No one has exclusive claim to the Holy Land
They won’t like hearing it, but the loudest supporters of both sides of the Israel/Palestine conflict are misguided. The struggle is not an existential clash of civilizations, competing nationalisms or religious fundamentalism vs. liberal democracy. Even comparative devastation — horrific, albeit asymmetrical, what some have called a competitive “Olympics of suffering” — is not the key issue.
At the risk of being unduly reductive, this struggle is one of territory; literally, the soil — the soil of homeland, not just dirt. From the perspective of 30,000 feet and 3,000 years of history, no one has an exclusive claim to the Holy Land.
Since the territory between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea was at the crossroads of empires, it has always been a strife-torn neighborhood. Stripped of current incendiary rhetoric, the historical conflict is a turf battle over real estate. The Book of Deuteronomy says the struggle began when formerly enslaved Hebrews led by Joshua arrived from Egypt and fought the Canaanites.
Formal, prior nationhood is often cited as a contemporary claim. But each tribe in the land — Jews and pagans — had their petty kings and dynasties that rose and fell, both before and after Israelites arrived.
In following millennia, the contested land was never an empty “land without a people.” There were indigenous Israelites, Judeans, Idumeans, Samaritans, Phoenicians, Philistines, etc. Each tribe made divine claims to the land. All built temples and shrines and made sacrifices.
The Israelites believed the Hebrew God gave the land to them, building two temples to establish their title. Thus, West Bank settlers today claim the Torah is their divine “deed.” This mirrors Osama bin Laden’s resurfaced claim that Allah willed the land to Muslims, who built the Dome of the Rock and Al-Aqsa to cement their claim.
Jews ruled parts of the land for more than 2,500 years. Then, after the Greek and Roman periods, the Arabs and later Ottoman Muslims ruled it for 1,300 years. Two failed revolts against Rome, the Muslim conquest and the Crusades reduced but never erased Jewish presence in Israel.
With Zionism’s late-19th-century emergence, Jewish “pioneers” began trickling in from Eastern Europe, often buying land from absentee Ottoman landowners. Jewish philanthropists like the Montefiores and Rothschilds financed some purchases. Understandably, by the early 20th century, fear of displacement kindled Palestinian nationalism, anti-Jewish ethnic strife and anti-colonialism — sometimes violently.
Yet, on reflection, the issue is not superior divine claim or historical tenure. Absent an equitable territorial-sharing consensus or prospect, the issue has become one of military might.
The Palestinian relationship with Nazi Germany explains some of the Jewish animus. The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, who had incited the 1929 antisemitic Hebron massacre and the 1936 Arab Revolt, visited Berlin during World War II and supported Hitler. Palestinians did not build Nazi gas chambers, but they partially paid the price for them in the 1948 war, battling Jewish concentration camp survivors wanting a haven.
The 1948 Israeli/Arab fighting saw massacres on both sides (trading atrocities is unhelpful here). Jews drove hundreds of thousands of Palestinians from their homes and villages; more were displaced after the Six Day War. After that war, the leaders of Muslim-majority nations expelled Mizrahi and Sephardi Jews from their age-old homes in North African and Middle Eastern countries.ThesehomelessJews also sought refuge in Israel.
The answer seems to be a shared land agreement. Sadly, a definitive territorial settlement now appears politically impossible for both sides.
For a workable two-state solution, the West Bank portion of any Palestinian state would have to roughly comprise the pre-1967 Green Line division, including East Jerusalem. Most of the hundreds of thousands of Israeli settlers (and voters) on this territory, some now engaged in a murderous terror campaign against their Palestinian neighbors, would have to leave — a nonstarter for any elected Israeli government.
For the Palestinians, any two-state territorial agreement would have to be recognized and final. It could not be an irredentist “first stage” in reclaiming all the pre-1948 Mandatory Palestine, “from the river to the sea.” Militant Palestinian nationalists would reject this. Internecine struggle with moderates, perhaps a civil war, could follow. The Palestinian Authority is now widely acknowledged as sclerotic, corrupt and incompetent. Who would manage this strife?
The next stage in such an imagined solution requires a complete revisioning of region governance. Clearly, no constituency for either concession presently exists.
So where does that leave Jews and Muslims in the United States? Will we be driven into crude tribalism, forced to root for our respective “sides” as spectators, or in the streets or on campuses, with most Jews supporting Israel and most Muslim and Arab-Americans supporting the Palestinian cause? Each without acknowledging the other’s pain and loss, except perfunctorily, in passing, while making our argument?
Or can we convince more strident American voices on each side to lower the rhetoric and advocate for a more even-handed approach to an eventual territorial settlement?
Ultimately, we need a resolution involving peaceful land sharing. The cost of failure is incalculable, and success would mean a lasting peace for Israel.
