NATO doubles down on its containment-plus Russia policy
At this week’s summit in Washington, NATO will celebrate 75 years of the most effective defensive alliance in modern history. Alliance leaders seem likely to recommit to what amounts to a “containment-plus” policy toward Russia.
A containment-plus policy seeks to stop or limit some of Russia’s harmful activities, such as evading oil sanctions and preventing Russian sabotage in Europe, and to roll back others, such as its occupation of parts of Ukraine.
Russia’s attempt to subjugate Ukraine is a direct threat to the security of Europe, and NATO members are confronting it. NATO and its members seek not just to hold aggression in check, but to roll back Moscow’s conquests in Ukraine and its expanding hybrid war in Europe.
This is the right policy, so long as Russia is ruled by a regime as aggressive and oppressive as President Vladimir Putin’s. As our colleague former U.S. ambassador to NATO Alexander Vershbow wrote last year, “Russia needs to understand that there can be no normalization of relations until it once again upholds the fundamental principles laid down in the 1975 Helsinki Final Act, the 1990 Paris Charter and the 1997 NATO-Russia Founding Act.”
Legendary career diplomat George Kennan, the intellectual father of post-World War II containment policy, wrote in 1947 that “the main element of any U.S. policy toward the Soviet Union must be that of long-term, patient but firm and vigilant containment of Russian expansive tendencies.”
Sadly, this approach is needed again today to deal with Putin’s imperial and revanchist dreams. NATO and its members need again to bear the burden of what President John Kennedy called the “long, twilight struggle.” More is required now to help Ukraine roll back Russia’s military assault on its independence and territorial integrity.
Consider four decades ago, when the USSR invaded Afghanistan, threatened militarily to suppress a popular movement for more freedoms in Poland and secretly deployed a new intermediate-range missile against Europe and Japan.
The Carter and Reagan administrations responded forcefully. The U.S. aided the Afghan resistance and supported the Solidarity free trade union in Poland. And NATO deployed missiles to counter Soviet SS-20s. These steps were more akin to a “roll back” than to trying to stem further aggression.
Today’s threats bear similarities, and so do the policies of NATO and its members. In response to Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, the U.S. and its allies have steadily expanded the quantity and quality of military aid. Allies are acting despite persistent Russian warnings of adverse consequences, even irresponsible nuclear threats.
In a June TIME interview, President Biden said “peace” meant making sure Russia never occupied Ukraine. In this spirit, Secretary of State Antony Blinken speaks of “taking the fight as necessary to Russia.”
Most recently, the U.S. has allowed Ukraine to fire U.S.-produced tactical missiles across the border into Russia at forces that are attacking or about to attack Ukraine. Yet, this still leaves a sanctuary beyond which Ukrainians are eager to strike.
In another containment-plus policy, the allies are making substantial use of sanctions. Russia’s economic output is over 5 percent smaller than foreseen before the full-scale war began. Underinvestment, slow productivity growth and labor shortages drag down the economy. The U.S. and the EU are rolling out new sanctions.
Russia is responding. Putin has put the country on a war footing; some one-third of Russia’s budget now goes to defense. Russia is having some success in sanctions evasion. A recent Kremlin reshuffle seems aimed at developing a more efficient military sector.
Russia is engaging in stepped-up subterfuge against allies in Europe. Outgoing NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg warns of a surge in hostile hybrid threats, including disinformation, sabotage, arson and cyberattacks.
The Washington Post’s David Ignatius has written that the U.S. is working with allies to counter this shadowy surge. It is sharing more intelligence to prevent sabotage of supplies destined for Ukraine and countering disinformation through proactive and open public communications, to get ahead of its spread.
The summit might also consider how to respond to Russia’s heightened nuclear threats, movement of nuclear weapons into Belarus and secret deployment of intermediate-range missiles. Putin evidently thinks he can scare Ukraine and its Western supporters, but they cooperate and raise the ante against Russian aggression.
Finally, NATO and its members will have to deal with Putin’s cultivation of ties with Chinese Premier Xi Jinping and Russia’s growing dependence on Iran and North Korea. Of special concern are technologies and weapons that can help Russia’s war effort.
The summit will have a complex Russian agenda. The alliance is challenged to come up with new approaches to deal with Moscow's rogue behavior and an international order that is becoming more complex and less stable.
