Sotomayor hits presidential immunity decision in first public comments since new Trump admin

Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor on Wednesday doubled down on her opposition to the presidential immunity decision last summer and expressed concern about public confidence in the high court.

In her first public remarks since President Trump took office about two weeks ago, Sotomayor said she worried that the Supreme Court has departed too far from public sentiment, when asked about dwindling public confidence in the court.

“If we as a court go so much further ahead of people, our legitimacy is going to be questioned," Sotomayor told an audience in Kentucky Wednesday evening.

“I think the immunity case is one of those situations,” she continued. “I don’t think that Americans have accepted that anyone should be above the law in America. Our equality as people was the foundation of our society and of our constitution.”

“I think my court would probably gather more public support if it went a little more slowly in undoing precedent,” she said.

In a 6-3 vote last summer the Supreme Court ruled former presidents enjoy absolute criminal immunity for certain core functions. Other official acts are entitled to a presumption of immunity, Chief Justice John Roberts wrote for the majority.

Sotomayor issued the stinging 30-page dissent, joined by fellow liberal Justices Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson, in which she wrote, “Today’s decision to grant former Presidents criminal immunity reshapes the institution of the Presidency.”

“It makes a mockery of the principle, foundational to our Constitution and system of Government, that no man is above the law,” she wrote at the time.

She reiterated her position at the event Wednesday night.

“Our constitution itself has provisions not exempting the president from criminal activity after an impeachment,” Sotomayor said. "So, I had a hard time with the immunity case. And if we continue going in directions that the public is going to find hard to understand, we’re placing the court at risk.”

Sotomayor said Wednesday she worried that frequent court reversals of long-established legal precedent “creates instability” and contributes to the public questioning “of whether we’re doing things because of legal analysis or because of partisan views.”

Sotomayor stressed that she does not accuse her "colleagues of being partisan” and trusts that they “genuinely have a belief in a certain way of looking at the Constitution.”

“And I understand, in good faith, that they think that that belief better promotes our democracy,” Sotomayor continued. "But whether that’s true or not is irrelevant if people are feeling insecure in the changes that they’re instituting at a pace that they can’t absorb.”

The Associated Press contributed.

Topics

China keeps renminbi steady in first fix since Trump’s tariffs

Traders had expected Beijing to weaken its currency following a week-long market holiday
Financial Times - 1d
Watch live: Fed's Powell gives first remarks under new Trump admin

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell is holding a press conference Wednesday afternoon, the first since President Trump began his second term. Powell, who is expected to serve out the rest of his ...
The Hill - Jan. 29
Trump seeks presidential immunity from any state court civil suit filed against him

Donald Trump wants to stop a lawsuit against his Truth Social company by arguing that, while he's president, he should be immune from any civil suit filed in state court.
ABC News - Jan. 28
Fmr. Trump attorney: Supreme Court went ‘too far’ with immunity decision

Former Trump White House attorney Ty Cobb talks to Kristen Welker about last year's Supreme Court decision on presidential immunity and his perspective on President Trump's early moves in his ...
NBC News - Jan. 24
Trump’s First Presidential Trip, and an American Egg Crisis

Plus, how Kidz Bop grew up.
The New York Times - Jan. 24
Trump's bid to expand presidential power hits its first snag: From the Politics Desk

Welcome to the online version of From the Politics Desk, an evening newsletter that brings you the NBC News Politics team’s latest reporting and analysis from the White House, Capitol Hill and the ...
NBC News - Jan. 23
South Korea's Yoon defends martial law decree in first public appearance since arrest

South Korea’s impeached president has denied that he ordered the military to drag lawmakers out of the National Assembly to prevent them from voting to reject his martial law decree last month, as ...
ABC News - Jan. 21
Trump says he discussed TikTok in first call with Xi since 2021

Conversation between US and Chinese leaders comes days before president-elect’s inauguration
Financial Times - Jan. 18
Biden calls for constitutional amendment on presidential immunity

President Biden on Wednesday said there should be an amendment to the Constitution that makes clear presidents are not immune from crimes committed in office, using his farewell address in part to ...
The Hill - Jan. 16