Narrower radiation compensation bill rankles advocates
Advocates of a bipartisan bill to extend and expand compensation for Americans exposed to nuclear radiation by the government are now grappling with a new wrinkle they fear could impede their efforts.
While the bill's sponsors pressure Speaker Mike Johnson (R.-La.) to give it a House vote following its passage in the Senate, Utah's senators have introduced separate legislation that would extend the law without expanding its coverage — a move that has drawn frustration from lawmakers and members of impacted communities who have championed the cause.
The Radiation Exposure Compensation Act (RECA), first passed in 1990, compensates Americans exposed to radiation in their work on nuclear weapons testing or as uranium miners, as well as those who were downwind of the test site in Nye County, Nev.
Several categories of people exposed to radiation, including those downwind of the first-ever detonation of an atomic bomb in the 1945 Trinity test, are not eligible for compensation, however. And the law, for which President Biden signed an extension in 2022, is set to expire in July.
In March, the Senate passed a bill sponsored by Sens. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.), Eric Schmitt (R-Mo.), Mike Crapo (R-Idaho) and Ben Ray Lujan (D-N.M.) to extend the bill another six years and expand eligibility to radiation exposure victims in Missouri, Idaho, Montana, Guam, Colorado, Tennessee, Kentucky and Alaska, as well as people downwind of the Trinity test in Los Alamos, N.M.
While the senators are pushing for the measure to move forward in the lower chamber, Johnson has not yet announced any House action on the bill, which passed the upper chamber 69-30 with 49 Democratic and 20 Republican votes.
In the meantime, Sens. Mike Lee (R-Utah) and Mitt Romney (R-Utah), both of whom voted against the earlier measure, introduced legislation in mid-April to extend RECA another two years with no coverage expansion. Lee previously introduced the two-year extension in the Senate in 2022.
A Lee spokesperson told The Hill that the primary distinction between this bill and the one passed by the Senate in April is cost, while a person familiar with Lee’s thinking said the senator is also prioritizing keeping the law in effect past the July expiration date.
Romney, who backed the two-year extension in 2022, expressed similar sentiments, telling The Hill, “Sen. Hawley's [bill] is a $50 billion provision, and Sen. Lee’s is a small fraction of that, and is reserved [for] those individuals who have been determined to actually be suffering as a result of radiation exposure.”
Lujan expressed frustration with the notion of a narrower RECA extension that does not expand the law’s coverage, invoking Christopher Nolan’s Oscar-winning biopic “Oppenheimer.” The New Mexico Democrat frequently sought to use the renewed interest in the history covered by the movie in 2023 as a springboard to push the legislation.
“The question that I have for colleagues that want to introduce legislation and exclude New Mexico is, I'd invite them to go back and watch movies … like 'Oppenheimer,' or they can go back and read history,” he told The Hill. “And I'd like to remind them where the first bomb was tested in America. It was in New Mexico, the Trinity test site. How can that community be left out from the communities that would qualify for downwind? Answer me that.”
Hawley’s office referred The Hill to community activists working on the issue rather than offering comment on the Lee-Romney bill, but the Missouri senator has previously had sharp words for those who invoke the costs associated with expanding compensation.
In a February meeting with Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), Hawley said McConnell “brought up the cost, and I said I didn’t hear a lot of grousing about the cost when we were voting on Ukraine funding or anything else for that matter.”
In addition to the coverage expansion, the Hawley-Lujan bill includes provisions that would increase the amount of compensation available to beneficiaries for the first time since 2000. The Utah senators' bill includes no such increase.
Mary Dickson, a Salt Lake City downwinder and thyroid cancer survivor, said RECA as it currently exists “has always been flawed; it’s never been extensive enough.”
“Here in Utah, where we were basically at Ground Zero, it only covers 10 rural counties,” she told The Hill. Those lobbying to expand the law, she said, have “never had the momentum we’ve had right now,” and “it’s a more expansive bill that’s more inclusive, and that’s what we’ve been working so hard for.”
