On his way out, AMLO is taking a wrecking-ball to Mexico's institutions
The future of democracy and the investment climate in Mexico are in peril at this moment. Lame-duck President Andrés Manuel López Obrador (known universally as AMLO) has a very clear roadmap to finish his tenure in the National Palace. He wants to consolidate his party's parliamentary supermajority, reform the judiciary and eliminate all the checks and balances.
Long story short, he wants to exterminate democracy in Mexico by installing a totalitarian regime in the style of Cuba, Nicaragua and Venezuela.
First, by creating new artificial seats in the legislative branch, AMLO has managed to ensure, through pressure and persuasion, more than 73 percent of seats in the Lower House. He is also attempting to undermine judicial independence by establishing the election of all judges by popular vote.
The Mexican government has claimed that these reforms would establish a judiciary with true independence and strengthen democracy. In practice, they would accomplish the opposite, while also lowering professional standards and creating vulnerabilities to political, economic and criminal organizations in a nation where drug cartels are still shockingly powerful.
Bank of America believes that the next 90 days, before AMLO leaves office and is replaced by his elected successor, Claudia Sheinbaum, will set the tone for Mexico's next 10 years. The report noted that AMLO's reforms are high-risk, affect the character of Mexico's democracy and will cause greater volatility in the markets.
Morgan Stanley also issued an underweight warning in Mexican shares due to concerns about the judicial reforms in particular. These changes may also increase uncertainty about the capital expenditure outlook amid bottlenecks in nearshoring capacity.
In short, the Cuban model is advancing in Mexico, under which a one-party state is everything and no constitutional guarantee is worth anything. According to article 94 of the Cuban Constitution, “Every person, as a guarantee of their legal security, enjoys due process in both the judicial and administrative spheres.” In practice, the supreme interest of the revolution tramples on all human rights.
In Venezuela, the Supreme Tribunal of Justice acts as a branch of the Bolivarian regime. This is the court that has validated the electoral fraud of Nicolás Maduro, calling his self-proclamation of victory unobjectionable and unappealable. The United Nations has made it clear that the rulings of this institution are not impartial nor credible.
In Nicaragua, the Supreme Court of Justice has been reduced to a dependency of the party and the family of dictator Daniel Ortega. Legal security vanished a long time ago. Confiscation of private property is the order of the day, despite being prohibited by Nicaragua's constitution.
AMLO’S plan seemed to be going full steam ahead, but a few days ago the Biden administration broke its long silence and warned of the great risks represented by these changes in the judiciary.
The U.S. ambassador to Mexico, Ken Salazar, said that popular direct elections of judges is a major risk to the functioning of Mexico’s democracy. “Any judicial reform should have the right kinds of safeguards that will ensure the judicial branch will be strengthened and not subject to the corruption of politics.” He also noted that the reform will threaten the historic trade relationship between Mexico and the U.S.
Democrats and Republicans in the Senate issued a joint statement. Senate Foreign Relations Chairman Ben Cardin (D-Md.) and Ranking Member Jim Risch (R-Idaho), along with Sens. Tim Kaine (D-Va) and Marco Rubio (R-Fla.), issued a statement expressing deep concern about proposed constitutional reforms in Mexico that would undermine judicial independence and risk violating the terms of the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Trade Agreement.
“We strongly urge the Lopez Obrador Administration, as well the incoming Sheinbaum Administration, to pursue only those reforms that enhance professional qualifications, combat corruption, protect judicial autonomy, and strengthen investors’ confidence.”
Mexico is on the wrong path. In regimes based on absolute power, legal certainty is the first victim of judicial reforms; the second is foreign investment; the third is the sacred right to private property.
In this model, it doesn't matter how much you know about the law, but who you know. In this scheme, everything would be resolved as it is in banana dictatorships.
Mexico, the top U.S. trade partner and one of the 12 largest economies in the world, deserves better — strong, robust and reliable institutions that confer legal certainty and economic predictability. Businesses need this, and democracy needs it even more.
Arturo McFields is an exiled journalist, former Nicaraguan ambassador to the OAS and former member of the Norwegian Peace Corps.
Date: |
Topics
-
ABC News - Sports
Chris Sale stymies Dodgers and Ohtani on his way to 17th win as Braves beat LA 10-1
Chris Sale allowed one run and struck out six over six innings, shutting down Shohei Ohtani in the process, for his major league-leading 17th win of the season as the Atlanta Braves beat the Los ...10 hours ago - MLB -
The Guardian - World
Real v fake: how the Harris-Trump debate laid out different takes on AI
One candidate revels in AI-generated images of cats and geese, while the other posts real photos of her grandparents. In their first, and likely only debate, Kamala Harris and Donald Trump argued ...7 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Yahoo News - World
SpaceX Polaris Dawn capsule safely splashes down in Gulf of Mexico
4 hours ago - Mexico -
The New York Times - Lifestyle
His Parents Are Susan Sarandon and Tim Robbins. That’s the Joke.
In a series of videos, Jack Robbins has been lampooning nepo baby culture — and embracing it — with help from his parents and Steven Spielberg’s daughter.September 3 -
ABC News - World
Tropical Storm Ileana makes landfall on Mexico's Sinaloa coast after pounding Los Cabos
Tropical Storm Ileana has made landfall on the coast of the Mexican state of Sinaloa a day after it pounded the resort-studded Los Cabos18 hours ago -
The New York Times - Top stories
Abortion vs. Border Security: New Mexico House Race Tests Dueling Messages
Representative Gabe Vasquez, a Democrat in a border district, is under attack by his Republican opponent on immigration policy. Can a pro-abortion access message help him prevail?9 hours ago - Abortion -
ESPN - Sports
Buffaloes take it 'personal,' dominate rival CSU
A week after losing to Nebraska, Colorado played its best game of the season, as Shedeur Sanders threw for 310 yards and four touchdowns in the Buffaloes' 28-9 victory over rival Colorado State.11 minutes ago -
The New York Times - Top stories
In ‘Matlock,’ Kathy Bates Takes One Last Case
The Oscar winner found surprising depths in this reboot of the beloved procedural, which she said will be her final job. “This is my last dance,” she said.5 days ago -
Yahoo Sports - Sports
Chase believes Bengals misled him about his extension this offseason
Ja'Marr Chase reportedly has no plans to negotiate new deal this season with Cincinnati.15 hours ago -
CBS News - Top stories
"Will & Harper": Will Ferrell embarks on a unique road trip with his best friend
Comedy legend Will Ferrell and former "SNL" head writer Harper Steele had been buddies since the mid-1990s. Two years ago, Steele announced that she had transitioned to a woman. How they approached ...4 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Map: Over 20 states have chance at seeing northern lights after solar flare
An intense solar flare could spark aurora chances across nearly half of the country late Sunday night -- here's what to know.1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
Shapiro on Harris’ chances in Pennsylvania: 'Every election is close’
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro (D) said Sunday that "every election is close in" his home state when asked about Vice President Harris' chances of winning. “How likely is it at this point that ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
Why isn’t Biden enforcing his own sanctions against Iran?
Without enforcement, new sanctions against Iran Air are just another paper tiger from the Biden administration.1 hour ago - Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Your old iPhone could be worth big bucks. Here's what to look for
The newest iPhone models are currently available for preorder, but it’s the older ones you might really want.1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
McClellan defends Democrats’ opposition to SAVE Act, calls it a ‘modern poll tax’
Rep. Jennifer McClellan (D-Va.) defended Democrats’ opposition to the SAVE Act, calling it a “modern poll tax,” in an interview on NewsNation’s “The Hill Sunday.” “The devil in that bill is in the ...2 hours ago