Republicans hold the key to depolarizing the climate issue
Climate advocates are alarmed by President Trump’s return to the White House. But Republicans may hold the key to bridging the partisan gap on climate solutions.
Consider what’s happening in Republican states. The top three states for the number of new solar panel installations include not only California but also Republican-led Florida and Texas. The top three states generating wind energy are Texas, Iowa and Oklahoma.
In Wyoming, Republican Gov. Mark Gordon is promoting climate-friendly policies of wind, solar, and nuclear energy, alongside technologies to remove atmospheric carbon while generating coal-powered energy. And Republicans have been instrumental in utilizing the vast incentives for renewable energy from the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022, which have disproportionately benefited Republican states.
Our research shows that Republican leadership can reduce partisan divisions on climate change solutions more effectively than Democratic leadership.
Here is why: Democratic and Republican voters both take cues from their party’s political leaders. Although Democratic voters are somewhat less supportive of Republican-led climate solutions than Democratic-led solutions, they do not oppose them outright. Among Republican voters, however, Republican leadership can be transformative in driving support for solutions to climate change.
In a national experiment, we asked survey respondents to consider one of two climate policy proposals. One was a national cap and trade policy, like those that exist in several states. The other was a tax on carbon emissions like the one favored by economists from across the political spectrum.
We introduced a key experimental manipulation. Depending on random assignment, we told some people that Democratic members of Congress proposed the policy and that Republican members opposed it. For these people, 83 percent of Democratic survey respondents supported the policy but only 49 percent of Republicans did, a 34-point gap.
We told other people that Republican members of Congress proposed the same and that Democratic members opposed it. Now, Democratic support dipped to 68 percent while Republican support increased to 69 percent. The partisan divide on the specific proposal vanished.
In other words, our experiment shows that Republican leadership can depolarize climate policy. And such leadership may not be unrealistic.
In Congress, 18 Republican members wrote Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) last summer declaring their collective support for not repealing the clean energy tax credits in the Inflation Reduction Act. They stated the act has “spurred innovation, incentivized investment, and created good jobs in many parts of the country.”
Beyond support for these incentives, Republicans are also leading states in developing climate solutions. Gordon, for instance, spearheads the Western Governors’ Association’s “Decarbonizing the West” initiative. This coalition includes leaders from states such as California, Oregon, Colorado and Kansas. The approach features all-of-the-above strategies that can help Western states eliminate their total output of carbon emissions.
Decarbonization bills at the state level passed during the first Trump administration further support the idea that bipartisan action on climate solutions is possible.
A study by political scientists Renae Marshall and Matthew Burgess of 418 major state-level enacted decarbonization bills from 2015-2020 found that nearly one-third were passed in Republican-controlled legislatures, with half enjoying bipartisan co-sponsorship. Compare this to Democratic-controlled legislatures, where only 33 percent of climate bills had bipartisan support.
Republican-led bills emphasized incentives for renewable energy like wind and solar, while Democratic bills focused on mandates and standards to limit carbon emissions.
Depolarizing effects are not limited to politicians. Our research suggests that it can be depolarizing to learn that ordinary Republicans prioritize climate.
In one experiment, we told respondents that ordinary Democratic voters thought that the federal government should prioritize climate action over jobs, Medicare and infrastructure. In response, 96 percent of Democrats considered climate action a priority, while only 36 percent of Republicans did.
But when we instead told respondents that ordinary Republican voters prioritized climate action, 94 percent of Democrats and 61 percent of Republicans considered climate action a priority. The gap between Democratic and Republican priorities narrowed from 60 percent to 33 percent.
As with political leaders, grassroots efforts by conservative climate advocates are already happening. Groups like RepublicEn, ConservAmerica, and the American Conservation Coalition are rallying young conservatives behind market-based solutions, permitting reform and carbon sequestration.
They even have podcasts, which seem to be the medium of choice for changing the discourse in this country; podcasts such as EcoRight Speaks and Green Tea Party Radio are publicizing conservative support for climate action, advocating for broad energy strategies in addition to incentivizing utilities and energy producers to reduce their carbon emissions.
Climate policy has proven elusive, owing to deepening political divisions. But our research shows that Republican politicians and climate advocates have a unique opportunity to depolarize climate solutions. There is a way — is there a will?
Leaf Van Boven is a professor in the Department of Psychology and Neuroscience at the University of Colorado Boulder. David K. Sherman is a professor in the Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences at the University of California, Santa Barbara.
