Red states reject data, force office mandates on government workers

Recent months have seen several Republican-led states and Republican legislators embrace a controversial push to mandate in‐office work for government employees. The evidence suggests that this move prioritizes partisan political agendas over evidence-based decisionmaking, especially given its alignment with the Trump administration’s federal in-office mandate.

Rather than rely on hard data that shows remote work can be as effective as or even more effective than traditional office arrangements, leaders in Nebraska, Ohio, Oklahoma and Wisconsin are issuing or promoting return-to-office orders that many argue are little more than political theater.

In Nebraska, where nearly 2,250 state employees in the largest agencies already work remotely or on a hybrid basis, Gov. Jim Pillen (R) has issued a full-time return-to-office order. Pillen’s move, which remains mired in a years-long legal dispute over labor contracts, has stirred a political firestorm.

“Who cares where our IT application developers are working — as long as their assignments are done on time.” said Justin Hubly, executive director of the Nebraska Association of Public Employees, which represents over 8,000 workers. Hubly argues that many state jobs could be performed remotely and laments how the issue has been needlessly politicized. His frustration echoes a broader national debate where every aspect of government work has become a partisan flashpoint.

Ohio’s Gov. Mike DeWine (R) has also ordered state employees to return to their offices. In Oklahoma, GOP Gov. Kevin Stitt signed an executive order mandating full-time office attendance.

And in Wisconsin, Republican lawmakers and House Speaker Robin Vos have introduced proposals to force pre-pandemic office attendance levels — even as Democratic Gov. Tony Evers threatens to veto any such requirement.

Even states that once championed remote work are rethinking their approach. In Utah, former Lt. Gov. Spencer Cox, who in 2019 famously called himself a “televangelist for telework,” is now reevaluating his state’s remote work framework. Whereas Cox once credited remote work with saving taxpayers millions and improving air quality, his recent comments underscore that remote work, though beneficial, requires proper oversight and support — a nuance that many red state mandates fail to acknowledge.

By prioritizing partisan posturing over data-driven decisionmaking, these leaders are sidelining compelling evidence that remote work saves money, reduces overhead and enhances employee retention. The political narrative has shifted remote work into a culture war issue rather than a strategic efficiency tool — one that could jeopardize the federal and state workforces in the long run.

Studies and surveys consistently demonstrate that remote work yields substantial benefits. According to the U.S. Office of Personnel Management, telework has saved agencies millions in operating costs while maintaining or even boosting productivity levels.

Yet although these findings point to a more efficient, agile workforce, several red state governors are clinging to outdated ideas. Executive orders mandating full-time office attendance seem less rooted in genuine concerns about public service performance and more in a desire to symbolically “return to normal” and trim government headcount — a political ploy reminiscent of earlier conservative attempts to weaken public-sector unions.

The damage from forcing employees back into the office is not just theoretical. Just two years ago, former President Biden’s more moderate in-office work mandate — which required federal employees to return to their offices at least 60 percent of the time — triggered a substantial increase in turnover among senior and highly skilled employees.

A groundbreaking study by Mark Ma and his colleagues at the University of Pittsburgh, using data from Revelio Labs, provided clear evidence of the losses incurred by this policy. In March 2022, the hybrid return-to-office directive caused turnover rates among senior employees (directors, supervisors or higher) to spike by 26 percent, as leaders with decades of institutional knowledge left for the private sector. Highly skilled employees experienced an even sharper 32 percent increase in turnover, leaving many departments struggling to maintain efficiency and continuity.

The current return-to-office policies being pushed in red states are even more stringent than Biden’s. They risk replicating or even outpacing the disruption caused by previous mandates without delivering any clear productivity benefit.

A recent study by Alessandra Fenizia of George Washington University and Tom Kirchmaier of the London School of Economics reveals significant productivity gains associated with work-from-home arrangements in the public sector. Their research analyzed detailed administrative data on employees alternating between home and office work. The findings showed that employees working remotely achieved a 12 percent increase in productivity compared to their in-office performance. This boost is attributed primarily to there being fewer distractions at home — fewer interruptions, less informal chatter and reduced office-based inefficiencies.

Critically, the study debunks the myth that remote workers are less accountable or diligent. Data showed no decline in the quality of work completed at home. In fact, remote employees handled more cases per day without any measurable increase in errors. The research also suggests that hybrid work models — where employees alternate between home and office — offer the best of both worlds. Workers enjoy the productivity boost of remote work while still reaping the benefits of periodic in-office interactions that foster team cohesion and collaboration.

Decisions affecting public sector work models should be driven by evidence, not ideology. Data from the U.S. Office of Personnel Management, and independent studies all indicate that remote work, when implemented thoughtfully, enhances productivity, reduces costs and improves employee retention.

The painful lessons from Biden’s hybrid mandate demonstrate that even moderate in-office requirements can have disruptive consequences. In contrast, flexible, hybrid work models have proven successful across numerous sectors and geographies; they allow governments to leverage the best of both worlds without sacrificing efficiency.

Additional international examples support this approach. While some U.S. states are scrambling to force government workers back into crowded offices, the European Central Bank recently extended its remote work policy for another two years for its public servants, citing improved work-life balance and sustained productivity levels.

In an era when data-driven decision making is more critical than ever, red states’ insistence on a full return to the office seems to be driven more by political theater than by solid evidence. The experiences of the federal workforce — marked by significant turnover among senior and skilled employees under Biden’s moderate mandate — and the robust productivity gains documented in recent public sector studies suggest that flexible work models improve efficiency, thus saving taxpayers money.

For the sake of government performance and the well-being of millions of workers, public policy should prioritize evidence over dogma and adopt work models that truly enhance public service.

Gleb Tsipursky, PhD, serves as the CEO of the hybrid work consultancy Disaster Avoidance Experts and authored the best-seller "Returning to the Office and Leading Hybrid and Remote Teams."

Topics

Worker Strike Forces California Lab to Send Bird Flu Tests Out of State

Striking are workers from the California Animal Health and Food Safety Lab.
Inc. - 4d
Supreme Court Rejects, for Now, Trump’s Bid to Fire Government Watchdog

The court’s order indicated that it may return to the issue as soon as next week, when a trial judge’s temporary restraining order is set to expire.
The New York Times - Feb. 22
Council pension ‘pools’ in England and Wales reject government push to merge

Investment vehicles tell ministers continuing to operate independently will deliver best value for 6.7mn members
Financial Times - 3d
Fired Workers Reject ‘Low Performance’ Judgments as They Take to Social Media

Meta’s recent cull of workers supposedly targeted weaker performers. But they and federal workers hit by DOGE-driven federal workforce cuts are fighting against that label, fearing it will affect ...
Inc. - Feb. 24
Apple removes advanced data protection tool in face of UK government request

Apple says removal of tool after government asked for right to see data will make iCloud users more vulnerable. Business live – latest updates Apple has taken the unprecedented step of ...
The Guardian - Feb. 21
Apple pulls data protection tool after UK government security row

Customers' photos and documents stored online will no longer be protected by end-to-end encryption.
BBC News - Feb. 22
Farmers Sue Over Deletion of Climate Data From Government Websites

The data, which disappeared from Agriculture Department sites in recent weeks, was useful to farmers for business planning, the lawsuit said.
The New York Times - Feb. 24
Lutnick Remarks on Removing Government Spending in GDP Data Raises Fears

Howard Lutnick, the commerce secretary, suggested government spending should be excluded from data about U.S. economic output.
The New York Times - 6h
DOGE Is Working on Software That Automates the Firing of Government Workers

Operatives working for Elon Musk’s DOGE appear to be editing the code of AutoRIF—software designed by the Defense Department that could assist in mass firings of federal workers, sources tell WIRED.
Wired - 6d
Man dies at Manchester airport after arrest by Border Force officers

Police watchdog is investigating death of 27-year-old who showed ‘unusual behaviour’ at security check. A 27-year-old man has died at Manchester airport after being arrested by Border Force ...
The Guardian - Feb. 20
Alabama police force put on leave after 5 officers arrested, charged

The Hanceville police chief and four of his officers are accused of mishandling or removing materials from the department's evidence room.
CBS News - Feb. 21
FBI New York field office chief says he was forced to resign

The head of the FBI’s New York field office, who had been critical of Trump administration firings at the bureau, says he was forced out of his role. James Dennehy, the assistant director in charge ...
The Hill - 1h
Netanyahu rails against the 'deep state' in tirade rejecting court-led probe into Oct. 7 attacks

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu railed against the “deep state” as he rejected the establishment of a court-appointed inquiry into the Hamas attacks.
NBC News - 2h
Election systems feared vulnerable as government cuts workers tasked with security

Cuts to the U.S. cybersecurity agency and FBI affected the federal workers tasked with stopping foreign interference in elections.
CBS News - Feb. 25
Government Workers Who Have Lost Their Jobs Worry About Their Housing

The abrupt firings have left federal workers and contractors throughout the country in flux, with many distressed over how they will pay the mortgage or rent.
The New York Times - Feb. 25
Fired federal workers told their termination is in the government's 'best interest'

NBC News White House Correspondent Vaughn Hillyard joins Meet the Press NOW to discuss the latest reaction among federal workers to the government layoffs as widespread uncertainty continues to loom.
NBC News - 6d
Lebanon’s government wins confidence vote, says only armed forces should defend country in war

