Newsom vetoes bill for stricter AI regulations
California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) on Sunday vetoed a landmark artificial intelligence (AI) bill that would have created new safety rules for the emerging tech, handing much of Silicon Valley a major win.
Newsom’s veto caps off weeks of skepticism over how he would act on the controversial legislation, known as California Senate Bill 104, or the Safe and Secure Innovation for Frontier Artificial Intelligence Models Act.
In a veto message published Sunday, the governor said the bill's focus on the “most expensive and large-scale models” “could give the public a false sense of security about controlling” AI.
“Smaller, specialized models may emerge equally or even more dangerous than the models targeted by SB 1074 – at the potential expense of curtailing the very innovation that fuels advancement in favor of the public good,” he wrote.
The legislation was sent to his desk late last month after it passed the state Legislature, and his veto came just a day before the Monday deadline.
The bill, also called SB 1047, would have required powerful AI models to undergo safety testing before being released to the public. This might include, for example, testing whether their models can be manipulated to hack into the state’s electric grid.
It also intended to hold developers liable for severe harm caused by their models but would have only applied to AI systems that cost more than $100 million to train. No current models have hit that number yet.
“While well-intentioned, SB 1047 does not take into account whether an AI system is deployed in high-risk environments, involves critical decision-making or the use of sensitive data,” Newsom wrote. “Instead, the bill applies stringent standards to even the most basic functions – so as long as a large system deploys it.”
Newsom has often indicated skepticism about reining in AI technology, which stands to bring large amounts of money to the Golden State. California is home to 32 of the world’s “50 leading AI companies,” according to Newsom’s office, and has become a major hub for AI-related legislation as a result.
The governor stressed his veto does not mean he does not agree with the author's argument that there is an urgent need to act on the advancing tech to prevent major catastrophe.
“California will not abandon its responsibility,” he said, adding, “Proactive guardrails should be implemented and severe consequences for bad actors must be clear and enforceable.”
Any solution, Newsom argued, should be informed by an “empirical trajectory analysis” of AI systems and their capabilities.
The bill received mixed opinions from AI startups, major technology firms, researchers and even some lawmakers who were divided over whether it would throttle the development of the technology or establish much-needed guardrails.
Those on both sides of the argument have piled on pressure on Newsom over the past few months.
Several of the country's leading tech firms, including OpenAI, Google and Meta – the parent company of Facebook and Instagram – expressed concerns the legislation would have targeted developers rather than the abusers of AI and argued safety regulations for the technology should be decided on a federal level.
Meanwhile, Anthropic, a leading AI startup, said last month the benefits of the bill likely would have outweighed the risks.
Last week, more than 120 Hollywood figures wrote an open letter pushing him to sign the legislation, writing the “most powerful AI models may soon pose severe risks.” Earlier this month, over 100 current or former employees of leading AI companies – including OpenAI, Anthropic, Google’s DeepMind and Meta – also wrote to Newsom, warning of these same risks.
Congressional lawmakers joined the debate too, with former Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) and some other California politicians coming out against the bill. Pelosi last month said “many” in Congress viewed the legislation as “well-intentioned but ill informed.”
Newsom pushed back on the argument that California should not have a role in a bill with nationwide implications.
“A California-only approach may well be warranted – especially absent federal action by Congress – but it must be based on empirical evidence and science,” he said, pointing to the federal and state-based risk analyses currently being done on AI.
The governor signed a series of other bills earlier this month aimed at preventing abuses of AI and placing guardrails on the emerging tech.
Three of these bills are aimed at preventing the misuse of sexually explicit deepfakes, which can generate images, audio, and video and digitally alter likenesses and voices. He signed two other bills aimed at protecting actors and performers from having their names, images and likenesses copied by artificial intelligence without authorization.
Date: |
Topics
-
Tech - The Wall Street Journal
California's Gavin Newsom Vetoes Controversial AI Safety Bill
The governor is seeking more encompassing rules than the bill opposed by OpenAI and Meta, and supported by research scientists.7 hours ago - California -
Entertainment - Los Angeles Times
Gov. Gavin Newsom vetoes AI safety bill opposed by Silicon Valley
Gov. Gavin Newsom vetoed AI safety bill SB-1047, which was opposed by tech companies including ChatGPT maker OpenAI and Facebook parent company Meta.7 hours ago -
World - The Guardian
California won’t require big tech firms to test safety of AI after Newsom kills bill
Governor vetoes bill that would require generative AI safety testing after tech industry says it’d drive companies away. California governor Gavin Newsom on Sunday vetoed a hotly contested ...5 hours ago - California -
Business - Financial Times
California governor vetoes bill to regulate artificial intelligence
Gavin Newsom agreed with leading AI companies that the legislation would have stifled innovation5 hours ago - California -
Tech - ABC News
California governor vetoes bill to create first-in-nation AI safety measures
California Gov. Gavin Newsom has vetoed a landmark bill aimed at establishing first-in-the-nation safety measures for large artificial intelligence models4 hours ago - California -
Top stories - CBS News
California governor vetoes first-in-nation AI safety bill
Gov. Gavin Newsom on Sunday vetoed a landmark bill aimed at establishing first-in-the-nation safety measures for large artificial intelligence models.6 hours ago - California -
Tech - ABC News
California governor vetoes bill that would have set first-in-the-nation AI safety measures
California governor vetoes bill that would have set first-in-the-nation AI safety measures7 hours ago - California -
Tech - ABC News
California governor signs bills to protect children from AI deepfake nudes
California Gov. Gavin Newsom signed the two proposals.3 hours ago - California
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Harris presses Trump to debate again: VP showdown ‘should not be the last word’
Vice President Kamala Harris on Sunday re-upped her calls for a second debate with former President Trump as she courted voters in the critical swing state of Nevada two days before the first vice ...29 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Biden says he'll speak with Netanyahu soon amid fears of a wider war
President Biden said on Sunday that he would speak with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and said he thinks a broader war in the region “has to be” avoided. “It has to be,” Biden said, ...49 minutes ago - Joe Biden -
Politics - The Hill
Emhoff: Trump vow to protect women 'is yet more lies and more gaslighting'
Second Gentleman Doug Emhoff said former President Trump’s vow to protect women “is yet more lies and more gaslighting,” in a Sunday interview on MSNBC’s “Inside with Jen Psaki.” In a discussion ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Zelensky says his latest US trip 'saved bipartisan support of Ukraine'
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky touted his latest U.S. trip as a success, emphasizing the bipartisan nature of the meetings, in an interview Sunday. “I think that we saved bipartisan support ...2 hours ago - Ukraine -
Politics - The Hill
3 California firefighters injured in crash en route to hurricane response
Three members of a California search and rescue team were injured in a vehicle crash Sunday morning as they were driving cross-country to support Hurricane Helene relief efforts in North Carolina. ...4 hours ago - California