Sanders’s long COVID funding bill misses opportunity to aid a similar chronic condition
Sen. Bernie Sanders’ (I-Vt.) recent call for $10 billion in research grants over ten years for long COVID is a worthy initiative, yet we are deeply disappointed the senator is limiting his focus to long COVID. Millions of victims of infection-associated chronic conditions have been waiting decades for the federal government to fund research to improve diagnosis and develop therapies.
A handful of diseases that, like long COVID, are chronic and debilitating, each of which affects the central nervous system and result from infection, have been neglected. All of them existed prior to the COVID-19 outbreak of 2020. The most neglected of these is also the most common and among the most disabling of all: ME/CFS. This is a compromise name for Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome. Formerly known as ME, the severity of the illness was dismissed and victims were ridiculed in the popular press after CDC renamed the disease “chronic fatigue syndrome” in 1988.
We ask that Sanders specifically name ME/CFS in his bill and include a generous budget for ME/CFS research, one commensurate with the burden of the illness. In spite of the fact that ME/CFS is common, afflicting 1.3 percent of the American population and an estimated 67 million people globally, federal funding levels to study it have been shockingly low. Before COVID-19 arrived, the economic cost of ME/CFS was over $36 billion a year.
One reason for this neglect has been the public’s failure to understand how high their chances of acquiring ME/CFS are and just how serious it actually is. Impaired cognition, a major feature of the disease, results in a devastating loss of mental acuity that interferes with the ability to maintain a semblance of normal life. ME/CFS victims find they cannot exert themselves for the simplest demands of daily life without heightening all their symptoms. Indeed, patients aren’t “tired” — they’re often too weak to stand or walk unaided. Another crippling problem is a lack of blood flow to the brain, a serious circulation defect that can prevent patients from remaining upright without blacking out.
Morbidity studies suggest the physical suffering in ME/CFS is enormous, worse than multiple sclerosis or congestive heart failure, for instance. Recovery is vanishingly rare, leaving patients to struggle for decades.
Any discussion of the toll of ME/CFS would be remiss without mentioning the surfeit of suicide observed in this population. Final letters from patients typically invoke the specter of permanent suffering without medical care.
A tantalizing piece of the ME/CFS puzzle has been its history of discrete outbreaks all over the world during the last century. One of the earliest occurred in Los Angeles in 1934. Two-hundred out of 1,500 members of the Los Angeles County General Hospital staff fell ill, most of them permanently. Outbreaks in Iceland, New Zealand, the UK, and the U.S. followed. A combination of indifference, dismissal of patients’ concerns and inadequate technology resulted in a failure to identify the responsible viruses. Ultimately, the medical establishment largely ignored the surge in ME/CFS in the mid-1980s — effectively disappearing an epidemic.
Long COVID entered the picture after the COVID-19 pandemic began in 2020. Doctors and patients themselves began comparing the symptom constellation to that of ME/CFS and noting striking similarities. As a result, some scientists, medical professionals and long COVID patients have suggested that ME/CFS is a “subset” of long COVID or, more confusingly, that some cases of long COVID actually are ME/CFS.
The fact is, it’s unclear how similar these maladies are at the biochemical level. We need to find out. SARS-COV-2 has been found to persist in the body long after the acute infection. If persistent virus causes most cases of long COVID, eradicating it from patients has little chance of helping ME/CFS patients. SARS-COV-2 could not possibly have caused any of the multi-millions of cases of ME/CFS prior to 2020.
As Monica Bertagnolli, MD, the new NIH director said recently, “…I don't think you can ever assume that one virus is going to act like another. Certainly, every virus that we know of seems to have a different effect in the body long term.”
Nevertheless, there are some intriguing overlaps in symptoms, suggesting that physiological features of the disruptions occurring in these diseases may be shared. New drugs that can improve symptoms such as ones affecting brain function, muscle function or circulation, for example — might benefit both types of patients. But for any underlying causes that differ between ME/CFS and long COVID, disease-specific remedies will be necessary.
Despite decades since the ME/CFS outbreaks, no FDA-approved drugs are available for treatment. The NIH, which currently has an annual budget of $48 billion, has provided ME/CFS researchers with between $5 to 17 million in each of the last ten years. These sums are so puny they’re considered “budget dust” by government officials.
Advocates for earmarked funds for ME/CFS have been stymied in the past by NIH’s claims going back to the 1980s that scientists aren’t interested in working on ME/CFS. But the long COVID field burgeoned with an enormous influx of researchers when public and private funds became available. The ME/CFS field will also blossom when adequate funds are made available.
