Port worker strike threatens technological progress
The strike by 47,000 International Longshoremen’s Association (ILA) members, which shut down all 36 East and Gulf Coast ports, has ended after an agreement on wages. However, the most important issue, automation, remains unresolved.
The union which wanted a 77 percent pay increase over six years, and the U.S. Maritime Alliance, which was negotiating for the ports, wanted a 50 percent increase, compromised and agreed to a 62 percent increase. The compromise on wages ended the strike. But the battle that is important for our future is over the union’s demand to halt port automation. And that fight is still on the table when the two parties return to the bargaining table on Jan. 15.
The two main jobs at ports — operating cranes and moving shipping containers around — were traditionally performed by union workers. But these tasks can now be automated and run by computer. People oversee the operations from a control room, but far fewer union workers are needed on the ground.
Only the Los Angeles and Long Beach ports are fully automated in the U.S., and three East Coast ports are classified as partially automated. But the global trend of 63 fully automated ports, is clear.
Picketers have held signs that read, “Automation Hurts Families: ILA Stands For Job Protection.” New Orleans local union president Henry Glover Jr. said that although automation could make work easier, “they’re using it to kill jobs. We don’t want them to implement anything that would take our jobs out.”
The unions had a similar reaction in the 1960s when Malcom McLean introduced the modern shipping container. Before the introduction of shipping containers, roughly 50 percent of the transport cost of a 4,000-mile shipment occurred at the ports on each end of the journey. McLean Industries reported to shareholders that “A containership can be loaded and unloaded in almost one-sixth of the time required for a conventional cargo ship and with about one-third of the labor.”
AFL-CIO president George Meany told his 1963 annual convention that automation is “rapidly becoming a curse to this society.” In response to containerization the East Coast, ILA went on strike in 1962 and 1964. Presidents Kennedy and Johnson both invoked the Taft-Hartley Act and ordered 80-day cooling-off periods that temporarily ended the strikes.
Ultimately, the unions accepted new work rules allowing the mass spread of containerization in exchange for higher and more stable wages and payoffs to displaced workers. The result was a revolution in global shipping that dramatically decreased costs. Today, the United States imports more than four times the variety of goods that it did in the early 1970s, in part because of container shipping.
The ILA members are a modern Luddite movement. The Luddites opposed mechanized garment production in the early 19th century on the grounds that it would destroy jobs. Technological progress does eliminate some jobs, but it simultaneously creates others. Ultimately, the total number of jobs in any economy is largely determined by the size of its labor force because we have a limitless desire for goods and services. So opposition to automation does not save jobs on net. It just holds back the shift to more productive employment that ultimately raises living standards.
Unfortunately, President Biden backed the union and refused to invoke the Taft-Hartley Act to temporarily end the strike and instead stated, "Now is not the time for ocean carriers to refuse to negotiate a fair wage for these essential workers." If the bargaining over port automation in January results in another strike, the new president should follow Kennedy and Johnson’s lead, and pause the strike to encourage an agreement that will allow for automation and technological progress.
Benjamin Powell, a senior fellow at the Independent Institute in Oakland, Calif., is director of the Free Market Institute and a professor of economics in the Rawls College of Business at Texas Tech University.
Date: |
Topics
-
Business - Financial Times
US dockworkers suspend strike that threatened to cripple ports
Workers will return under deal to extend contract until January 15 and avert billions in economic damage19 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Port workers reach tentative agreement to end strike
The International Longshoremen’s Association (ILA) union and the U.S. Maritime Alliance (USMX), an association of companies that operate East and Gulf Coast ports, reached a tentative agreement ...23 hours ago -
Business - CNBC
Port strike ends as workers agree to tentative deal on wages and contract extension
The strike was the first by the ILA since 1977, and it impacted port operations at 36 different ports, including the 10 busiest ports in North America.5 hours ago -
World - The Guardian
US dock workers agree on deal with port operators to end strike
International Longshoremen’s Association announces agreement for wage hike and immediate work resumption. The US ports strike that shut down shipping on the east and Gulf coasts for three days came ...22 hours ago -
Business - The Wall Street Journal
Asian Shipping Stocks Fall After U.S. Port Workers Suspend Strike
Shares of Asian shipping companies fell sharply after U.S. port workers suspended a three-day strike, dashing hopes for higher freight rates as a result of limited supply.17 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: White House holds briefing after Biden tours Helene damage, port workers strike deal
White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre will hold a news briefing Friday afternoon. The briefing comes a day after President Biden traveled to Florida and Georgia in the aftermath of ...5 hours ago - Joe Biden -
Business - The New York Times
Port Strike Suspended After Dockworkers’ Union Receives New Wage Offer
The International Longshoremen’s Association received a new wage offer and will halt its walkout at East and Gulf Coast ports, which began Tuesday.8 hours ago -
Top stories - CBS News
Agreement reached to suspend port strike
A strike by thousands of dockworkers at 14 ports along the East and Gulf coasts was suspended Thursday when a tentative agreement was reached to extend the current contract through Jan. 15.22 hours ago -
World - ABC News
North Korea's Kim threatens to destroy South Korea with nuclear strikes if provoked
North Korea says leader Kim Jong Un has threatened to use nuclear weapons and destroy South Korea permanently if provoked18 hours ago - North Korea
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Debate rages over Israeli response to Iran
Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story Should Israel strike Iranian oil or nuclear facilities? President ...27 minutes ago - Israel -
Politics - The Hill
Evening Report — Where things stand a month out
🌀 Plus: FEMA funding and fighting falsehoods {beacon} Evening Report30 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Harris meets with Arab American and Muslim leaders in Michigan
Vice President Harris met with leaders from the Muslim and Arab American community while in Flint, Mich., on Friday amid the ongoing war in the Middle East and shrinking support for Democrats from ...35 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Harris gets October Surprise
Welcome to The Hill's Business & Economy newsletter {beacon} Business & Economy Business & Economy The Big Story Harris buoyed by strong jobs report, port strike end An expectation-smashing jobs ...37 minutes ago - Kamala Harris -
Politics - The Hill
Buttigieg dismisses Musk's Helene federal response claims
Department of Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg called out tech giant Elon Musk on Friday for making false claims about the federal government blocking flights with deliveries for Hurricane ...1 hour ago