Senate Republicans to save millions of dollars on ads — thanks to the FEC
Senate Republicans are preparing to significantly escalate their plans to exploit a campaign-finance loophole that will allow them to save millions of dollars on TV advertising, irking Democrats who hoped federal regulators would block the GOP plan.
Republicans in late July began quietly piloting their new strategy: running campaign ads for a candidate, framed as a fundraising plea, to get cheaper ad rates and avoid awkward content restrictions. Democrats, furious at what they saw as the crossing of ethical and legal lines, asked the Federal Election Commission to weigh in.
At a contentious meeting Thursday, the agency deadlocked 3-3 on whether these joint fundraising ads should be permitted — effectively allowing the practice to continue.
With no restrictions imposed, Republicans, who have been facing a deep cash disparity with Democrats, are now preparing to turn what was a smaller-scale effort into a key component of their closing TV ad strategy.
The National Republican Senatorial Committee and its candidates already set up these fundraising vehicles in several states — and they added Wisconsin, Pennsylvania and Nevada in recent weeks. Those committees have already been collecting money for a flood of the new, cheaper “fundraising” ads.
The financial reality is that Republicans, facing a significant money gap, need this kind of spending workaround the most. But Democrats, who, “unlike Republicans …asked for clear guidance from the FEC” and did not receive it, now say they will be forced into using the tactic, too.
“Moving forward the DSCC is committed to ensuring our campaigns do not operate at a disadvantage in the closing weeks of the campaign and will utilize the same tactics that are being employed by Republicans regarding joint committee advertising," Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee spokesperson David Bergstein said in a statement.
And Republicans took a victory lap: “Senate Democrats’ attempt to limit party speech backfired spectacularly. This is a rough day for the DSCC," said Ryan Dollar, the NRSC's general counsel.
Democratic candidates have raised far more than Republicans and can purchase ads at the cheaper rate offered to candidates. Republicans rely more heavily on independent expenditures from their campaign arm and allied super PACs, which have to pay much more per ad.
The NRSC has tried to overcome the deficit by using so-called “hybrid ads” in which the party and candidates split the cost — and receive the candidate rate. But half of those ads must be devoted to a national party or issue, often leading to clunky messaging. And the candidate’s campaign must foot half the bill.
The NRSC was searching for ways to more effectively narrow Democrats’ massive money advantage within the constraints of campaign finance law. Dollar had been advocating for deploying a new strategy. The plan: air political ads through what's known as a "joint fundraising committee" — a group that raises money for several groups, such as party committees and individual campaigns, at the same time.
That would allow the NRSC and other party committees to cover nearly the full cost of the ads, while keeping the focus on the specific race. All the committee has to do is insert a donation line at the end of the ad, turning a campaign ad into a fundraising one.
As financial disparities mounted, the NRSC decided to try Dollar's idea.
They started testing the idea in Montana at the end of July, with ads run by a joint fundraising committee helping GOP Senate candidate Tim Sheehy. One ad from the group, which has spent $2.8 million so far, is narrated entirely by Sheehy. He begins by discussing his military service and ends with the phrase “join my team, give now.” A QR code that leads to a fundraising page briefly appears in the closing seconds of the spot.
In mid-September, the NRSC and its candidates began running similar fundraising campaign ads in Maryland and Arizona, with joint fundraising committees spending nearly $3 million so far on TV in the former and $500,000 in the latter.
“This is just a really blatant attempt to bypass contribution limits, and it's just the latest attempt by Republicans to further dismantle our campaign finance system,” Tiffany Muller, president of End Citizens United, a liberal campaign finance reform group, said in an interview Thursday. “This big outside money is directly undercutting the power of small-dollar donors that are investing in candidates.”
The GOP only needs to flip two seats to guarantee control of the Senate, and they are favored to do so. But party leaders have been openly warning for weeks that their cash deficit with Democrats could lead to them losing winnable seats. And in some states, the disparities between the two parties have only grown more stark as Senate Democrats raise tens of millions of dollars from small-dollar donors in the final months.
The party committees can direct donors toward these joint fundraising committees, which can accept much larger checks. They benefit candidates who raise more from large donors and make attracting small donors less necessary.
In the FEC’s Thursday meeting, Democratic commissioners expressed concern that allowing joint fundraising committees to run advertisements with short advertising solicitations would encourage them to push the boundaries with ads that have no plausible fundraising benefit.
“There's no end limit here, right? Like, somebody could put up a QR code for a quarter of a second and have it be completely transparent, and then I don't know how my colleagues would vote in an enforcement matter,” said Commissioner Dara Lindenbaum, a Democrat.
The continued practice could have implications far beyond this election cycle as campaigns and their joint fundraising committees get more creative.
Those were among the concerns of campaign finance advocates ahead of the FEC’s decision. Saurav Ghosh, director of federal campaign finance reform at the Campaign Legal Center, was one of those who had submitted comments urging regulators to say that the tactic should be impermissible.
“As much as this appears to be kind of a technical issue and kind of in the weeds of campaign finance, I think the ramifications could actually be quite huge,” Ghosh said.
Date: | |
Tag: | Republican Party |
Topics
-
Business - Inc.
