No Paris, no problem? The case for a conservative climate strategy.
![No Paris, no problem? The case for a conservative climate strategy.](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/07/paris_agreement-691257682.jpg?w=900)
If it wasn’t clear before Thursday night's debate, a second Trump presidency would bring an unsanctimonious end to U.S. inclusion in the current international framework for tackling climate change. Yet for all the planning around another exit from the Paris agreement by former President Donald Trump, his campaign owes America more than prose on clean air and water.
By articulating a counterstrategy that positions the U.S. at the forefront of efforts to slash global emissions, a future Trump administration would be set to reap massive economic and national security benefits.
Precedent shows that Trump’s willingness to “break glass” in international diplomacy may not be a misguided approach. Not every international institution is effectively managed and some, arguably, do not align with U.S. interests. In those instances, sudden exits or threatened exits from international frameworks can serve as an empowering diplomatic tactic.
For example, the Obama administration successfully drove consensus on the South Pacific Tuna Treaty by abruptly announcing a U.S. withdrawal from the treaty altogether. The Trump administration made similar progress by giving the Universal Postal Union an ultimatum requiring it to modernize a fee system that unfairly advantaged Beijing.
But even at times when disrupting the global status quo has upsides, these measures benefit from a complementary strategy for how to navigate the wake of such bold policy action — a plan for the days after.
Fashioning an international climate strategy isn’t just a means of contributing to global sustainability goals. It’s also a critical component of retaining America’s competitiveness across all sectors of the U.S. economy. In today’s world, far more so than during the first Trump administration, the failure to develop such an approach would empower U.S. adversaries and produce unnecessary headwinds for many other U.S. foreign policy priorities — not the least of which is to counter Chinese influence.
Global dynamics have changed dramatically since Trump stood in the Rose Garden in June 2017 and announced the U.S. withdrawal from the Paris climate accord. Russia’s flagrant violation of Ukraine’s sovereignty has since rewritten the script of European security. Europe is no longer balking at U.S. natural gas but embracing it as a central pillar of its strategy to stabilize and grow its economy. The continent, under a flood of Chinese electric vehicles, is also awakening to the risk of overreliance on Beijing.
Through all of this, however, a prevailing majority of Europeans still see climate change as a serious threat. Given these developments, a major shift in the U.S. government’s global climate policy without a well-articulated plan to replace the existing framework may unnecessarily ignite the ire of U.S. allies at the exact moment when they're predisposed to firmly enter America’s orbit.
This point should not be mistaken for a plea to remain in the Paris agreement. It is, rather, an acknowledgement that U.S. climate and clean energy policy will still be critical in fostering international partnerships that are essential to advancing long-standing elements of the Republican foreign policy and economic agenda.
Today, for example, the European Union is exploring ways to strengthen its own defense-industrial base — a precursor to a more stable path future for NATO. A second Trump administration may very well be in position to take that policy win over the line. Why jeopardize impending success for the sake of scoring short-term political points on jettisoning U.S. climate leadership?
Notably, these perspectives aren’t unique to Europe. In Dubai last year, the UAE marshalled a global commitment to accelerate paths towards “net zero emission energy systems.” This international milestone illustrates that Trump’s economic ambitions require more than “dominance” over oil and gas alone. China, for its part, has embraced this outlook, actively establishing a firm grasp over clean energy supply chains. Overcoming Beijing’s head start should be a priority for any U.S. administration.
Trump’s decision to exit the Paris pact in 2017 may have checked the box on a campaign promise, but the absence of a cohesive counterstrategy to a growing and global effort to transform the world’s energy system left a policy vacuum that was quickly filled by competing international voices. Climate activist Greta Thunberg led the charge on a “green wave” that swept across Europe while Chinese President Xi Jinping embarked on a climate charm offensive despite his country simultaneously supporting the construction of nearly two new coal-fired power plants every week.
Most of all, the U.S. decision to leave Paris did not change the trajectory of the global energy mix, which continues to decarbonize even as oil and gas remain the anchor of the global economy.
