Pushing Canada around: Trump forgot the US isn’t supposed to be just another bully
For decades, the U.S. stood apart. It wasn’t merely the most powerful country in the world — it was the anchor of the international system it built after World War II. The American-led order was far from perfect, and the U.S. could act hypocritically at times, but the setup had a purpose: to discourage territorial expansionism, promote stability and uphold a set of rules that kept great-power competition from spiraling into chaos.
President Trump is breaking with that paradigm, clearly considering it a thing for losers and suckers. His vision is not of America as a guardian of international norms but as a raw, self-interested force willing to extort allies, impose tariffs on friends and even threaten their sovereignty. This is a rupture with the entire post-World War II consensus, disdainful of “expertise” and indifferent to criticism.
Nowhere is this clearer than in his treatment of America’s closest partners. His administration has waged trade wars against allies, using national security as a flimsy excuse to impose tariffs on Canadian and European goods. He has floated the idea of seizing Greenland from Denmark, questioned why the U.S. ever gave up the Panama Canal, and engaged in open economic coercion against Mexico.
Perhaps the greatest outrage is his treatment of, our long-friendly neighbor to the north with whom we share professional baseball and hockey leagues and much more. Last week, when challenged on Fox about his harsh tariff assault on Canada, he replied: “Here’s my problem with Canada ... Canada was meant to be the 51st state ... We don’t need their cars. We don’t need their lumber ... We don’t need their energy. We don’t need anything.”
Even in the Trump era, words have value, so it’s important to deconstruct this nonsense.
Canada was never intended to be part of the U.S., having chosen a different path after the American Revolution. The War of 1812 cemented its independence, and it has built its own institutions and economy. Canada is actually the largest export market for the U.S., supporting American businesses and jobs. And the assertion that the U.S. doesn’t need Canadian goods is just false.
The North American auto industry is deeply integrated, with American car manufacturers depending on Canadian-made parts. The U.S. also relies on Canada for more than 80 percent of its softwood lumber imports, and without it, housing prices would soar. Canada is also America’s largest foreign energy supplier, providing over half of U.S. crude oil imports and virtually all its electricity imports from abroad.
Moreover, trade deficits aren’t inherently bad, don’t measure economic strength, and reflect financial realities rather than unfair trade. Countries with surpluses, like China and Germany, reinvest in the U.S. by buying stocks, real estate and government bonds. Eliminating the deficit could weaken growth by reducing this investment and raising interest rates.
Indeed, trade deficits often signal strength: A wealthy country with a strong currency and high consumer demand will naturally import more. Many surplus countries suppress wages and consumption — hardly a model to follow.
Moreover, the quickest way to fix trade deficits is to weaken the dollar, making U.S. exports more attractive and imports more expensive; the price of that will be paid by U.S. consumers via price rises of everything from pure exports to domestic products with foreign components, which includes ... most things of high economic value.
Either way, the message that is being understood around the world — on tariff madness and territorial covetousness both — is that in the new era alliances with the U.S. are not based on shared values or mutual defense, but on submission. The tragedy is that the distrust this breeds will outlast Trump in office. A future less bellicose leader will struggle to fix the damage — economic and reputational damage that’ll harm America for years.
The idea that stronger nations should not seize (or extort) territory from weaker ones has been a foundational principle of the world order America helped construct. It was the logic behind the formation of the United Nations, the legal basis for NATO’s deterrence strategy, and the moral underpinning of U.S. opposition to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
Yet Trump has explicitly rejected this notion. In 2019, when Denmark refused to entertain the sale of Greenland, he responded by attacking the Danish prime minister as “nasty.” When it was later suggested that the U.S. could simply take Greenland if Denmark refused to cooperate, his administration did not dismiss the idea, allowing it to circulate.
A similar impulse has surfaced with Panama. Trump and his allies have begun questioning why the U.S. ever relinquished control of the canal, calling it a historic mistake. At first, such statements sounded like throwaway campaign bluster. But more recently, voices within his orbit have suggested that if Panama does not align with U.S. economic demands, stronger measures could be taken. The language is deliberately vague, but the implications are clear: Trump does not see sovereignty as an inviolable principle, but as a bargaining chip.
For much of its modern history, the United States has justified its vast power by claiming that it operated differently from traditional empires. Unlike the colonial powers of the 19th century, America positioned itself as a force that upheld principles rather than just raw national interest. This was, of course, always an ideal rather than a perfect reality. But ideals shape global perceptions, give legitimacy to power and reinforce the stability of the system.
