No, asylum-seekers are not invading the country
A slew of executive orders in the first week of Donald Trump’s second presidential term are predicated on his proclamation that “an invasion is ongoing at the southern border.” He has invoked emergency powers on this basis.
We are already witnessing the shutdown of asylum processing at the border, the deployment of the military to seal the border, the first arrests of Trump’s promised “mass deportations” and the transfer of migrants to the U.S. naval base at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba.
Putting aside the obvious fact that no foreign country is mounting an attack on the United States, even the more metaphorical notion of an invasion of undocumented foreigners is simply not true. Even Homeland Security’s implementation of a memo for the executive orders has acknowledged “a major reduction” in recent border crossings.
Many of the people who entered the U.S. unlawfully during the past decade, including many families with children, promptly presented themselves to the first Border Patrol agents they encountered. Not intending to do any harm, they crossed the border illegally because of the lack of legal pathways. The numbers were large, but it was not an "invasion."
What was needed were more asylum officers and immigration judges to process protection cases and simpler, clearer standards for deciding claims fairly and efficiently, as well as a more clear-eyed recognition of U.S. labor needs.
Amy Pope, director general of the International Organization for Migration, a United Nations agency, wrote recently that “The demand for H-2B visas … the main visa for low-skilled nonagricultural workers … has rocketed,” and “the industries supposed to benefit from them have faced unprecedented shortfalls in the last several years” because U.S. labor-visa caps have been kept so low.
Last year, a significant change took place in the number of people entering the country irregularly. Department of Homeland Security statistics showed a more than 60 percent decrease in Border Patrol “encounters” between ports of entry along the southwest border from May to December. As the Biden administration opened legal pathways, irregular encounters dropped.
A Pew Research Center analysis of U.S. Border Patrol statistics found huge drops in southwestern border-crosser encounters between December 2023 and August 2024 for the four nationalities that had been provided the safe and legal mechanism of humanitarian parole. During the period when members of these nationality groups — Cubans, Haitians, Nicaraguans and Venezuelans — could be vetted, sponsored, and allowed orderly entry to the U.S. interior, Border Patrol encounters dropped 99, 98, 97, and 96 percent, respectively.
Yet, Trump terminated these programs on Inauguration Day by executive order, and this week his administration canceled the extension of temporary protected status for more than 300,000 Venezuelans who soon will be at risk of being returned to the same dangerous conditions from which they fled.
If “invasion” implies chaotic, irregular entry, ending humanitarian parole is more likely to foment it. So are indefinite suspension of all refugee admissions and the closure of "safe mobility offices" in Latin America to identify and safely process refugees, including reunifying separated parents and children.
Another change that portends disorder is the end of the program that used a phone application to schedule appointments for asylum-seekers at U.S. ports of entry along the southern border because people fleeing life-threatening conditions will take desperate measures to seek safety when legal avenues are closed.
These orders authorize ham-fisted responses to the very chaos they will provoke. One order specifies that “use of force policies prioritize the safety and security of Department of Homeland Security personnel and of members of the Armed Forces,” an invitation to law enforcement officers and soldiers to draw their weapons, which they are more likely to do when the president simultaneously announces, “America’s sovereignty is under attack.”
Trump’s rhetoric evokes a country overrun and besieged. It isn’t true. The U.S. government is fully capable of providing both security and compassion.
The danger posed by the rhetoric of invasion is not only to the migrants and refugees who will impale themselves on the razor-wire border fences intended to keep them out but also to the Americans living on the other side of the wall.
As police and immigration agents storm churches and schools, and as county jails, private for-profit detention centers and military bases fill and expand with potentially hundreds of thousands of indefinitely detained people, the public may begin to ponder the words of Timothy Snyder in his book, “On Tyranny": "[W]hen leaders are able to convince people they are living in a state of emergency, citizens then trade real freedom for fake safety.”
Bill Frelick is the longtime refugee and migrant rights director at Human Rights Watch.