Congress has the ability to set medical agendas through recognition of serious public health problems. As witnessed during the AIDS epidemic, federal health agencies were awarded billions of dollars for AIDS research.
Sadly, when $10 billion is on the table for long COVID research, another prevalent infection-associated illness — ME/CFS — is missing in Sanders’ proposed bill. We think that’s a serious mistake since, by law, if ME/CFS is not directly specified by name in the bill, NIH will have a mandate to fund long COVID to the exclusion of ME/CFS, a viral illness that arrived decades before SARS-COV-2. Medical ethics and economic realities dictate that the millions of unwilling members of the ME/CFS community can’t be put on a shelf and abandoned for yet another decade.
We appeal to Sanders to include in his bill substantial funding for what we must now call “ pre-pandemic ME/CFS” and specify a budget commensurate with this disease’s toll. Hundreds of millions more dollars are needed to restore health to the millions who are missing their previously productive lives. It’s long past time for Congress to address a major chronic illness that does not go away on its own, causes unspeakable suffering and threatens everyone.
Maureen Hanson is a scientist who directs an ME/CFS research center and Hillary Johnson is a journalist who has chronicled the history of the disease since the 1980s.
Date: | |
Tag: | Covid |
Topics
Filter
-
Notes 'missing' after funeral handed to Covid team
Notes of Stormont's first Executive meeting after Bobby Storey funeral were requested seven times.BBC News - Top stories - Covid -
Sanders: Protests ‘may be Biden's Vietnam’
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) said that the protests on college campuses over Israel’s war against Hamas could be President Biden’s Vietnam War, making the comparison to the anti-war protests in the 1960s while also offering support for the ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
U.S. Approved More Weapons for Ukraine. Now It’s a Race Against Time.
President Biden and Ukraine’s allies have invoked a sense of urgency over weapon deliveries. But there are logistical hurdles, and Ukraine has little time to lose.The New York Times - Top stories - Ukraine -
How Stormzy's #Merky FC is providing opportunities in south London
British rapper Stormzy shows BBC Sport around his new #Merky FC venue, which brings together music, gaming and football for young people.BBC News - Top stories -
Middle East Crisis: Trade and Diplomatic Moves Deepen Israel’s Isolation
Turkey’s decision to suspend trade with Israel came after some countries downgraded or cut ties. But key allies including the U.S. remain supportive.The New York Times - World - Israel -
West Saratoga Is a Kentucky Derby Long Shot. But So Was His Trainer.
Larry Demeritte, the Derby’s first Black trainer in 35 years, is a man who understands this is all about much more than him.The New York Times - Sports -
Denmark increases defense spending in view of Russian long-term war
Yahoo News - World - Russia -
A NATO country says it could join Ukraine's war with Russia if 2 conditions are met
Yahoo News - World - Ukraine -
Why you should purchase long-term care insurance at 65 years old, according to experts
There are several reasons to purchase long-term care insurance at 65. Here's why experts say you should apply now.CBS News - Top stories -
Legrand Misses Forecasts But Keeps Outlook
Legrand posted lower profits for its first quarter following a slowdown in the construction sector, but confirmed its financial targets for the year.The Wall Street Journal - World
More from The Hill
-
How to ensure that Biden’s environmental and labor regulations survive
Even if courts were going to look favorably on some of the Biden regulations, there is a great deal that a potential second Trump administration could do to subvert the rules.The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Hope Hicks takes the witness stand in Trump’s hush money trial: Live updates
Former President Trump’s ex-political adviser Hope Hicks has taken the witness stand in his hush money trial in Manhattan on Friday. Hicks, once a close confidant of Trump’s when he ran in 2016 and after he entered the White House, has testified ...The Hill - Politics -
Confusion and trade rules are speed bumps for Biden’s EV goals
If widespread EV adoption is truly a priority, then America’s trade policies, some of which Biden inherited and some of which are his own, need another look.The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
De Niro to Biden on Trump: 'Every chance you get, go at him'
Robert De Niro says President Biden should "keep up the fight" against former President Trump, advising the commander in chief to "go at him hard." "Keep at him," De Niro said when asked by Stephanie Ruhle on MSNBC's "The 11th Hour" Thursday about ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
UN ambassador condemns Gershkovich detention
United Nations Ambassador Linda Thomas-Greenfield condemned the detention of Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich, who has been in Russian prison for more than a year. “We gather here on the eve of World Press Freedom Day, an opportunity ...The Hill - Politics - United Nations