A potential second Trump administration, therefore, would be wise to fixate less on a symbolic exit from the Paris agreement and more on articulating a credible international climate strategy that embraces the energy transition in a manner that empowers U.S. economic growth and national security. Such a strategy is an opportunity to emphasize longstanding conservative policy.
That includes accelerating the deployment of breakthrough technology where China has yet to gain a foothold and configuring global supply chains to ensure long-term U.S. leadership across all energy sectors — oil, gas, nuclear and renewable energy alike.
Landon Derentz is the Atlantic Council’s Morningstar Chair for Global Energy Security and senior director of the Global Energy Center. He was director for energy at the White House from April 2018 to November 2019.
Date: | |
Tag: | Climate |
Filter
-
Yahoo Sports - Sports
Kerr's comedic strategy for possible matchup with Atkinson in Olympics
Steve Kerr is looking forward to potentially facing off against former assistant coach Kenny Atkinson in the Paris Olympics. -
Financial Times - World
Can the market fix climate change?
Also in this newsletter: French horse-trading, Biden under pressure, inflation slows across EuropeClimate -
CNBC - Business
This 'bucket strategy' could lower your taxes in retirement — here's how to maximize it
Most Americans aren't planning to reduce taxes on retirement income. Here's how the "bucket strategy" could help, experts say. -
The Hill - Politics
The internet’s oldest problem is also its youngest: Child safety
For almost 25 years, there’s been a major effort to address the issue of children’s safety on the Internet, but a major obstacle has continuously impeded this effort: effectively identifying who is an adult and who is a child. -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Modi's Ruling BJP Party in India Has a Diversity Problem
The prime minister needs to muster support from Indians who aren’t Hindus to secure his legacy.India -
The Wall Street Journal - World
LNG Exports Could Be a Boon for Climate and Security
If only the Biden administration can put good policy above the word of green activists and TikTok influencers.Climate -
CBS News - Top stories
How to talk to kids about climate change
Recent studies show that kids are increasingly becoming concerned about the effects of climate change. Elizabeth Bagley, the managing director at Project Drawdown, joins CBS News with tips on how to talk to children about the future of the planet.Climate -
The New York Times - Lifestyle
High Jewelry Shines During Paris Couture Week
Hermès embraced color, Piaget went for texture and Boucheron used technology to capture ocean waves. -
ABC News - Entertainment
Why was it a surprise? Biden's debate problems leave some wondering if the press missed the story
Did the media covering President Biden miss a story that was right in front of themJoe Biden -
MarketWatch - Business
Hurricane Beryl puts focus on oil with climate change likely to intensify storms
Even though Hurricane Beryl is predicted to miss most of the offshore oil rigs in the Gulf of Mexico, the U.S. energy industry is on high alert over climate change and the risk of more frequent, more intense storms posing a growing challenge for ...Climate
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
California Democrat says Biden campaign 'arrogant' after debate
Rep. Scott Peters (D-Calif.) says the Biden campaign has been “arrogant” since a shaky debate performance by the president last week. “As much as I love Joe Biden, in those swing states, he's having a hard time,” Peters said Wednesday in an ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Third House Democrat says Biden should bow out of presidential race
Rep. Seth Moulton (Mass.) on Thursday became the third House Democrat to publicly call on President Biden to step out of the presidential race after a weak debate performance last week that left his allies shaken. “President Biden has done ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Biden says he was seen by doctor after debate and is fine
President Biden told Democratic governors that he saw a doctor after his shaky debate performance last week and was given a clean bill of health. The comments, first reported by Politico, apparently contradict White House press secretary Karine ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
I’m Gen Z. Here’s how I’m escaping my phone this summer.
Gen Z is experiencing a barrage of notifications and ads on social media, but museums offer a slower, more thoughtful approach to sharing information, providing a respite from the fast-paced online world. -
The Hill - Politics
Students at fake university created by ICE can sue US, court rules
Students who enrolled in a fake university set up by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) as part of a sting operation can sue the U.S., an appeals court ruled last week. The ruling by a three-judge panel of the Federal Circuit Court of ...