Musk Super PAC Gets Warning Letter About Million Dollar Giveaways, CNN Reports
5 hours ago - Elon Musk -
World - Yahoo News
Ukraine's Zelensky thanks G7 states for latest military aid
6 hours ago - Ukraine -
Tech - The New York Times
Bots Linked to China Target Republican House and Senate Candidates, Microsoft Says
7 hours ago - China -
Politics - Politico
Senate Republicans’ strangely uneven spending map
October 6 -
Sports - ESPN
Player ratings: Liverpool stay unbeaten in Champions League thanks to Núñez winner
5 hours ago - UEFA Champions League -
Politics - NBC News
New Justice Department scrutiny of Musk's million dollar giveaway plan
5 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Trump campaign files FEC complaint over Labour staff campaigning for Harris
16 hours ago - Donald Trump -
World - The Guardian
Elon Musk’s pro-Trump Pac pouring millions into Facebook ads instead of X
Yesterday - Facebook -
Politics - The Hill
Trump, Harris race draws millions of dollars to politics betting sites
Yesterday - Donald Trump -
Top stories - NBC News
Some Juul users are receiving thousands of dollars as part of a $300M class action settlement
Yesterday -
World - Yahoo News
Germany's Scholz thanks Qatar for mediation efforts in Gaza war
Yesterday -
Top stories - ABC News
Trump and allies are pouring millions into anti-trans election ads as election nears
Yesterday - Donald Trump -
World - The Guardian
US presidential election briefing: Harris courts Republicans with Liz Cheney as Trump says he was ‘saved’ by God
2 days ago - Donald Trump -
World - The Guardian
Israel claims Hezbollah bunker under Beirut hospital holds millions of dollars
2 days ago - Israel -
Business - CNBC
Biden extends student loan payment pause by 6 months for 8 million SAVE plan borrowers
2 days ago - Joe Biden -
Politics - The Hill
Cook shifts Pennsylvania Senate to 'toss-up,' Nebraska to 'lean Republican'
2 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
Republican senator pushes back against KOSA 'lies'
2 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
Top Republican super PAC jumps into Nebraska Senate race
2 days ago -
Top stories - The New York Times
Door-Knocks, Texts, and Ads, Ads, Ads: Life on the Swing-State Battlefield
3 days ago -
Tech - The Wall Street Journal
Electric Motors Are About to Get a Major Upgrade Thanks to Benjamin Franklin
5 days ago -
Top stories - BBC News
Packer thankful for 'tough' World Cup draw
5 days ago - World Cup -
Politics - The Hill
Senate Republicans raise questions after funds for disaster loans exhausted
5 days ago - Republican Party -
Politics - NBC News
Donald Trump thanks Melania Trump during the Al Smith dinner
5 days ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - NBC News
Republican Sam Brown swings away in Nevada Senate debate amid polling deficit
6 days ago -
World - The Guardian
Netflix to double profits after adding millions of subscribers in three months
6 days ago - Netflix -
Top stories - The New York Times
Inside the Secretive $700 Million Ad-Testing Factory for Kamala Harris
6 days ago - Kamala Harris -
Top stories - NBC News
Playing out this Sunday: A tale of two QBs nobody wanted
6 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
Senate Dems’ campaign arm launching ad campaign targeting Black voters
October 16 -
Politics - The Hill
Senate Republicans pump brakes on year-end omnibus
October 16 - Republican Party -
Top stories - CBS News
Trump campaign has spent millions on anti-trans ads
October 15 - Donald Trump -
Sports - Yahoo Sports
Yankees chase Guardians ace Tanner Bibee early, secure 6-3 win for 2-0 ALCS series lead
October 15 - MLB -
Top stories - BBC News
No 10 denies Swift tickets were 'thank you' to Starmer
October 15 -
Politics - The Hill
Democratic groups launch $2.5M ad buy attacking Republicans over reproductive access
October 15 - Republican Party -
Politics - The Hill
Robinson lashes out at Republican senator amid tensions over campaign
October 14 -
Politics - The Hill
Harris campaign touts Republican Mesa mayor's support in new Arizona ad
October 14 -
Politics - The Hill
Tim Scott mulls run to lead Senate Republicans' campaign arm
October 14
More from Politico
-
Politics - Politico
The POLITICO race to watch: Nebraska’s 2nd
Yesterday -
Politics - Politico
House GOP braces for bitter fight over the power to oust a speaker
Yesterday - House -
Politics - Politico
Internal GOP poll shows trouble for Peltola in Alaska
2 days ago -
Politics - Politico
Law enforcement missed ‘pivotal moments’ to engage Trump gunman, House panel finds
2 days ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - Politico
What if it's President Harris, but a GOP Senate? That's her allies' fear.
3 days ago
Latest in Politics
-
Politics - The Hill
L.A. Times editorial editor quits after owner blocks plans to endorse Harris
57 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
4 takeaways from Harris's CNN town hall
1 hour ago -
Politics - NBC News
Kamala Harris calls Trump a 'fascist' as she argues he's 'dangerous' and unfit for office
1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - CBS News
After John Kelly's remarks, Harris says she believes Trump is a fascist
1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Boeing machinists reject new contract on 41st day of strike
1 hour ago