-
Fifty countries affected by USAID freeze, says WHO
HIV treatments and other services have been disrupted, says Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus.BBC News - 3h -
Vance out of the country ahead of Gabbard confirmation vote
Politico - 2d -
Asylum seeker taken into custody during Denver ICE raid
Luis Fernando says his brother was taken into custody by ICE agents and is being held despite showing them court paperwork showing he is an asylum seeker. KUSA's Angeline McCall reports.NBC News - 2d -
Record number of asylum seekers died in 2024 while in care of Home Office
Data obtained by the Guardian shows 51 people died in Home Office provided accommodation in 2024. A record number of asylum seekers died last year while in the care of the Home Office, according to ...The Guardian - 2d -
Trump wants to end birthright citizenship. Where do other countries stand?
The US has historically given automatic citizenship to anyone born in the country, but this principle is not the norm globally.BBC News - 2d -
Chile issues evacuation alerts as wildfires rage in the country's south
Chilean authorities have issued two evacuation alerts for the southern region of La Araucanía as wildfires continue to rageABC News - 2d -
Trump's national security adviser: 'I don't think there's any plans to invade Canada'
President Donald Trump’s national security adviser Mike Waltz told NBC News’ “Meet the Press” on Sunday he doesn’t think the president has “any plans to invade Canada.”NBC News - 3d -
‘Backsliding’: most countries to miss vital climate deadline as Cop30 nears
Developing countries urge biggest polluters to act as Trump’s return to the White House heightens geopolitical turmoil. The vast majority of governments are likely to miss a looming deadline to ...The Guardian - 4d
More from The Hill
-
Lawyer for Vince McMahon says criminal probe 'definitively concluded' with no charges
A lawyer for Vince McMahon said Wednesday that Manhattan federal prosecutors have dropped their criminal probe into whether the World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE) co-founder attempted to cover up ...The Hill - 28m -
Evening Report — House, Senate GOP duel over budget path
Presented by March of Dimes — The race is on between Republican leaders in the House and Senate to see who can be first to create a budget with the greatest likelihood of passing President Trump’s ...The Hill - 29m -
House Commerce chair launches data privacy working group
House Committee on Energy and Commerce Chair Brett Guthrie (R-Ky.) on Wednesday announced the creation of a data privacy working group as policymakers work toward a national privacy standard. “We ...The Hill - 38m -
Education Department launches Title IX probes over trans athlete policies
The Department of Education announced on Wednesday it is investigating two state athletic associations that say they will not abide by the Trump administration's Title IX rules that forbid ...The Hill - 41m -
Trump says he expects to meet with Putin in Saudi Arabia
President Trump said Wednesday he expects to meet in person with Russian President Vladimir Putin multiple times, suggesting they are likely to meet first in Saudi Arabia. “We ultimately expect to ...The Hill - 49m
More in Politics
-
Lawyer for Vince McMahon says criminal probe 'definitively concluded' with no charges
A lawyer for Vince McMahon said Wednesday that Manhattan federal prosecutors have dropped their criminal probe into whether the World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE) co-founder attempted to cover up ...The Hill - 28m -
Evening Report — House, Senate GOP duel over budget path
Presented by March of Dimes — The race is on between Republican leaders in the House and Senate to see who can be first to create a budget with the greatest likelihood of passing President Trump’s ...The Hill - 29m -
House Commerce chair launches data privacy working group
House Committee on Energy and Commerce Chair Brett Guthrie (R-Ky.) on Wednesday announced the creation of a data privacy working group as policymakers work toward a national privacy standard. “We ...The Hill - 38m -
Education Department launches Title IX probes over trans athlete policies
The Department of Education announced on Wednesday it is investigating two state athletic associations that say they will not abide by the Trump administration's Title IX rules that forbid ...The Hill - 41m -
Trump has a ‘real opportunity’ to bring Putin and Zelenskyy to a peace deal: Amb. Bill Taylor
Former U.S. Ambassador to Ukraine Bill Taylor joins Meet the Press NOW as President Trump announces initial talks to negotiate an end to the war in Ukraine. NBC News correspondents Gabe Gutierrez ...NBC News - 48m