With a comprehensive settlement, even now-desolate Gaza has viable economic potential as part of a Palestinian state. Some fertile, richly cultivated acreage exists there. A major infrastructure effort, including new high-rise public housing and sewage treatments plants, could provide much-needed jobs, eventually closing refugee camps.
Gaza once had luxury beachfront hotels. Beachfront building and rebuilding could create a viable tourist industry. Even the surviving, vaunted Hamas tunnels could become tourist attractions, like those in Cu Chi in Vietnam.
Gaza doesn’t have to be “an open-air prison.” Although it could take decades, Palestinian brain power, with adequate outside help, could turn Gaza into a Mediterranean Singapore.
Mark I. Pinsky is a journalist and the author of seven nonfiction books, including “A Jew Among the Evangelicals: A Guide for the Perplexed.”
Date: |
Topics
Filter
-
No One Knows How Far Bird Flu Has Spread
With little incentive for US farmers to test their cattle, and many undocumented laborers on dairy farms, the full scale of the outbreak is unclear.Wired - Tech -
Hope Hicks: Trump was worried about WSJ article’s effect on Melania
Donald Trump’s former communications director testifies that he worried about Wall Street Journal article about purchase of Stormy Daniels and Karen McDougal stories. Trump trial continues with judge dismissing claims that ex-president can’t ...The Guardian - World - Donald Trump -
Paul Walter Hauser Lands Mystery Role In The Fantastic Four
Marvel's upcoming Fantastic Four reboot is beginning to fill out the rest of its cast, and now Emmy-winner Paul Walter Hauser is the latest addition. Via Deadline, Hauser's role is currently undisclosed, so he could be playing a friend or foe to ...GameSpot - Tech -
‘It’s like winning the lottery’: the mobile home owners buying the land they live on
Residents of manufactured housing parks typically own their homes – but not the parks themselves, which can be incredibly lucrative. Now some residents are forming cooperatives, and taking control. This story is co-published with the Lever, a ...The Guardian - World -
Ohio State lands Duke transfer F Sean Stewart as Buckeyes reload frontcourt with promising prospects
Stewart is the latest high-upside addition to an Ohio State frontcourt losing two key piecesCBS Sports - Sports -
The Unfortunate Reality Facing One of Baseball’s Best Players
Mike Trout seems destined to spend his entire career with the Angels. That’s horrifying, a columnist from The Athletic writes.The New York Times - Sports -
In Super Metroid, No One Can Hear You Scream
Super Metroid recently celebrated its 30-year anniversary. Below, we look back at how it used and helped to create horror game tropes.It begins with a benign pulse over black. An otherworldly synth shriek interrupting. Random shots of dead ...GameSpot - Tech -
Here's where the jobs are for April 2024 — in one chart
Health care and social assistance led the way, while construction hiring slowed.CNBC - Business -
Estonia's border city of Narva, singled out by Putin as historically Russian land, is among potential Baltic targets for destabilization by Moscow should the Russian leader further test the West's political and military resolve.
Estonia’s border city of Narva, singled out by Putin as historically Russian land, is among potential Baltic targets for destabilization by Moscow should the Russian leader further test the West’s political and military resolve.The Wall Street Journal - World - Russia -
Beyoncé Has Finally Changed Fashion
It’s now impossible to see a cowboy hat or pair of cowboy boots and not think of her.The New York Times - Lifestyle
More from The Hill
-
‘America First’ conservatives aren’t putting American workers first
We know these senators aren’t on the side of the American worker, which begs the question — whose side are they on? The answer is obvious: people and corporations with money.The Hill - Politics -
Education secretary condemns 'abhorrent' antisemitic incidents on campus
Education Secretary Miguel Cardona sent a letter Friday to college and university presidents condemning what he called “abhorrent” antisemitic incidents on campus, the latest response from the Biden administration to the ongoing nationwide ...The Hill - Politics -
Chris Christie: ‘More likely than not’ Stephen A. Smith runs for president
Former GOP presidential candidate and New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie claimed that its “more likely than not” that sports commentator Stephen A. Smith runs for president in the future. “I don’t think it’s imminent, but will he run someday? I think ...The Hill - Politics -
White House shakes up its immigration team
The White House is shaking up its roster of immigration advisers, bringing in a top border enforcement policy leader and a development expert to round out its team. Blas Nuñez-Neto comes to the White House from the Department of Homeland Security ...The Hill - Politics -
Jean-Pierre: 'Admirable' for UNC students to hold up American flag during campus protest
The White House on Friday praised the actions of a group of University of North Carolina students who held up the American flag at a protest on campus over the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza. Press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre was asked during a ...The Hill - Politics