Speaker Johnson won’t raise bar on motion to vacate rule
Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) announced Thursday that he won’t seek to raise the bar for removing a Speaker from power as part of the current debate over Ukraine aid — a prospect that had sparked an outcry from conservatives earlier in the day.
Under current House rules, any single member of the House can compel a vote on a motion to vacate, but a number of moderate Republicans have pressed Johnson to use the yet-to-be-passed rule governing the foreign aid legislation to raise that threshold.
Johnson, who’s under fire from conservatives over his leadership style and deal-cutting record with Democrats, had reportedly deliberated over that rule change. But after hours of public clamoring and furious threats from the hard-liners, the Speaker announced he would leave the rule as it stands.
“Since the beginning of the 118th Congress, the House rule allowing a Motion to Vacate from a single member has harmed this office and our House majority. Recently, many members have encouraged me to endorse a new rule to raise this threshold. While I understand the importance of that idea, any rule change requires a majority of the full House, which we do not have,” Johnson wrote in a post on social platform X.
“We will continue to govern under the existing rules,” he added.
Johnson’s decision to leave the motion-to-vacate threshold as is could earn him some good graces from hard-line conservatives, who were up in arms Thursday morning amid reports that the Speaker was considering a change to the ouster mechanism.
Rep. Lauren Boebert (R-Colo.) told reporters Thursday that she would support Johnson’s removal if he went ahead and modified the motion-to-vacate threshold.
“It’s a red line for me, for sure,” she said.
Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.), who spearheaded the ouster effort against former Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) last year, suggested he would join those calling for Johnson’s removal if he made a change.
“I think a motion to vacate is something that could put the conference in peril, and Ms. Boebert and I were working to avoid that,” Gaetz said. “Our goal is to avoid a motion to vacate. But we are not going to surrender that accountability tool, particularly in a time when we are seeing America’s interests subjugated to foreign interests abroad.”
Gaetz appeared to welcome Johnson’s decision, writing on X, “The Motion to Vacate was built for speed, not comfort, Mr. Speaker.”
In a statement to The Hill, the Florida Republican said, “I hope his views on this subject aren’t as flexible as his views on single subject spending bills, warrantless spying, or Ukraine.”
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.), a frequent Johnson critic who has already introduced a motion to vacate against the Speaker — a resolution that she’s been dangling like a warning over the Ukraine debate — also protested the notion of raising the motion-to-vacate threshold. Marching from the chamber to the Capitol steps, she accused Johnson of conspiring with Democrats to protect his gavel at the expense of Republicans’ policy priorities.
“Kevin McCarthy, while he was staring down the barrel of a loaded gun, he never made a move like this: behind closed doors and made deals with Democrats to change the motion to vacate. And we're hearing that's exactly what Mike Johnson is doing,” Greene said. “It's unprecedented. This has never happened in history. And it's completely wrong.”
The drama over the motion to vacate this Congress began in January 2023, when conservatives pushed McCarthy to drop the threshold for the ouster mechanism to just one member as a condition for earning their support in his quest for the Speaker’s gavel. Under former Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.), a motion to vacate could only be brought if a majority of either party was in support.
McCarthy ultimately gave in to the calls, which helped him earn the gavel but also led to his demise: Gaetz forced a vote on his ouster in October, which was successful.
Since then, moderate Republicans have pushed to raise the threshold. A source familiar told The Hill that the Main Street Caucus had led the current effort to change the rule.
Johnson himself has floated changing the rules surrounding the motion to vacate. During an interview with CNN, he said the mechanism “has been abused in recent times,” adding “maybe, at some point, we change that.”
At the House GOP retreat in West Virginia last month, Johnson told reporters he expects "there will probably be a change” to the motion to vacate rules.
“The motion to vacate is something that comes up a lot amongst members and discussion. … I expect there will probably be a change to that as well. But just so you know, I’ve never advocated for that; I’m not one who’s making it into this issue, because I don’t think it is one for now,” Johnson had said.
“I just think it’s something that a lot of members on both sides of the aisle talk about openly that they have a desire for [a] more normal process on the House floor again,” he continued. “So we’ll be looking at that on the House rules package in our respective caucus and conference packages as well as going to the new Congress. And that’s just something we should do in due course, be good stewards of the institution.”
