Starbucks receives sympathetic Supreme Court reception in union case
Starbucks received a sympathetic reception at the Supreme Court on Tuesday, as it fought a lower court judgement ordering it to reinstate seven employees amid a unionization drive.
The justices are weighing how difficult it should be to halt alleged unfair labor practices as the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) processes complaints, which can sometimes take years.
Federal appeals courts have applied different legal tests for when to dole out the so-called 10(j) injunctions, which can force companies to reinstate employees, keep facilities open and pause corporate policy changes.
Lower courts ordered Starbucks to reinstate the seven employees by applying the more lenient test.
Starbucks says that version is a "huge problem," urging the justices to order lower courts to instead apply their traditional, four-factor test that would be more stringent.
Several of the court’s conservative justices appeared sympathetic to that position, asking relatively few questions to Starbucks’s lawyer while pressing the government on its proposed standard.
“In all sorts of alphabet soup agencies we don't do this ... so why is this particular statutory regime different than so many others?” Justice Neil Gorsuch asked the government’s lawyer.
The case arose from the “Memphis Seven,” seven Starbucks employees who were terminated in 2022 during a unionization effort. The employees had publicly posted a letter addressed to the company’s CEO and sat down in the store with a television news crew to discuss the organizing efforts.
The coffee giant said it lawfully terminated the employees for breaking the company's policies the day of the television interview, including by going behind the counter while off-duty and unlocking a locked door to allow an unauthorized person to enter the store.
The dispute came amid a broader unionization wave at Starbucks. Starbucks Workers United said earlier this year that 400 stores with more than 10,000 workers have joined the union.
Starbucks is not challenging the constitutionality of the NLRB. At issue before the justices is what criteria apply when the NLRB goes to court seeking injunctions until it resolves a labor complaint, like the agency did to get the Memphis Seven reinstated.
Starbucks argues courts should apply their four traditional criteria, but the NLRB contends it should receive more deference given its role in investigating unlawful labor practices.
“The district court is an independent check, so it seems like it should be just doing what district courts do since it was given the authority to do it,” said Justice Amy Coney Barrett.
Though that sentiment was echoed by multiple justices during the argument, not all agreed.
“This is not just the standard preliminary injunction that district courts do on a daily basis in regular ordinary cases,” said Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, one of the court’s liberals.
Lisa Blatt, the attorney arguing on behalf of Starbucks, rejected that notion, saying, “It is an ordinary preliminary injunction, and this is an ordinary statute.”
Austin Raynor, an assistant to the solicitor general who represented the government, cited data that the NLRB only sought the injunctions at issue in a handful of instances last year out of the 20,000 unfair labor charges it received.
“This isn't a case where the board is engaged in abuse or bringing all sorts of claims before courts,” Raynor said.
That point appeared to garner sympathy from Jackson, who suggested that “this is not sounding like a huge problem.”
And fellow liberal Justice Sonia Sotomayor at one point noted data that the NLRB’s win rate under its favored standard is only 61 percent.
“So, it's not a rubber stamp to win,” Sotomayor said.
A decision in the case, Starbucks v. McKinney, is expected by the end of June.
Date: |
Topics
Filter
-
Former Supreme Court justice Stephen Breyer: ‘Are you kidding? You’ll get more cases than ever!’
The American lawyer on the problem of overturning of Roe vs Wade, the ‘psychological difficulty’ of retirement — and what ‘Macbeth’ tells us about WashingtonFinancial Times - Business -
Democrats alarmed over conservative judges in Trump court cases
Democratic lawmakers are sounding the alarm over what they see as conservative justices and judges tipping the scales in favor of former President Trump in two federal cases. The two cases accuse the former president of attempting to subvert the ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Panama Supreme Court rejects challenge to candidacy of presidential frontrunner days before vote
Panama’s Supreme Court has rejected a constitutional challenge to the candidacy of leading presidential contender José Raúl MulinoABC News - World -
Cambodia's Supreme Court upholds the 2-year prison sentence of a casino strike leader
Cambodia’s Supreme Court has upheld the two-year prison sentence of a labor union leader who led a long-running strike against the country’s biggest casinoABC News - World -
Ledecky, Thorpe to receive Medal of Freedom
Katie Ledecky, the most decorated women's swimmer in history, and Jim Thorpe, the first Native American to win an Olympic gold medal for the United States, will be among 19 people to be honored with the Presidential Medal of Freedom.ESPN - Sports -
Starbucks Is Running Out of Americans to Drink Its Expensive Coffee
The chain is banking on foreigners, especially in China, to buy a lot more of its drinks.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Wide receiver rankings for fantasy football 2024
The Yahoo Fantasy football analysts reveal their first wide receiver rankings for the 2024 NFL season.Yahoo Sports - Sports - Fantasy Football -
What Happened When the Skating Coaches Wanted a Union
A group of figure skating coaches at Chelsea Piers in Manhattan, many of whom earn less than $40,000 a year, sought to bargain their contracts collectively. Two were fired.The New York Times - Top stories -
Trinity College Dublin's students' union fined €214k over protests
TCD issues fine over loss of income as a result of recent blockades of a tourist attraction.BBC News - Top stories - College Football -
Union propagandists are confusing high housing costs with ‘wealth’
Overall, the average disposable income per capita in right-to-work states last year, adjusted for the cost of living, was roughly $2,800 higher than the average of the other states.The Hill - Politics
More from The Hill
-
AI deepfakes are causing chaos in elections across the world. The US isn’t ready.
As the parade of 2024 global elections continues, including the massive vote underway in India, the U.S. will likely get further previews of how much damage deepfakes can cause.The Hill - Politics -
Cruz knocks Greene's 'silly' threats to oust Johnson
Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) knocked Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene’s (R-Ga.) effort to oust Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) as “silly,” while praising him as a “strong” conservative. “I think it is silly,” Cruz said during this Thursday appearance on ...The Hill - Politics -
DC police say officers won't take down GW encampment despite GOP demands
District of Columbia police defended its decision to let the pro-Palestinian encampment at George Washington University (GW) stand, despite calls from Republican lawmakers for it to be cleared. The Metropolitan Police Department (MPD) and Mayor ...The Hill - Politics -
White House news briefing: Watch live
White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre is scheduled to brief reporters on Friday afternoon. The briefing comes after President Biden drew a clear line in a Thursday address between his administration’s support for Israel in its war against ...The Hill - Politics -
12:30 Report — Fewer April jobs may bode well for interest rates
{beacon} 12:30 REPORT Happy Friday! This is a weekend full of festivities: The Kentucky Derby is tomorrow, and Cinco de Mayo is on Sunday! Here’s what’s in today’s edition: The U.S. economy added far fewer jobs than expected last month. The Fed ...The Hill - Politics