Lebanon’s new government has won a confidence vote in Parliament, with the support of Hezbollah’s bloc, even though the government statement adopted took a swipe at the group’s weapons
ABC News - 5d
Judge blocks Department of Education, federal personnel office from sharing data with DOGE

A federal judge in Maryland has blocked the Department of Education and Office of Personnel Management from sharing the personal information of plaintiffs in a lawsuit against the Trump ...
NBC News - Feb. 24
Musk: Federal workers who haven’t returned to office will be placed on leave this week

Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) leader Elon Musk said early Monday that federal workers who haven’t returned to the office will be placed on administrative leave this week. Last month, ...
The Hill - Feb. 24
Starbucks asks office workers to stay at home as it announces 1,100 job cuts

Corporate lay-offs are the first for coffee shop chain since 2018
Financial Times - Feb. 24
US personnel office walks back email ultimatum from Musk to workers

OPM says failure to respond to email will not be considered resignation but Trump ally digs in and threatens job losses. The US government’s human resources office has walked back an ultimatum ...
The Guardian - Feb. 25
Google’s Sergey Brin Asks Workers to Spend More Time In the Office

The tech giant’s co-founder said that if employees worked harder and were in the office more, the company could reach an artificial general intelligence breakthrough.
The New York Times - 4d
DOGE’s Latest Victim: Federal Tech Workers in Office 18F

Mark Cuban has some advice for the fired employees, who focused on tasks like building the login tool for key government programs.
Inc. - 20h
Hochul highlights New York state jobs for federal workers

New York Gov. Kathy Hochul is launching a "You're Hired" campaign to recruit federal workers who are losing their jobs due to the Trump administration's program cuts.
The Hill - 6d
CEOs want workers back in offices—this company is giving workers a $10,000 raise to do it

Cameo wants workers back in the office more often, and it’s paying them each $10,000 to show up.
NBC News - Feb. 20
CEOs want workers back in offices—this company is giving workers a $10,000 raise to do it

Cameo wants workers back in the office more often, and it's paying them each $10,000 to show up.
CNBC - Feb. 20
Austria's new government takes office after a 5-month wait for a new administration

Austria’s new government has taken office after a long, five-month wait for a new administration
ABC News - 1d
How a low-profile federal board could host appeals for thousands of fired government workers

Thousands of federal workers fired in recent days by the Trump administration may be able to use an appeals process to get reinstated in their jobs — and potentially receive back pay.
NBC News - Feb. 24
Nicaraguan government is cementing total control of the state and violating rights, UN experts warn

Yahoo News - 5d
Federal workers free to ignore Elon Musk email ultimatum, US personnel office says – as it happened

This blog is now closed. Here’s our latest politics story . Here’s a little more on Dan Bongino , the Maga podcaster Donald Trump has named as deputy director of the FBI and who will oversee ...
The Guardian - Feb. 25
Deal reached to end illegal strike by New York state prison workers, governor says

New York Gov. Kathy Hochul has announced an agreement to end a wildcat strike that has roiled the state’s prison system for more than a week
ABC News - 4d
Half of U.S. workers don't know their state's paid sick leave laws—this tool can help

In the absence of a federal law, U.S. workers rely on a patchwork of state laws or their private-sector employer for sick leave coverage.
CNBC - 23h
Once kids start dying, we'll see how people really feel about immunization mandates

Anti-vaxxer movement is putting children at risk, with 13 states allowing immunization exemptions and governors issuing executive orders allowing latitude for exemptions, while the number of ...
The Hill - Feb. 24
Downing Street rejects plan for legal migration cap

Officials had been studying hard limit as way to reduce numbers
Financial Times - Feb. 21
Reject the quiet life — there is no growth without competition

The UK government should learn from the sorry history of cartels and monopolies
Financial Times - Feb. 24
Apple shareholders reject proposal to scrap DEI program

Apple credits its DEI program as helping make the iPhone maker the most valuable company in the world.
CBS News - 6d
Apple shareholders reject ban on diversity programs

Apple shareholders rejected a proposal to eliminate internal programs intended to boost the diversity of the company's workforce on Tuesday before its public shareholder meeting.
NBC News - 6d
Apple Shareholders Reject Proposal to Scrap Diversity Programs

Unlike other tech firms, the iPhone maker isn’t walking back its DEI initiatives. And shareholders have now backed that decision.
Inc. - 6d
Zelenskyy rejects calls for immediate Ukraine-Russia ceasefire

Defiant Ukrainian president sees no need to make amends for explosive Oval Office row with Trump
Financial Times - 1d