Trump’s America is instead just another large country throwing its weight around, unconcerned with long-term consequences. The notion that the U.S. stands for anything greater than itself has been binned in favor of international relations as a zero-sum struggle.
This shift does not merely alienate allies — it accelerates global instability. If the United States no longer upholds the idea that sovereignty must be respected, why should anyone else? If America treats its friends as rivals, what incentive do those countries have to stand with the U.S. in times of crisis? If America no longer differentiates itself from aggressive powers, it cannot credibly lead a coalition against them.
It is telling that some of the most blunt warnings about this transformation are coming from outside the U.S. Earlier this month, French Senator Claude Malhuret gave a speech describing Trump as a leader who has “done more harm to America in a month than in four years” of his previous term. He argued that the free world must prepare for an America that is not merely unreliable but actively hostile to the system it once defended.
“Donald Trump is a traitor,” he declared. “A traitor to Ukraine, a traitor to democracy, and a traitor to the very alliances that have kept the world stable for 75 years.”
Strong words to be sure, but Malhuret is correct to be alarmed.
Thomas Hobbes, writing in the 17th century during the chaos of the English Civil War, saw a world where might made right — a brutal state of nature where life was “nasty, brutish, and short.” Our society’s progress since then has been an effort to escape that cycle, to build systems based on laws rather than force, cooperation rather than conquest. We called it Western civilization, a project that culminated in the postwar order America helped create — one that sought to contain raw power with rules, alliances and shared values.
That’s what Trump is messing with.
Dan Perry is the former Cairo-based Middle East editor and London-based Europe/Africa editor of the Associated Press, the former chairman of the Foreign Press Association in Jerusalem, and the author of two books. Follow him at danperry.substack.com.
-
Iran’s supreme leader rails against Trump’s ‘bullying’ military threat
Ayatollah Khamenei says US demand to reopen talks on Iran’s nuclear programme is aimed at domination. Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, has criticised what he described as bullying ...The Guardian - Mar. 8 -
Trump's quest to conquer Canada is confusing everyone
Canadians and Republicans alike are confounded as President Donald Trump increasingly links a trade war to his push to annex Canada.NBC News - Mar. 14 -
The Memo: Trump, amid tariff tangle, sounds serious about bringing Canada into US
President Trump’s tariff policies sparked another day of political and financial-market turmoil Tuesday — along with new recognition that he really may be serious about trying to make Canada part ...The Hill - Mar. 12 -
Trump administration pushes to have deportation case reassigned to another judge
The Trump administration is pushing to change the judge overseeing a challenge to the president’s invocation of the Alien Enemies Act to carry out swift deportations. The Justice Department made ...The Hill - Mar. 17 -
Trump pledges to match EU and Canada's retaliatory tariffs
Trump repeated trade threats after the European Union and Canada retaliated to US steel and aluminium tariffs.BBC News - Mar. 12 -
UK must stand up to 'bully' Trump, says Ed Davey
Lib Dem leader says UK should "hit back with tariffs of our own" and co-ordinate a with the EU and Canada.BBC News - 2d -
Trump looms over Canada's election as campaign begins
The country will vote on 28 April as President Trump wages a trade war and says he wants to make Canada the 51st US state.BBC News - 2d -
Carney ready to talk trade with Trump if 'there's respect for Canada's sovereignty'
Prime minister-designate's comments follow Canada's reciprocal tariffs on US imports after Trump slapped taxes on steel and aluminium.BBC News - Mar. 12 -
Trump says he would be happy for US to become ‘associate’ Commonwealth member
US president posted Sun news story that referred to a supposed ‘secret offer’ King Charles is due to extendFinancial Times - 4d -
UK should not cave in to Trump’s ‘bullying’ over tech tax says Davey
Lib Dem leader warns US president is ‘an unreliable ally’Financial Times - 5d -
Tariffs could impact longstanding electricity trade between US and Canada
The tariffs the Trump administration is imposing on Canada could disrupt the longstanding trade of electricity between the two countries.ABC News - Mar. 11 -
Rubio says Canada takeover won't be on G7 agenda
Secretary of State Marco Rubio said that talk about the U.S. acquiring Canada will not be a topic of discussion when the Group of Seven (G7) nations meet in Quebec. Asked about President Trump's ...The Hill - Mar. 12 -