Date: |
Filter
-
Marjorie Taylor Greene says she will go forward with motion to oust Speaker Johnson
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., held a press conference to announce she would be advancing the motion to vacate she filed against Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., after he worked with Democrats to pass pieces of legislation.NBC News - Politics -
Marjorie Taylor Greene Says She Wants Vote to Oust Speaker Johnson Next Week
Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene, the right-wing Republican from Georgia, excoriated the House speaker for working with Democrats to push through major bills. She said she would move ahead despite all but certain defeat.The New York Times - Top stories -
Boebert: 'It makes no difference to me' if Jeffries or Johnson is Speaker
Rep. Lauren Boebert (R-Colo.) said Tuesday there is “no difference” to her whether Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) keeps his job or Rep. Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.) becomes Speaker. “We are passing the democratic agenda each and every day that we're ...The Hill - Politics -
Biden Tax Increases Won’t Hit Middle Class, Yellen Says
Republicans pressed the Treasury secretary on President Biden’s tax proposals and the fate of the Trump tax cuts that will expire in 2025.The New York Times - Top stories - Joe Biden -
Biden Tax Increases Won’t Hit Middle Class, Yellen Says
Republicans pressed the Treasury secretary on President Biden’s tax proposals and the fate of the Trump tax cuts that will expire in 2025.The New York Times - Business - Joe Biden -
Mulvaney: More government intervention won’t ‘fix’ housing prices
Experience should have taught us by now that more government “fixes” at the local and federal levels will only make the problem worse.The Hill - Politics -
For Truly Envy-Inducing Vacation Pictures, Put the Phone Away
Instead, try a unique point-and-shoot camera and a 360-degree action option. Or, if you’re braver, a drone.The Wall Street Journal - Tech -
Democrats say they'll block an attempt to oust House Speaker Johnson
House Democratic leaders said Tuesday they would support Speaker Mike Johnson, a Republican from Louisiana, if a motion to vacate is called. CBS News congressional correspondent Scott MacFarlane reports from Capitol Hill.CBS News - Top stories -
New Jersey Rep. Donald Payne Jr. dies
Rep. Donald Payne Jr. was well-liked by his colleagues and served as chair and ranking member of the House Subcommittee on Railroads, Pipelines, and Hazardous Materials.Politico - Politics -
Speaker Johnson calls on Biden to visit Columbia amid pro-Palestine protests
Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) is urging President Biden to visit Columbia University and observe the pro-Palestine protests roiling its Manhattan campus after Johnson and a group of GOP lawmakers stopped by the university grounds and denounced the ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden
More from The Hill
-
Partisan gap on abortion 'larger than ever:' Analysis
The divide between Democrats and Republicans on abortion is at its starkest point in years, according to a new survey on the issue that’s poised to play a big role in the 2024 presidential race. There’s a 50-point gap between the two major ...The Hill - Politics - Abortion -
CNN host presses NYC mayor on claims of 'outside agitators' at student protests
CNN anchor Erin Burnett pressed New York City Mayor Eric Adams (D) on his claims of "outside agitators" at the recent pro-Palestinian protests at Columbia University. “Do you have any ability at this point to tell us how many of those were ...The Hill - Politics -
Georgia governor signs controversial Republican-backed bill requiring cash bail for more offenses
Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp (D) signed a controversial bill requiring cash bail for more offenses that require cash bail Wednesday, according to a press release from his office. Senate Bill 63 (SB 3) adds offenses including racketeering, sex ...The Hill - Politics -
JD Vance says he is 'skeptical' Pence's life was in danger on Jan. 6
Sen. J.D. Vance (R-Ohio) said Wednesday he is “skeptical” that former Vice President Pence’s life was endangered during the Jan. 6, 2021, riots at the Capitol. CNN’s Kaitlan Collins asked Vance on “The Source” whether the Ohio Republican had “any ...The Hill - Politics -
GOP hardliners use rare procedural move to block leadership-backed bill
A group of hardline Republicans joined with Democrats in executing a rare procedural gambit on Wednesday that blocked a bill from being voted on in its current form, marking a small but embarrassing blow for GOP leadership. Six Republicans joined ...The Hill - Politics