Senate duo pushes for warrant requirement in foreign spy bill
A bipartisan Senate duo is pushing to require a warrant before accessing information on Americans obtained by the government through foreign spying activities, reigniting a battle that failed with a tie vote in the House.
The amendment from Senate Judiciary Chair Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) and Sen. Kevin Cramer (R-N.D.) largely mirrors a similar amendment seeking to add a warrant requirement to Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA).
Section 702 only permits the government to spy on foreigners located abroad. But Americans who communicate with targets have those interactions swept up in the course of operations.
A contentious debate on the warrant provision led to a 212-212 vote in the House. While proponents see a warrant requirement as a way to protect Americans’ Fourth Amendment rights, opponents — including the White House and the intelligence community — say it would gut the spy tool and stop law enforcement from acting on information in real time.
“I have sat through numerous classified briefings on Section 702 queries and listened carefully to the government’s concerns about having to obtaining court approval in order to review the contents of Americans’ communications,” Durbin said in a statement.
“Our bipartisan amendment accounts for these concerns by providing exceptions to the warrant requirement for emergencies or cybersecurity attacks, or where an American consents to the search. This will ensure that there will not be any delays that jeopardize national security. But if the government wants to spy on the private communications of Americans, they should be required to get approval from a judge — just as our Founders intended.”
The intelligence community has suggested the provision would be unworkable, and the Biden administration swiftly came out swinging against the amendment, calling it “a reckless policy choice contrary to the key lessons of 9/11 and not grounded in any constitutional requirement or statute.”
“The amendment outright bars the government from gaining access to lawfully collected information using terms associated with U.S. persons. Exceptions to that prohibition are narrow and unworkable. They are insufficient to protect our national security,” the Biden administration wrote in a one-pager that was distributed to senators.
“The emergency exception for imminent threats of death and serious bodily harm is so narrowly limited that the criteria would almost never be met. Without reviewing the communications returned by a query, an analyst would not know whether a threat meets the exception.”
Rep. Jim Himes (Conn.), the top Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee, noted that in many cases, agencies like the FBI are using the 702 database to ferret out information on potential threats — information that would likely be insufficient to get a traditional warrant.
“Say a member of Congress has been discussed by Chinese intelligence officers. There’s no real worry that the member of Congress is engaged in a crime. But obviously, our intelligence community would like to know why Chinese intelligence officers are talking about a member of Congress,” Himes said when the House was set to consider the warrant requirement.
“If we pick up that an ISIS leader is talking to an individual in Los Angeles, who is by definition a U.S. person, we have no idea why that conversation is occurring. It could be a family member or a friend. So you cannot go to a judge and say, ‘We have no idea why this communication is occurring, but we want you to issue us a probable cause warrant.’ That is why the administration says the passage of a warrant requirement would shut this program down.”
A U.S. intelligence official offered another example, citing a case where the CIA was able to alert partners of an incoming shipment of fentanyl precursors — information they gleaned just 48 hours before it arrived at the U.S. port and information they would not have derived without reviewing information from American sources.
Still, some argue the provision is needed to curb abuse of the 702 database, particularly after the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court found the FBI improperly used the tool roughly 278,000 times over several years.
“Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act has been abused and any reauthorization demands we further protect Americans’ Fourth Amendment rights. Preventing the intrusive and all too often corrupt federal government from warrantless access to private communications is crucial to preserving civil liberties and the Fourth Amendment rights of every American,” Cramer said.
FBI queries of U.S. citizens have dropped dramatically in recent years after the agency instituted reforms and made a technical fix to the search platform, which previously opted agents into searching the 702 database.
Intelligence leaders, however, have said the FISA 702 reauthorization bill makes substantial reforms that will shift the program.
The bill includes a number of reforms, including one that would drastically limit the number of personnel who can sign off on any queries of the 702 database involving those in the U.S., and another that would require an after-the-fact audit for all U.S. person searches.