US pauses water-sharing negotiations with Canada over Columbia River
Break in talks comes as Trump escalates trade war with Canada and threatens its sovereignty. The United States has paused negotiations with Canada on a key water-sharing treaty as Donald Trump ...The Guardian - Mar. 12 -
Trump: US has 'just about' ended Ukraine intelligence-sharing suspension
President Trump said Sunday the United States had "just about" ended a suspension of intelligence sharing with Ukraine, adding that he expects "a lot of progress" during the talks with Ukrainian ...The Hill - Mar. 10 -
Democrats push back on plans to use military installations as migrant detention centers
Democratic lawmakers are pushing back against Trump administration plans to detain thousands of immigrants living in the country illegally at U.S. military sites. In a letter signed by nine ...The Hill - Mar. 18 -
Trump's Canada, Mexico tariffs try to 'stop the bleeding' in US economy: UAW chief
President Donald Trump's tariffs on Canada and Mexico "are an attempt to stop the bleeding" in the U.S. economy, United Auto Workers President Shawn Fain said.ABC News - Mar. 9 -
Markets open down again, Trump announces more tariffs against Canada
Traders on Wall Street hoping to rally back after Monday's major selloff are starting Tuesday with another dip. Meanwhile, President Trump has announced additional tariffs for Canada. CBS News' ...CBS News - Mar. 11 -
How Trump's threats have revived Canada's Liberal Party
Justin Trudeau's party was headed for near-certain defeat - until the US president said he wanted to make Canada the 51st state.BBC News - Mar. 9 -
Putin is just playing Trump for time
Russian President Vladimir Putin is using the ceasefire negotiations in Saudi Arabia between Washington and Moscow as a license to kill Ukrainian civilians, while Team Trump's envoy, Steve Witkoff, ...The Hill - 18h -
Top diplomats from G7 countries meet in Canada as Trump threatens more tariffs on US allies
Top diplomats from Group of 7 have held a first day of talks in Canada as U.S. President Donald Trump's trade and foreign policies have thrown the bloc's once solid unity into disarrayABC News - Mar. 13 -
Trump Suspends Mexico and Canada Tariffs on USMCA Goods for a Month
Many imports from Canada and Mexico will be exempt from tariffs, as the president quickly reversed a sweeping trade action taken just two days ago after market turmoil.The New York Times - Mar. 8 -
Canada can win trade war with US, foreign affairs minister Mélanie Joly says
Canada is among the countries waiting to see what Trump's 2 April reciprocal tariffs look like.BBC News - 2d -
Trump tariff uncertainty pushes BoJ to hold rates
Risk of potential US downturn weighs on Tokyo’s hope for economic revivalFinancial Times - Mar. 19 -
Former Australian PM Malcolm Turnbull says leaders must stand up to bullies after being lashed by Donald Trump
US president’s late-night social media post came after Turnbull criticised Trump’s leadership as ‘chaotic’. Ex-Tropical Cyclone Alfred LIVE: latest news and updates Get our breaking news email ...The Guardian - Mar. 10 -
Hundreds of muscle car drivers rally around bullied Alabama boy
When a mother desperate to show her 10-year-old son that people care and life can be joyful put out a small request on social media, hundreds of muscle car drivers heeded the call. Steve Hartman ...CBS News - Mar. 14 -
Trump tariff threats are pushing Canada's largest oil producer to break its dependence on the U.S.
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith said the oil-producing region could look beyond the U.S. for customers if Trump's tariff threats create uncertainty.CNBC - Mar. 13 -
Trump economic adviser: US 'launched a drug war, not a trade war' with Mexico, Canada
Kevin Hassett, the Trump administration’s National Economic Council director, said the United States has not launched a trade war with Mexico and Canada but “a drug war.” Hassett joined ABC News’s ...The Hill - Mar. 9 -
How Trump united Canada against him and flipped its election upside down
President Donald Trump may be pushing Americans further apart, but he’s brought Canadians closer together.NBC News - Mar. 15 -
Canada to review the purchase of US-made F-35 fighter jets in light of Trump's trade war
A spokesman for Canada's Defense Minister Bill Blair says new Prime Minister Mark Carney has asked for a review of the purchase of America’s F-35 fighter jetABC News - Mar. 15 -
Donald Trump’s imperial presidency is a throwback to a greedier, pernicious age | Simon Tisdall
His attempts to bully and exploit the weak hark back to an era when the US emulated the worst aspects of the British empire. Donald Trump’s imperial presidency is a tawdry, threadbare affair. The ...The Guardian - 3d -
Canada’s designated PM Mark Carney meets Trudeau as Trump threat looms
