Paxton asks Texas's high court for 'emergency' action on poverty relief program
In his campaign to block a Houston-area guaranteed basic income program, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton (R) is betting that third time’s the charm.
On Tuesday, Paxton’s office filed an emergency petition to the Supreme Court of Texas, calling on justices to block Harris County’s basic income program, Uplift Harris.
“Harris County officials cannot continue to abuse their power and the people’s money to score political points, and we will fight every step of the way to hold them accountable,” he said in a statement Tuesday.
County attorney Christian Menefee (D) shot back that “Ken Paxton has made it clear that he wants to work against Harris County families and officials to the very end. It’s unfortunate, but I plan to keep fighting.”
Paxton’s push to block the program has been rejected in past weeks by both district and appellate courts.
If Paxton’s measure fails, Uplift Harris will begin sending out $500 monthly checks to nearly 2,000 residents in two days — a time window that Paxton argues constitutes an emergency.
“Harris County will violate our Constitution in less than two days,” his office wrote in a filing that seeks to block the measure before it can go into effect.
Otherwise, Paxton argued, the state fight against the measure will likely drag on for longer than the 18-month pilot itself. “And once the payments are made, the funds will not be recoverable.”
In a statement Tuesday, Paxton argued the plan violates the Texas Constitution, which his office claims “prohibits this kind of free-money transfer absent an express constitutional exception … even for a laudable cause like poverty relief.”
In his series of filings, Paxton argued that the money comes with no strings attached and is therefore unconstitutional. Harris County has countered that there are significant strings attached: Recipients must be at certain low-income levels, live in certain high-poverty counties and can't use the money on illegal conduct — an argument that Texas judges have thus far upheld.
Despite the use by former President Trump — an ally of Paxton's — of similar basic income strategies during the COVID-19 pandemic, Paxton’s weeks-long campaign against the measure has carried strong overtones of the culture war.
In previous filings, he has called it “The Harris Handout” and “a socialist experiment by [County Judge] Lina Hidalgo and the progressive [Democrats] responsible for the Harris County disaster.”
In an initial filing, he also implied that the basic income plan represented an electoral quid pro quo. His office wrote that the suit was intended to make sure “that public funds are properly expended and not doled out as door prizes at the voting booth.”
While Paxton did not spell out in his filing what constituted the "disaster," the attorney general has long claimed that Harris County is a hotbed of voter fraud. In 2020, Paxton blocked Harris County from sending out millions of mail-in ballot applications to area voters — a step he told former Trump adviser Steve Bannon had kept Texas from going over to Biden.
Paxton’s language in these filings also echoed election denial claims made by a sitting member of the court who will now help adjudicate Paxton’s filing.
In a December speech, Texas Supreme Court Justice John Devine argued, without evidence, that there had been widespread voter fraud in Harris County in the 2020 presidential election.
Saying those elections had put in place “a corrupted government on a federal level run by a criminal enterprise,” Devine charged that Harris County’s reforms to voting measures during the COVID-19 pandemic were “an excuse to change election laws … so that the Democrats could cheat in Harris County.”
“This was a complete and total disaster,” Devine added. “This was completely bastardized right before everyone’s nose.”
Devine implied to the crowd that 2020 was prologue: Democrats were going to cheat in Harris County in 2024.
“Do you really think the Democrats are going to roll over and let Trump be president again? You think they’re just going to go away, all of a sudden find Jesus, and [that there will] be an honest election? I don’t think so.”
In a statement at the time, Menefee called these statements “shockingly inappropriate” given that the perennial litigation between state and county means that Harris County “has been and will continue to be before his court,” The Texas Tribune reported.
Menefee added that he hoped “Justice Devine acts with integrity and recuses himself from Harris County cases moving forward, but given his concession that he views himself as aiding Republicans in a ‘fight’ against Democrats, I won’t hold my breath.”
The Hill has reached out to Devine for comment. As of press time, the justice had not recused himself from the case.
Date: |
Filter
-
UK government’s climate action plan is unlawful, High Court rules
Judgment upholds four of five grounds for legal challenge brought by campaign groups against net zero strategyFinancial Times - World - United Kingdom -
Government defeated in High Court over climate plans
Activists argued that the plan for cutting emissions would not meet the UK's climate targets.BBC News - Top stories - Climate -
The UK government acted unlawfully in approving a climate plan, a High Court judge has ruled
A U.K. High Court judge has ruled that the government acted unlawfully when it approved a plan to meet climate targets without evidence it could be deliveredABC News - Tech - United Kingdom -
Kenya brings in emergency measures to combat ‘unprecedented’ floods
More than 200 dead and 160,000 displaced as torrential rain wreaks havoc in east African countryFinancial Times - World -
Flooding worsens in southeast Texas, forcing mandatory evacuations in some areas
River and lake levels are rising and are expected to crest Friday night as flooding gets worse in southeast Texas. Many roads in the region are swamped, making driving impossible.CBS News - Top stories -
A Chinese flavor of rap music is flourishing as emerging musicians find their voices
In 2018, the censors who oversee Chinese media issued a directive to the nation’s entertainment industryABC News - World -
A Chinese flavor of rap music is flourishing as emerging musicians find their voices
In 2018, the censors who oversee Chinese media issued a directive to the nation’s entertainment industryABC News - Entertainment -
College football transfer portal grades: Texas, FSU get 'A+' but LSU finishes with 'C+' after window closes
Handing out letter grades for a few of college football's marquee programsCBS Sports - Sports - College Football -
DOJ expected to announce indictment of Texas Democratic Rep. Henry Cuellar, sources say
Texas Democratic Rep. Henry Cuellar is expected to be indicted by the Justice Department.NBC News - Top stories -
Ruined centuries-old town re-emerges as Philippines dam dries up during heatwave
After a long spell of intense heat and little rain, water levels have fallen to reveal parts of a sunken church, tombstones and foundations at Pantabangan. Ruins of a centuries-old town have emerged at a dam parched by drought in the northern ...The Guardian - World
More from The Hill
-
Confusion and trade rules are speed bumps for Biden’s EV goals
If widespread EV adoption is truly a priority, then America’s trade policies, some of which Biden inherited and some of which are his own, need another look.The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
De Niro to Biden on Trump: 'Every chance you get, go at him'
Robert De Niro says President Biden should "keep up the fight" against former President Trump, advising the commander in chief to "go at him hard." "Keep at him," De Niro said when asked by Stephanie Ruhle on MSNBC's "The 11th Hour" on Thursday ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
UN ambassador condemns Gershkovich detention
United Nations ambassador Linda Thomas-Greenfield condemned the detention of Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich, who has been in Russian prison for over a year. “We gather here on the eve of World Press Freedom Day, an opportunity to ...The Hill - Politics - United Nations -
Government remains essential for the nation’s financial stability and prosperity
As we have detailed in our book, government has built our country by steering the market from the first presidential administration to the current one.The Hill - Politics -
Trump accuses judge of making hush money trial ‘as salacious as possible’
Former President Trump on Friday claimed the judge handling his hush money case was trying to make the trial "as salacious as possible," even as Trump's own attorneys sought to undermine a witness by bringing up celebrity scandals. "This Corrupt ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump