Rudy Giuliani’s Florida condo, World Series rings on the line in latest trial

Rudy Giuliani will again square off in court against two Georgia election workers Thursday, this time seeking to keep his Florida condominium and other prized possessions from the women who won a $146 million defamation judgment against him.

Giuliani faces trial in New York over whether his Palm Beach, Fla., condo, which he claims as his permanent residence, must be turned over to Ruby Freeman and Shaye Moss, who he has falsely asserted for years engaged in widespread 2020 election fraud.

A federal judge will also weigh whether the ex-New York City mayor must cough up three New York Yankees World Series rings, which Giuliani says he gifted to his son, Andrew, and therefore are not his to give up.

Giuliani, his son and two other witnesses could take to the stand during the bench trial, which could last three days. It comes after a more than yearlong effort by the two former election workers to collect their multimillion-dollar judgment.

Though U.S. District Judge Lewis Liman already ordered Giuliani to turn over most of his assets, the judge has yet to decide the fate of the condo and rings.

The upcoming trial over those assets caps a month of legal losses for Giuliani. He was held in contempt by two different courts last week — in Manhattan for failing to turn over evidence about his assets, and in Washington for continuing to spread lies about the election workers.

Giuliani’s contempt in New York set his defense back before the trial even began.

Liman, who presides over both, ruled that he will draw an adverse inference against the former New York City mayor and prevent him from offering certain evidence at the trial.

That evidence includes Giuliani’s change in service providers, like doctors and lawyers, when he purportedly moved his permanent residence to Florida, as well as texts or emails proving the move Giuliani failed to timely produce.

Liman said he would take notice of the “gaps” caused by Giuliani’s failure. Giuliani’s attorney warned it would effectively be the death penalty in his fight to retain control of his roughly $3.5 million Florida condo, though Liman said the sanctions were “narrower.”

The judge has also issued an order preventing Giuliani from calling as witnesses his longtime friend, Monsignor Alan Placa, and his spokesperson, Ted Goodman.

The ex-mayor will be able to call Maria Ryan, another of his employees, to testify about his purported relocation from New York to Florida. If Giuliani successfully declares the condo his homestead, it would shield the property from being seized to satisfy a portion of the tens of millions of dollars he owes Freeman and Moss.

Giuliani has asserted losing the condo effectively would make him homeless.

He has already been forced to turn over his roughly $5 million Manhattan apartment, a Mercedes-Benz convertible and other prized possessions, like luxury watches. The election workers in recent weeks have said they’re still trying to secure some of the assets.

World Series rings from 1996, 1999 and 2000, which Giuliani says he was gifted by former Yankees owner George Steinbrenner, are also in dispute at this week’s trial.

However, Giuliani claims they were meant for his son, Andrew. The elder Giuliani testified during a Dec. 27 deposition he told Steinbrenner the rings would eventually be his son’s and that he made it official at a birthday celebration six or seven years ago. Court filings show a years-old photo of Giuliani’s son with the rings.

"I made a little ceremony. I'd given it to him,” Giuliani said. “I said, ‘They are now yours. These are your rings. I don't know what I'm keeping them for. They belong to you.’”

Lawyers for Freeman and Moss argue the father-son duo have provided little evidence beyond the testimony and note the elder Giuliani listed the rings among his assets as part of his bankruptcy estate.

The rings are currently in Andrew Giuliani’s possession, stored in the bedroom closet of his New York City apartment, according to his lawyers. Liman considered keeping the rings in the court’s possession.

Andrew Giuliani could take the stand as well as a years-long acquaintance, Sean Kalin, he said will confirm the rings were gifted.

The elder Giuliani has repeatedly attacked the election workers’ legal team and his judges, portraying himself as the victim of political persecution. His attorney wrote in court filings this week that he is being treated differently because he “challenged the 2020 election.”

The Hill requested comment from Goodman, Giuliani’s spokesperson.

In particular, Giuliani has criticized the judge for refusing to delay Thursday’s trial until after Trump’s inauguration so Giuliani can attend.

“The Court's prejudicial actions is to deny Defendant a fair trial,” Giuliani’s lawyer wrote.

Topics

Giuliani Fails to Appear for Trial That Will Decide Fate of Florida Home

The former mayor of New York City is at risk of forfeiting his sole remaining home, a Palm Beach apartment, to election workers he defamed after the 2020 vote.
The New York Times - 17m
Rudy Giuliani fails to show for trial to allocate property in defamation case

Trial, to decide if he has to turn over Florida condo and World Series rings for $148.1 defamation award, was delayed. Rudy Giuliani ’s trial over whether he must turn over his Florida condo and ...
The Guardian - 41m
Fate of Rudy Giuliani's condo and World Series rings to be decided in court

Rudy Giuliani was set to be back in court Thursday for a trial to determine ownership of some of his most valuable assets — a Florida condo and New York Yankees World Series rings — but something ...
NBC News - 6h
Rudy Giuliani Is Held in Contempt of Court in Defamation Case

Rudolph W. Giuliani, the former mayor of New York City, has failed to turn over his assets to two Georgia poll workers who won a defamation lawsuit against him.
The New York Times - Jan. 7
Judge finds Rudy Giuliani in contempt of court in defamation case

A judge found the former Trump lawyer in contempt for not complying with orders to turn over information about his assets to two former Georgia election workers he defamed.
NBC News - Jan. 6
Rudy Giuliani found in contempt of court

A judge has found Rudy Giuliani in contempt of court for failing to properly respond to requests for information in response to a $148 million defamation judgment granted to two Georgia election ...
CBS News - Jan. 6
Rudy Giuliani, Slow to Transfer Assets to Election Workers, Could Be Held in Contempt

The former mayor of New York City could be held in contempt of court after failing to fully comply with orders to surrender millions of dollars in assets to election workers he defamed.
The New York Times - Jan. 4
Judge to decide whether to hold Rudy Giuliani in contempt of court

Former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani is expected to be at a court hearing in New York on Friday about whether he should be found in contempt of court, an appearance the longtime ally of ...
NBC News - Jan. 3