Stronger whistleblower laws can help prevent the next corporate fiasco
Boeing whistleblower Sam Salehpour recently testified before Congress that the aircraft maker slapped him down for simply reporting what he saw as serious safety issues. He is the latest in a string of whistleblowers silenced and shunned for speaking out with their concerns — only to be vindicated years later when their warnings eventually came to pass, or when their employers were publicly taken to task for ignoring them.
As Boeing’s crisis deepens by the day, it’s time to admit that there is something seriously wrong with how we treat whistleblowers in America.
It seems that behind every major calamity these days there is a whistleblower who tried to raise the alarm in advance. The Baltimore bridge collapse, OceanGate’s submersible disaster and the devastating Maui wildfires are three of the most recent examples, but the list goes on. These and many other debacles might have been averted if whistleblowers’ warnings had been heeded. But no matter how often this history repeats itself, employers continue to stubbornly ignore the obvious lesson to be learned.
Why do so many companies and government agencies treat whistleblowers with such contempt? Why can’t they see the critical role whistleblowers play in uncovering problems early on, before they have festered into something far more serious? And, most fundamentally, why do employers believe they can punish whistleblowers into submission when it so often leads to the exact opposite result — driving them to the authorities or the press, causing a whole lot more trouble for everyone down the road?
Boeing is a powerful case in point. So are Facebook, Twitter, Theranos and a host of other prominent companies forced to weather a maelstrom of unfavorable media and government attention for ignoring their whistleblower admonitions. It plays out this way in my legal practice all the time. The whistleblowers who seek my firm’s assistance almost always reach out only after they first raised their issues and concerns at work, and only after they were ignored, rebuffed or retaliated against for doing so.
In virtually every case, these companies would have avoided government and media scrutiny, substantial penalties and a public relations nightmare if they had simply embraced the whistleblowers and their concerns from the start. It would have been better for the whistleblowers and the public too, a win-win-win all around. But it is all too often the path not taken, because of a deep-rooted distrust and disdain for whistleblowers.
Perhaps the only way to snap these companies out of the “nobody likes a snitch” mentality is for the government to give recalcitrant employers a stronger push in the right direction. The Supreme Court recently did its part in Murray v. UBS, where it significantly lowered the bar for whistleblowers to prove illegal retaliation, unanimously recognizing that “the health, safety, or well-being of the public may well depend on whistleblowers feeling empowered to come forward.”
Congress needs to follow suit by strengthening whistleblower protection laws, which, while helpful, still fall short in several ways. They impose an unreasonably short window to bring a retaliation claim (typically 180 days or less); require whistleblowers to first pursue administrative channels (instead of the courts) with a poor track record of supporting whistleblowers; and provide only modest relief for those whistleblowers able to successfully navigate this bureaucratic scheme (typically only reinstatement and backpay).
This hardly provides the kind of meaningful mechanism for scaring employers straight and fostering a more whistleblower-friendly environment. Whistleblowers need an easier path to pursue employers behaving badly, and employers need a more serious regulatory deterrent to mistreating whistleblowers. Employers must face the threat of significantly more sizeable financial penalties, and offending managers and compliance professionals must be held individually accountable.
Only then might we see a meaningful shift in the whistleblower status quo. The next time a whistleblower comes along warning of an impending financial disaster or public health or safety risk, the employer must feel compelled to act on the whistleblower’s concerns. The employer, the whistleblower and the public will all be the better for it.
Gordon Schnell is a partner in the New York office of Constantine Cannon, specializing in the representation of whistleblowers.
Date: |
Filter
-
Rain, cooler temperatures help prevent wildfire near Canada's oil sands from growing
Yahoo News - World -
Rain, cooler temperatures help prevent wildfire near Canada's oil sands from growing
A wildfire that has forced thousands of people out of their homes in Canada’s oil sands hub city of Fort McMurray, Alberta is being held in place as rain and cooler temperatures sweep through the areaABC News - World -
Uber launches service that can help with eldercare
Transportation to medical appointments or medical errands can be arranged by app and paid for with health insuranceMarketWatch - Business -
Biden asserts executive privilege to prevent Congress from getting recordings
President Biden asserted executive privilege to keep Congress from obtaining recordings of his interviews with the special counsel who investigated his handling of documents. The counsel had referred to the president as a "well meaning elderly man ...NBC News - Politics - Joe Biden -
Member of Taiwan’s parliament steals bill to prevent its passage
Members of the Taiwanese legislature clashed in a chaotic brawl this week, resulting in members being tackled and hit, after a member attempted to steal a bill to prevent it from being passed. Lawmakers were seen leaping over tables and pulling ...The Hill - Politics -
Fed’s Mester says her businesses contacts are sensing the economy is stronger than anticipated
Business contacts in the Midwest are starting to become much more upbeat about where the economy is going, Cleveland Federal Reserve Bank President Loretta Mester said on Thursday.MarketWatch - Business -
Ethnic strife is tearing Ethiopia apart, but America can help end it
Ethiopia is a nation in crisis.The Hill - Politics -
Congress can help colleges counter antisemitism through free speech
The recent shocking torrent of antisemitism has awakened Americans. More and more are speaking up. The First Amendment provides them — as well as faculty and students — with opportunities to educate the public about Israel, Jewish history and ...The Hill - Politics -
Talk on how Jersey can help West African projects
Yahoo News - World
More from The Hill
-
Fetterman mocks Menendez 'blaming your wife' strategy
Sen. John Fetterman (D-Penn.) mocked Sen. Bob Menendez on Sunday for what he described as the New Jersey Democrat's "blaming your wife" legal strategy in his bribery trial that kicked off in Manhattan last week. Fetterman responded to the opening ...The Hill - Politics -
Biden has become detached from economic reality
The vast majority of Americans recognize Bidenomics as a disaster for the nation.The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Haley draws support from Trump in Maryland, Nebraska, West Virginia primaries
Former GOP presidential candidate Nikki Haley garnered significant shares of the vote in three Republican primaries Tuesday, despite dropping of the race over two months ago. In Maryland, Haley brought in 20 percent of the vote to former President ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
John Dean: Hush money case against Trump 'very powerful'
John Dean, former President Nixon's White House counsel, said in a Saturday interview that the New York hush money criminal trial against former President Trump is “very powerful” ahead of highly anticipated testimony this week from Trump’s ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Most expect Trump to be convicted in hush money trial: Poll
Most registered voters say they expect former President Trump to be convicted on some or all counts in his ongoing hush money criminal trial in New York, according to a poll released Tuesday. The Suffolk University/USA Today survey, conducted from ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump