Pennsylvania Democrat apologizes for mocking 'precedent' with ballot count decision
The Democratic chair of a key Pennsylvania county's elections board apologized on Wednesday for saying "precedent by a court doesn’t matter anymore" when she voted to count hundreds of deficient mail and provisional ballots.
"I wanted to start by apologizing for the upset and confusion that I have caused the citizens of Bucks County and the hardworking employees of this county and my family and those who share my last name," Bucks County Commissioner Diane Ellis-Marseglia said at a Wednesday meeting.
"Anyone who knows me knows that I care a lot about elections and I have been involved in them all my life, virtually. And like all of you and all Americans, I want this election and every election to be fair, to be honest, to be just and one we can have confidence in," she continued.
Ellis-Marseglia gained national attention when she voted last week to count hundreds of undated and misdated mail ballots as well as provisional ballots with errors.
“I think we all know that precedent by a court doesn’t matter anymore in this country and people violate laws any time they want. So for me, if I violate this law, it’s because I want a court to pay attention to it," Ellis-Marseglia said.
The comment sparked widespread criticism, given that state elections law prohibits counting ballots that fail to meet the technical requirements. Voting rights groups and Democrats have mounted various challenges, but the Pennsylvania Supreme Court before the election ruled that the date requirement must be enforced this cycle.
On Monday, the court reiterated its position that officials cannot flout provisions of the elections code, with multiple justices rebuking Ellis-Marseglia and other officials for defying the court.
At issue are roughly 600 ballots in Bucks County as well as hundreds of others in places like Philadelphia and Montgomery counties. As the controversy gained steam, Bucks County officials reported receiving threats.
The dispute has gotten attention particularly as Pennsylvania's Senate race heads to an automatic recount.
Decision Desk HQ, The Hill's partner, has projected Republican Dave McCormick as the winner. But incumbent Sen. Bob Casey (D-Pa.), who trails by roughly 16,000 votes, has not yet conceded.
Both campaigns are continuing to battle in state trial courts over the validity of various batches of ballots.
Topics
-
Pennsylvania Supreme Court rebukes Democratic election officials who counted undated mail ballots
Politics - The Hill - 3 days ago -
Supreme Court won't block counting of certain provisional ballots in Pennsylvania
Top stories - CBS News - November 1 -
Pennsylvania top court rules provisional ballots must be counted after mail ballot rejections
Politics - The Hill - October 24 -
Pennsylvania Democrats sue Erie County over mail-in ballot delays
Politics - The Hill - October 31 -
Pennsylvania appeals court rules timely mail ballots with improper dates should be counted
Politics - The Hill - October 30 -
Pennsylvania’s top court reaffirms mail ballots with missing, improper dates can’t be counted
Politics - The Hill - November 1 -
Pennsylvania Supreme Court orders election officials to stop counting ballots with date errors
Top stories - NBC News - 2 days ago -
Why California Is Still Counting Ballots
Top stories - The New York Times - November 12
More from The Hill
-
Giuliani appeals decision ordering him to turn over assets to election workers
Politics - The Hill - 35 minutes ago -
Evening Report — First Trump Cabinet pick goes down
Politics - The Hill - 39 minutes ago -
Police release more details on Hegseth's assault allegation
Politics - The Hill - 41 minutes ago -
Gaetz withdrawal from AG nomination is among quickest in history
Politics - The Hill - 44 minutes ago -
Georgia attorney general launches bid in 2026 governor's race
Politics - The Hill - 48 minutes ago