John Tefft is a distinguished chair in diplomacy and security at RAND and former U.S. ambassador to Russia, Ukraine, Georgia and Lithuania. William Courtney is an adjunct senior fellow at RAND and a former U.S. ambassador to Kazakhstan and Georgia, and to a U.S.-Soviet nuclear testing commission.
Date: | |
Tag: | Russia |
Topics
-
NBC News - Politics
Project 2025 winding down policy work following criticism from Trump
The Heritage Foundation official leading Project 2025 is stepping down and the group is winding down its policy work following sustained criticism by former President Donald Trump and his campaign.6 hr ago - Donald Trump -
CNBC - Business
Japan's central bank starts its monetary policy meeting today. Here's what's in focus
Traders will be on the lookout for moves in two areas, namely, the bank's benchmark interest rates and its bond buying programme5 hr ago -
CBS Sports - Sports
Breaking down historic QB contracts given to Jordan Love and Tua Tagovailoa, plus Cowboys have crazy weekend
Here's everything you need to know about the NFL for July 2913 hr ago - NFL -
BBC News - Top stories
'Fire devils' spotted as California fire doubles in size
Firefighters battle a growing wildfire, the largest blaze in California this year.12 hr ago - California -
The Hill - Politics
How to watch the double meteor showers tonight
Two meteor showers will overlap over southern skies tonight. Here is where they'll be most visible.12 hr ago -
ESPN - Sports
Murray extends Olympic farewell with doubles win
Andy Murray continues to stave off his planned retirement from tennis as he and Team GB playing partner, Dan Evans, won their second-round match in the Paris Olympics men's doubles tournament on Tuesday.3 hr ago -
ABC News - Tech
How Harris and Trump differ on artificial intelligence policy
Artificial intelligence’s growing visibility in everyday life has made it a popular discussion topic but hasn’t yet elevated it to a top election concern for American voters19 hr ago - Donald Trump -
Financial Times - Business
The self-contradicting mess of Republican foreign policy
American populists oppose China but like pro-Beijing strongmen19 hr ago -
Inc. - Business
AI Policy: Where Trump and Harris Stand
The major presidential candidates have backing from different ends of the Silicon Valley political spectrum, but it's still unclear how that would translate into AI regulation and safety legislation.11 hr ago - Donald Trump -
The New York Times - Business
Sullivan & Cromwell Policy on Campus Protests is Criticized
In a letter to Sullivan & Cromwell, Mr. Nader and two other prominent legal figures condemned its efforts to screen job applicants for their participation in antiwar protests.5 hr ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Election deniers gain ground: 5 early takeaways from Arizona's primaries
Arizona’s primaries on Tuesday night saw numerous candidates who have questioned the results of past elections gain ground, the latest sign of Donald Trump’s deepening imprint on the GOP in the Grand Canyon State. In the most significant races of ...39 min ago -
The Hill - Politics
Kari Lake wins Arizona Senate primary, teeing up showdown with Gallego
Republican Kari Lake easily glided to victory in the Arizona Senate GOP primary, according to a projection from Decision Desk HQ, teeing up a marquee showdown between her and Democratic Rep. Ruben Gallego. Lake was largely seen as the presumptive ...3 hr ago -
The Hill - Politics
Gallego wins Democratic Senate primary in Arizona
Rep. Ruben Gallego (D-Ariz.) has won the Democratic primary in the Arizona Senate race, according to a projection from Decision Desk HQ. Gallego ran uncontested in the Democratic contest to replace retiring Sen. Kyrsten Sinema (I-Ariz.), and he ...3 hr ago -
The Hill - Politics
Durbin says Harris' shift on some policies won't change how people vote
Sen. Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) downplayed concerns that changes in Vice President Harris’s positions could influence voters in November. Harris’s policy platform has changed somewhat since her 2020 presidential campaign, including now backing fracking, ...3 hr ago -
The Hill - Politics
Kelly says Democrats can win his Senate seat if he becomes vice president
Sen. Mark Kelly (D-Ariz.) said he’s confident that Democrats can keep his Senate seat in a special election if he is elected vice president, as speculation rises over who Vice President Harris will choose as her running mate. Kelly told CNN’s Manu ...3 hr ago