Plagiarism expert: Harris book shows 'sloppy writing habits,' not 'wholesale fraud'
Plagiarism expert Jonathan Bailey said Vice President Harris’s 2009 book showed signs of “sloppy writing habits” but pushed back on claims that the Democratic nominee engaged in “wholesale fraud.”
In an article published Tuesday in Plagiarism Today, Bailey expanded on his initial remarks to The New York Times in response to conservative author Christopher Rufo’s article accusing Harris of plagiarism in her book, “Smart on Crime: A Career Prosecutor’s Plan to Make Us Safer.”
Rufo’s article included five sections of the book, which, Bailey said, “bore strong similarities to earlier works.” Bailey said he now had the chance to examine the more complete dossier by an Austrian plagiarism expert, Stefan Weber.
“With this new information, while I believe the case is more serious than I commented to The New York Times, the overarching points remain,” Bailey said in his Tuesday article. “While there are problems with this work, the pattern points to sloppy writing habits, not a malicious intent to defraud."
“Is it problematic? Yes. But it’s also not the wholesale fraud that many have claimed it to be. It sits somewhere between what the two sides want it to be,” Bailey said.
The updated analysis from Bailey comes as Rufo’s plagiarism accusations against the Democratic presidential nominee gain traction online and in conservative media circles.
Rufo reported on five of the approximately 18 accusations of plagiarism that Weber’s dossier makes against Harris’s 2009 book. Rufo, late last year, made accusations of plagiarism against then-Harvard President Claudine Gay, who was under scrutiny at the time for her remarks at a congressional hearing about antisemitism. She resigned from her post soon thereafter.
The Harris campaign dismissed the accusations as a concerted effort by “rightwing operatives,” in a statement reported by USA Today.
“Rightwing operatives are getting desperate as they see the bipartisan coalition of support Vice President Harris is building to win this election,” Harris campaign spokesperson James Singer said in a statement, according to the national news outlet.
“This is a book that’s been out for 15 years, and the Vice President clearly cited sources and statistics in footnotes and endnotes throughout,” he added in the statement.
The Hill has reached out to the Harris campaign for comment.
Bailey, in his essay this week, said the most serious allegation was one instance in which Harris’s book “contained roughly two paragraphs copied from Wikipedia without citation.”
“To be clear, that is plagiarism,” Bailey continued.
He said the remaining examples were instances when the book allegedly failed to use quotation marks around words that were cited verbatim. Bailey said the sources “were largely cited and, in some cases, were quoted, though not all verbatim text was included.”
He said the alleged failure to cite sources from the time the book was written is relatively common, saying, “We’ve seen this problem repeatedly, especially with works from this period.”
“Poor writing techniques and the lack of accessible plagiarism detection tools made this a common problem, especially before the 2010s. While that doesn’t make it acceptable, it makes it more about sloppy writing habits than an intent to defraud,” he wrote.
Date: |
-
Sports - Yahoo Sports
Harris campaign calls plagiarism claims a partisan attack. Expert says it was 'sloppy writing'
WASHINGTON (AP) — Democratic presidential candidate Kamala Harris' campaign is dismissing accusations that she and a co-author plagiarized parts of a 2009 book on the U.S. criminal justice system ...2 hours ago -
Sports - CBS Sports
Takeaways from Drake Maye's first NFL start: QB settles in after sloppy start, shows flashes in Texans loss
Maye finished the game with more touchdowns than Jacoby Brissett had in the first five games this season3 days ago - NFL -
Politics - NBC News
Trump, Harris focus on swing states as new poll shows dead heat
Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Trump are focusing on battleground states as a new NBC News poll shows a tight race, with both candidates now tied among registered voters ...2 days ago - Donald Trump -
Business - CNBC
Kamala Harris says this lesson from her mom shaped her career—why parenting experts say it’s essential for success
Growing up, Vice President Kamala Harris's mother taught her to approach conflict with agency and accountability. The lessons have shaped her career, she says.3 days ago -
World - Yahoo News
Ex-ANC spokesperson charged with fraud
10 hours ago -
Business - CNBC
Harris PAC's $1 million contribution from Ripple's Chris Larsen shows crypto industry warming to VP
Ripple co-founder Chris Larsen recently gave $1 million worth of XRP tokens to a super PAC that's supporting the vice president's run for the White House.Yesterday - Kamala Harris -
World - The Guardian
If Kamala Harris is trying to show she can meet the needs of Black America, she has gaps to fill | Shamira Ibrahim
The Democratic nominee talked to Charlamagne tha God about turning her attention to Black men – but her vision is undercut by reality. As we enter the final 21 days of the 2024 presidential ...Yesterday -
Tech - GameSpot
The Penguin: Comic-Book Stories Are Still Ashamed of Being Comic-Book Stories
When Fox put the first X-Men movie together, producers looked at the pages of the comics and worried about whether moviegoers would be put off by the silly clowns dancing around on the pages even ...Yesterday -
Entertainment - ABC News
US-Apple-Books-Top-10
Apple Books charts for week ending Oct. 14Yesterday - Apple
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
NH Supreme Court justice indicted over alleged attempts to interfere with investigation into husband
New Hampshire Supreme Court Associate Justice Anna Barbara Hantz Marconi was indicted for allegedly trying to interfere in a criminal investigation into her husband, state officials announced ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
5 takeaways from a contentious Bret Baier, Harris interview
Vice President Harris sat for her toughest interview yet since becoming the Democratic nominee on Wednesday, when she was peppered with questions from Fox News’s Bret Baier. The two sparred ...2 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Former Harris aide says Baier pulled interview questions from 'Trump/Vance press release'
Former top aide to Vice President Harris turned MSNBC host Symone Sanders knocked Fox News anchor Bret Baier over how the journalist handled a high-stakes interview on "Special Report" with the ...2 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Judge rejects handful of controversial rules, including hand-count rule, from Georgia board
A judge in Georgia tossed out a handful of controversial rules passed in recent months by the GOP-majority Georgia State Election Board, arguing that the board didn’t have the authority to put ...2 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
The year's brightest supermoon is rising this week
Get ready to look up for the year’s biggest and brightest supermoon. And it's pairing up with a comet for a rare stargazing two-for-one.2 hours ago