Shared political views are more likely to result in a job hire
Seven in 10 hiring managers will prioritize candidates who share their political views, according to a new poll.
Resume Builder’s research, as the U.S. presidential election hots up, is timely. The company surveyed 1,000 U.S.-based hiring managers and found that 68% are likely to hire individuals who share similar political views to their own.
One in five say they are unlikely to hire candidates with opposing views, and 64% of hiring managers say that knowing a candidate’s political views is important.
Interestingly, 64% of managers say they are almost always aware (35%) or sometimes aware (29%) of job candidates’ political views. In an interview scenario, there are a number of protected categories which exist thanks to federal and state law prohibitions. These include questions around race, gender, religion, age, or disability, for example.
5 roles to apply for this week
- SAP EWM Consultant, Accenture, Los Angeles
- Senior Payroll Manager, Cherokee Federal, McLean ($150,000 - $175,000 a year)
- Congressional Affairs Manager (Senior Project Manager), International Association of Chiefs of Police, Alexandria
- Business Intelligence Analyst, Booz Allen, Arlington ($54,000 - $123,000)
- Policy Advisor, Arnold & Porter, Washington
But there are currently no federal laws prohibiting political bias in the hiring process. In lieu of a recruiter asking the question of party allegiance, how do hiring managers establish a candidate’s political leanings?
Stacie Haller, chief career advisor at Resume Builder, says that, “A significant number of hiring managers also scrutinize social media and other outlets for clues about a candidate’s age, religion, or other personal characteristics that may introduce bias into the process”.
She adds, “This practice is, of course, unacceptable, and political bias should be viewed with the same seriousness as any other form of bias”.
Increasing polarization
In a fraught domestic political sphere, coupled with divisive geopolitical conflicts, many Americans may feel compelled to share their views publicly, either on social media or through watercooler conversations with colleagues.
“The increasing polarization of our society has forced us to confront these issues in the workplace more than ever before,” Haller notes.
In 2022, the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) conducted a Politics at Work Study, which found that the percentage of U.S. workers saying they’d experienced political affiliation bias had risen by 12% across the previous three years.
“Unfortunately, we’ve seen a real decline in civility when people express their opinions and beliefs, and it’s a barrier to success for employers and their employees,” said SHRM president and CEO Johnny C. Taylor, Jr., SHRM-SCP, of the research.
“This trend has been fueled by the relative anonymity of social media, and it has spilled into our communities and our workplaces. In today’s climate, people are saying, ‘I can't work with you if you don't share my views.’”
This is quicksand territory to navigate for workers and employers alike. And it is made even more opaque by the fact that there is no one size fits all approach to how to deal with it.
Where federal workers may have more protections around political activity (as long as it occurs outside of work), experts point out that broadly, private employers can likely fire an employee based on their political affiliation, without running afoul of federal law.
Private companies may bring their own internal policies to bear on workers who they feel are outspoken. For example, in 2022, Meta used its Respectful Communication Policy to prohibit its employees from posting “opinions or debates about abortion being right or wrong, availability or rights of abortion, and political, religious, and humanitarian views on the topic”.
In April of this year, 28 employees at Google were sacked after staging a sit-in-style protest in the company's California offices, in relation to demands that the company end its contracts with the Israeli government.
Resume Builder’s research found that the hiring managers who were unwilling to hire someone with different political affiliations would do so to avoid potential actions that may reflect poorly on the company (75%), or to avoid a bad culture fit (73%).
“Some managers justify bringing their personal biases into the hiring process by claiming they want candidates who align with the company’s culture and can represent the organization accordingly,” says the company’s Stacie Haller.
Diverse teams matter
However, diversity matters at work, whether that’s across race, ethnicity, or gender––or political viewpoints. Being exposed to those with different views to you can result in better business outcomes, as opposed to existing in an echo chamber-environment where confirmation bias can take over.
Multiple studies support this. Older research from Deloitte identified that as far back as 2017, inclusive teams outperformed their less inclusive peers by 80% in business.
McKinsey’s most recent Diversity Matters report backs this up. It found that companies committed to diversity show “a 39 percent increased likelihood of outperformance for those in the top quartile of ethnic representation versus the bottom quartile”. If your team isn’t diverse, there isn't a regularly actioned DE&I policy in place, or you’re in an organization where your political stance is hindering your career growth or professional relationships, it could be time to find something new.
Looking for your next opportunity? Browse thousands of open roles via The Hill Jobs Board
Date: |
-
The Wall Street Journal - Business
Will AI Make Job Recruiting More Efficient---but Less Fair?
We asked readers what they think about companies that are relying more on artificial intelligence to screen candidates. Are the trade-offs acceptable?2 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
Farage says Tory brand is ‘bust’ as other Reform UK speeches target immigrants, drag queens, vegans and more – UK politics live
Lee Anderson, Richard Tice and Nigel Farage give speeches at Reform party conference. Richard Partington is the Guardian’s economics correspondent . UK national debt has hit 100% of the country’s ...16 minutes ago - United Kingdom -
Financial Times - World
Immigration and job creation
The labour market is softer than it appears11 hours ago -
GameSpot - Tech
Like A Dragon: Pirate Yakuza In Hawaii
Check out the reveal trailer for Like A Dragon: Pirate Yakuza in Hawaii shown off during RGG Summit 2024. The game comes out February 28th, 2025.6 hours ago -
BBC News - Top stories
Work begins on bridges to give aerial views of bison
The four bridges will expand the area the animals can roam by hundreds of acres.11 hours ago -
NBC News - Politics
Undecided voters, set in their views of Trump, now weigh backing Harris
Kenneth Hauck wasn’t sure how he would vote when the race between former President Donald Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris was just a hypothetical scenario.7 hours ago -
CBS Sports - Sports
Billy Napier's imminent firing prompts another big question: Who holds power to hire Florida's next coach?
Napier's time leading the Gators is running out, but questions have emerged over who ultimately decides on the replacement56 minutes ago -
Financial Times - Business
Mercedes-Benz shares fall after profit warning
German carmaker lowers full-year outlook on weakness in Chinese demand7 hours ago -
Financial Times - Business
European stocks close lower as carmaker shares slide
11 hours ago - Europe
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Eight Democrats vote to ax Biden’s EV rule
Eight Democrats voted with House Republicans in favor of overturning a Biden administration rule that’s expected to force automakers to make a significant portion of their fleet electric. The ...32 minutes ago - Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
It’s almost too late to protect our elections from AI — Congress must act now
As AI becomes more widespread, the potential for electoral mischief will only grow.41 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Microsoft strikes deal to reopen Three Mile Island nuclear plant
Nuclear energy operator Constellation Energy will reopen the Three Mile Island facility in Pennsylvania, the site of a 1979 partial nuclear meltdown, as part of a deal with Microsoft to power data ...43 minutes ago - Microsoft -
The Hill - Politics
Robinson won't be at Trump's North Carolina rally Saturday
North Carolina gubernatorial candidate Mark Robinson (R) will not be in attendance when former President Trump rallies supporters in the state on Saturday, a source told The Hill. Trump is ...48 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Stevie Wonder planning pre-election tour
Grammy-winning artist Stevie Wonder recently announced a 10-stop tour across the U.S. ahead of Election Day, now less than two months away. The concert tour — dubbed "Sing Your Song! As We Fix Our ...49 minutes ago