatedly issued rulings curtailing the authority of federal regulatory agencies, including in its most recent term, when it threw out the Chevron deference, which gave federal agencies broad discretion in interpreting statutes.
Date: | |
Tag: | Joe Biden |
-
Business - The New York Times
Conservative Justices Appear to Side With San Francisco in Water Quality Dispute
The justices heard arguments on Wednesday in a long-simmering dispute between San Francisco and the E.P.A. over regulation of water pollution.41 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Supreme Court allows Biden plan on power plants
{beacon} Energy & Environment Energy & Environment The Big Story Supreme Court paves way for Biden climate rule for power plants The Supreme Court declined Wednesday to block a Biden ...1 hour ago - Joe Biden -
Politics - The Hill
Supreme Court declines to block Biden's climate rule for power plants — for now
The Supreme Court on Wednesday declined to block a Biden administration rule setting climate standards for power plants — but hinted it could take up the case at a later time. The high court ...2 hours ago - Climate -
Top stories - NBC News
Supreme Court allows Biden to implement plan to curb carbon emissions from power plants
The regulation is aimed at curbing carbon emissions from coal- and gas-fired power plants by using a process called “carbon capture” that challengers say is not economically viable.1 hour ago - Joe Biden -
Entertainment - ABC News
Hunter Biden revives lawsuit against Fox News over explicit images used in streaming series
Hunter Biden is reviving a lawsuit that accuses Fox News of illegally publishing explicit images of him as part of a streaming seriesYesterday - Joe Biden -
World - The Wall Street Journal
Biden Administration Issues Warning to Israel on Gaza Aid
The administration is urging Israel to improve the humanitarian situation in Gaza or risk a cut to arms sales, the starkest threat by the U.S. since the war began last year.Yesterday - Joe Biden -
Business - Inc.
Petitions to Unionize Doubled Under Biden Administration
Workers filed 3,286 bids with the government to form unions, the first increase in a presidential term since Gerald Ford left office in 1976.4 hours ago - Joe Biden -
Top stories - The New York Times
Kamala Harris Didn’t Fail San Francisco. Progressives Like Aaron Peskin Did.
Aaron Peskin, a little-known progressive politician, bears responsibility for some of San Francisco’s biggest problems.13 hours ago - Kamala Harris -
Politics - The Hill
Ocasio-Cortez criticizes Biden administration over 'unrestrained' Israel government
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) criticized the Biden administration on Monday over what she called an “unrestrained” Israeli government. “The horrors unfolding in northern Gaza are the ...2 days ago - Joe Biden
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Lawmakers press Boeing to resolve monthlong strike
Welcome to The Hill's Business & Economy newsletter {beacon} Business & Economy Business & Economy The Big Story Lawmakers press Boeing to resolve monthlong strike Democratic lawmakers in ...25 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
NC county Democratic chair resigns after Trump sign stealing charges
A county Democratic chair in North Carolina resigned after he was arrested and charged with stealing road signs supporting former President Trump. The Moore County Democratic Party announced Monday ...41 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Big Tech turns to nuclear energy to power AI boom
Major technology companies are increasingly turning to nuclear energy as they attempt to keep up with the vast energy demands of artificial intelligence (AI) without derailing their highly ...45 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Warnock on Marjorie Taylor Greene: 'I pray for her every day'
Sen. Raphael Warnock (D-Ga.) said he prays for Georgia Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R) daily after the Republican falsely claimed people controlled the weather after Hurricane Helene hit the ...49 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
House Democrats launch $3M ad campaign focused on Project 2025
The House Democratic campaign arm on Wednesday launched a multimillion-dollar ad blitz focused on Project 2025, a conservative blueprint for the next Republican presidency that Democrats have been ...51 minutes ago