"It is best understood as the most comprehensive set of reforms in the history of the 702 program. This is a true reform bill that will change the way we do business, especially the FBI, in a way that will be more protective of civil liberties and privacy," a senior Justice Department official previously told The Hill.
Updated: 5:36 p.m.
Date: |
Filter
-
Georgia Bill Targeting ‘Foreign Interests’ Draws Protests
Opponents of the measure, which resembles a Russian law that Moscow has used to crack down on dissidents, say it could undermine efforts for Georgia to join the European Union.The New York Times - World -
Why are Georgians protesting against a ‘foreign agents’ bill?
Violent police crackdown follows nightly protests by thousands opposed to law seen as anti-democratic and pro-Russia. Europe live – latest updatesWatchdogs and western governments have condemned a police crackdown on protesters in Georgia who are ...The Guardian - World -
Georgia governor signs controversial Republican-backed bill requiring cash bail for more offenses
Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp (D) signed a controversial bill requiring cash bail for more offenses that require cash bail Wednesday, according to a press release from his office. Senate Bill 63 (SB 3) adds offenses including racketeering, sex ...The Hill - Politics -
Senate eyes finish line for House-passed foreign aid package
Politico - Politics -
Senate advances House-passed foreign aid package toward final passage
Politico - Politics -
House passes Israel cash, sending full foreign aid package to Senate
Politico - Politics - Israel -
GOP senator calls for deporting certain foreign student protesters
Sen. Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.) called for the U.S. government to revoke the visas given to international students who are Hamas sympathizers and deport them as college protests continue nationwide. “You cannot go around yelling ‘I am Hamas’ or ...The Hill - Politics -
Georgia condemned for crackdown on protesters opposing ‘foreign agents’ bill
EU leads calls for halt to escalating violence after police use water cannon, teargas and stun grenades against demonstrators. Western politicians and diplomats have called for a halt to spiralling violence in Georgia after security forces used ...The Guardian - World -
In Russia's Backyard, Georgians Protest Against Moscow-Inspired 'Foreign Agents' Bill
Government opponents say proposals for a restrictive new political-funding law represent a Russian ploy to weaken growing ties between the ex-Soviet state and Europe.The Wall Street Journal - World - Russia -
The Senate Republicans who backed moving foreign aid forward after earlier opposition
Politico - Politics - Republican Party
More from The Hill
-
Partisan gap on abortion 'larger than ever:' Analysis
The divide between Democrats and Republicans on abortion is at its starkest point in years, according to a new survey on the issue that’s poised to play a big role in the 2024 presidential race. There’s a 50-point gap between the two major ...The Hill - Politics - Abortion -
CNN host presses NYC mayor on claims of 'outside agitators' at student protests
CNN anchor Erin Burnett pressed New York City Mayor Eric Adams (D) on his claims of "outside agitators" at the recent pro-Palestinian protests at Columbia University. “Do you have any ability at this point to tell us how many of those were ...The Hill - Politics -
Georgia governor signs controversial Republican-backed bill requiring cash bail for more offenses
Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp (D) signed a controversial bill requiring cash bail for more offenses that require cash bail Wednesday, according to a press release from his office. Senate Bill 63 (SB 3) adds offenses including racketeering, sex ...The Hill - Politics -
JD Vance says he is 'skeptical' Pence's life was in danger on Jan. 6
Sen. J.D. Vance (R-Ohio) said Wednesday he is “skeptical” that former Vice President Pence’s life was endangered during the Jan. 6, 2021, riots at the Capitol. CNN’s Kaitlan Collins asked Vance on “The Source” whether the Ohio Republican had “any ...The Hill - Politics -
GOP hardliners use rare procedural move to block leadership-backed bill
A group of hardline Republicans joined with Democrats in executing a rare procedural gambit on Wednesday that blocked a bill from being voted on in its current form, marking a small but embarrassing blow for GOP leadership. Six Republicans joined ...The Hill - Politics