Former central banker won landslide victory in Liberal party race as trade war with US hastens transfer of power. Canada ’s incoming prime minister, Mark Carney, has met with Justin Trudeau as ...The Guardian - Mar. 10 -
Trump tariffs on steel and aluminum come into effect amid US-Canada trade war
European Commission announces countermeasures after sweeping US levies of 25% come into force without any exemptions. Donald Trump’s tariffs on steel and aluminum imports took effect on Wednesday ...The Guardian - Mar. 12 -
Ontario says it will slap a 25% surcharge on US-bound electricity
The move is in retaliation to Trump's tariff threats on Canada, and is expected to raise energy costs for 1.5 million US homes.BBC News - Mar. 10 -
Putin visits Kursk as Russia pushes back Ukrainian troops in captured region
Moscow’s soldiers step up offensive just hours after Kyiv backs 30-day, US-brokered armisticeFinancial Times - Mar. 12 -
Democrats push investigation into Trump, Musk White House Tesla event
Senate Democrats are seeking an investigation into President Trump and adviser Elon Musk's use of the White House to promote Musk's business interests, alleging a violation of federal ethics laws.The Hill - Mar. 13 -
The big question on Ukraine: is Trump ready to push Putin into peace? | Shaun Walker
Russian leader’s antagonism to Zelenskyy and lack of interest in a ceasefire leaves colossal task for US. David Lammy: Trump’s right, Putin can take the hard or easy way On paper, everyone is ...The Guardian - Mar. 15 -
Butler shrugs off Miami return: Just 'another game'
Jimmy Butler called his return to Miami on Tuesday just "another game," shrugging off the notion of any extra emotions tied to the matchup.ESPN - 2d -
Trump floats 250% tariff on dairy from Canada
Jerome Powell's remarks came as Trump threatened new tariffs on Canada.ABC News - Mar. 7 -
Can Mark Carney, Canada’s New Leader, Take on Trump and His Tariffs?
Mark Carney will most likely be in power just a few weeks before a federal election is held. To win, he will try to convince Canadians he can take on, but also negotiate with, Trump.The New York Times - Mar. 11
More from The Hill
-
Sanders slams Trump for trying to deport Columbia student: 'You can't exile political dissidents'
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) slammed the Trump administration’s attempt to deport a Columbia University student who participated in pro-Palestinian protests on campus. “You can't exile political ...The Hill - 6h -
Senate confirms Marty Makary to lead FDA
The Senate on Tuesday night confirmed Marty Makary to be the Food and Drug Administration commissioner. Makary was easily confirmed by a 56-44 vote, picking up three Democrats. Democratic Sens. ...The Hill - 7h -
Hundreds in Gaza take to streets to protest Hamas
Hundreds of Palestinians in the Gaza Strip took to the streets on Tuesday for a rare protest against the Palestinian militant group Hamas, which has controlled the war-torn strip for nearly two ...The Hill - 7h -
Democrat wins special state Senate election in Pennsylvania in major upset
Democrat James Malone has won an open Pennsylvania state Senate seat in a major upset in a district that comfortably voted for President Trump in November, Decision Desk HQ projects. Malone, the ...The Hill - 7h -
Democrat wins Pennsylvania special election, handing party control of state House
Democrat Dan Goughnour has won the open Pennsylvania state House seat left vacated by the death of the most recent officeholder, restoring Democrats’ narrow majority in the body, Decision Desk HQ ...The Hill - 8h
More in Politics
-
Sanders slams Trump for trying to deport Columbia student: 'You can't exile political dissidents'
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) slammed the Trump administration’s attempt to deport a Columbia University student who participated in pro-Palestinian protests on campus. “You can't exile political ...The Hill - 6h -
Senate confirms Marty Makary to lead FDA
The Senate on Tuesday night confirmed Marty Makary to be the Food and Drug Administration commissioner. Makary was easily confirmed by a 56-44 vote, picking up three Democrats. Democratic Sens. ...The Hill - 7h -
Hundreds in Gaza take to streets to protest Hamas
Hundreds of Palestinians in the Gaza Strip took to the streets on Tuesday for a rare protest against the Palestinian militant group Hamas, which has controlled the war-torn strip for nearly two ...The Hill - 7h -
Democrat wins special state Senate election in Pennsylvania in major upset
Democrat James Malone has won an open Pennsylvania state Senate seat in a major upset in a district that comfortably voted for President Trump in November, Decision Desk HQ projects. Malone, the ...The Hill - 7h -
Mike Waltz takes 'full responsibility' for military plans text group
President Trump's National Security adviser Mike Waltz said in an interview that he takes "full responsibility" for a group text that included a journalist while discussing military plans.NBC News - 7h