Topics
-
Trump to meet with Republicans key to tax negotiations and other GOP priorities
Their votes will be crucial to passing Trump's agenda in the closely divided House.Politico - 9h -
Trump issues orders aiming to drill in contentious Alaska areas, revisit Biden climate rules
President Trump late Monday issued a pair of executive orders that seek to bolster oil and gas drilling — including in contentious areas of Alaska. One order seeks to open up drilling in Alaska’s ...The Hill - 1d -
Stocks surge on inflation data. Trump, bond yields hold the key to what’s next.
Investors await details of fiscal and tax policies under Trump’s second term — and the 10-year Treasury yield’s response.MarketWatch - Jan. 15 -
Key Republican says he will support Gabbard as Trump DNI pick
Sen. James Lankford (R-Okla.) said in a Sunday interview that he will support President-elect Trump’s pick for director of national intelligence, former Rep. Tulsi Gabbard (Hawaii). In the ...The Hill - Jan. 13 -
SALT-focused Republicans to meet with Trump as they threaten to hold up bill
Republicans who are pledging to withhold support for President-elect Trump’s ambitious agenda if the state and local tax (SALT) deduction cap is not raised are set to meet with the incoming ...The Hill - Jan. 11 -
Republicans hold on to Virginia state Senate seat
Republican Luther Cifers defeated Democrat Jack Trammell in the special election for the state Senate's 10th District on Tuesday, according to Decision Desk HQ, maintaining Republicans’ grip on the ...The Hill - Jan. 8 -
A Key Part of Biden’s Climate Law Was Built to Survive Trump. Now, the Test.
A lucrative tax credit for renewable energy could be hard to kill because it applies to a technologies favored by Republicans, not just wind and solar.The New York Times - Jan. 7 -
Carville: Democrats have to focus on issues ‘Republicans can’t beef on’
Democratic strategist James Carville said in a new interview that Democrats need to focus on issues that Republicans “can’t beef on.” Carville joined MSNBC’s Jen Psaki on Sunday to discuss what the ...The Hill - Jan. 6 -
Chip Roy bid for Rules chair emerges as key issue ahead of Speaker vote
Rep. Chip Roy’s (R-Texas) bid to be chair of the House Rules Committee is emerging as a key issue for those withholding support for Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) ahead of Friday afternoon’s Speaker ...The Hill - Jan. 3
More from The Hill
-
Pentagon to support deportation flights, construct barriers in border deployment
The U.S. military will support deportation flights, intelligence collection and help construct barriers when 1,500 active-duty troops deploy to the southern border and begin work in the next two ...The Hill - 15m -
Boebert vows to offer Jan. 6 protests tour of the Capitol
Rep. Lauren Boebert (R-Colo.) said on Tuesday she would offer guided tours of the Capitol to the Jan. 6 rioters who just received a sweeping pardon from President Trump. “I’ll be the first member ...The Hill - 25m -
Trump's crypto reckoning
Welcome to The Hill's Technology newsletter {beacon} Technology Technology The Big Story Trump meme coin sparks crypto world backlash President Trump is facing backlash after he and first lady ...The Hill - 27m -
Congressional negotiators say bipartisan funding deal possible this week
House negotiators on both sides said Wednesday that they think a deal on a topline for fiscal 2025 spending could come as soon as this week. Rep. Rosa DeLauro (Conn.), top Democrat on the House ...The Hill - 45m -
Live updates: Congress gives Trump his first legislative win; Republicans form their own Jan. 6 panel
Rubber is meeting the road in President Trump's first week back at the White House. The administration warned federal workers in roles related to diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) that they ...The Hill - 46m
More in Politics
-
Pentagon to support deportation flights, construct barriers in border deployment
The U.S. military will support deportation flights, intelligence collection and help construct barriers when 1,500 active-duty troops deploy to the southern border and begin work in the next two ...The Hill - 15m -
Boebert vows to offer Jan. 6 protests tour of the Capitol
Rep. Lauren Boebert (R-Colo.) said on Tuesday she would offer guided tours of the Capitol to the Jan. 6 rioters who just received a sweeping pardon from President Trump. “I’ll be the first member ...The Hill - 25m -
Trump's crypto reckoning
Welcome to The Hill's Technology newsletter {beacon} Technology Technology The Big Story Trump meme coin sparks crypto world backlash President Trump is facing backlash after he and first lady ...The Hill - 27m -
Congressional negotiators say bipartisan funding deal possible this week
House negotiators on both sides said Wednesday that they think a deal on a topline for fiscal 2025 spending could come as soon as this week. Rep. Rosa DeLauro (Conn.), top Democrat on the House ...The Hill - 45m -
Live updates: Congress gives Trump his first legislative win; Republicans form their own Jan. 6 panel
Rubber is meeting the road in President Trump's first week back at the White House. The administration warned federal workers in roles related to diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) that they ...The Hill - 46m