“Sen. Lee has never been supportive of that,” she added.
It’s not clear when or if Johnson will bring the Hawley-Lujan bill, which President Biden has said he would sign, to the House floor. But Dickson expressed worries that Lee and Romney’s pitch of a lower price tag could lead to action being taken on that bill while the more expansive measure languishes.
“My big worry is it’s going to override the expansion,” she said. “To me, they’re undermining the bill that just passed in the Senate. We don’t want another temporary extension.”
Dickson said that Utah’s House delegation has been responsive to downwinders’ concerns in the past, but that none of them are backing the more expansive bill, leaving those working on the issue with a feeling of betrayal.
In an email, a spokesperson for Rep. Celeste Maloy (R-Utah) told The Hill, "We have been in contact with constituents regarding RECA and know many are hoping for an expansion. Currently, our office is concerned with the impending deadline for the program. Clean reauthorizations are much less controversial and have proved much simpler to get passed. We are hopeful our reauthorization bill will be passed before Utahns lose coverage in just a few weeks, whereas we believe the current expansion bills are unlikely to be approved before the deadline."
The Hill has reached out to Utah’s other three representatives, Reps. Blake Moore (R), John Curtis (R) and Burgess Owens (R), for comment.
“To me it’s heartbreaking they can’t do right,” Dickson said. “When they say it costs too much, to me that’s incredibly specious when you look at the amount of money this country’s invested in nuclear weapons.”
Date: |
Filter
-
Oil Prices Rise But Stay Stuck in Narrow Range
Oil futures edged higher with the market awaiting OPEC’s next move, with three possible scenarios for the June 1 meeting—extend, unwind or completely remove the voluntary cuts of 2.2 million barrels a day.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Alan Bates rejects second Post Office compensation offer
The latest offer amounted to around a third of what the campaigner had asked for.BBC News - Top stories -
Grab Raises Profitability Metric Forecast as Quarterly Loss Narrows
The Southeast Asian ride-hailing and delivery specialist raised its full-year forecast for a key profitability metric, citing cost-cutting efforts and expansion in its core businesses that helped narrow its net loss in the first quarter.The Wall Street Journal - Tech -
Schumer's AI roadmap falls flat with advocates
Welcome to The Hill's Technology newsletter {beacon} Technology Technology The Big Story How advocates reacted to Schumer's AI 'roadmap' Civil rights, technology and labor advocates are warning that the bipartisan artificial intelligence (AI) ...The Hill - Politics - Artificial Intelligence -
Pro-cannabis advocates in Thailand rally ahead of the government's plan to recriminalize the plant
Dozens of pro-cannabis advocates in Thailand gathered at the health ministry on Thursday to oppose the government’s plan to relist it as narcotics, two years after it was decriminalizedABC News - World -
Advocates warn Schumer’s AI 'roadmap' doesn’t go far enough
Civil rights, technology and labor advocates are warning that the bipartisan artificial intelligence (AI) guidance Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) released Wednesday is not adequate to address the risks posed by the advancing ...The Hill - Politics -
Google tests AI to detect scam phone calls. Privacy advocates are terrified.
Some privacy advocates say that they’re terrified by an announcement this week from Google that the company is testing a way to scan people’s phone calls.NBC News - Top stories - Google -
EasyJet expects summer demand to lift earnings after a narrowed first-half loss, but the airline's outlook for the end of the year weighed on its shares.
EasyJet expects summer demand to lift earnings after a narrowed first-half loss, but the airline’s outlook for the end of the year weighed on its shares.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Energy bills predicted to fall by 7% in July
If the forecast proves correct, it would mean a typical annual bill could be £500 lower than last summer.BBC News - Top stories - Energy -
Refinancing student debt is risky amid Biden forgiveness push. Borrowers 'forever lose access' to safety nets, advocates say
As protections and relief options for federal student loan borrowers grow, refinancing your debt may be a risky move, consumer advocates say.CNBC - Business - Joe Biden
More from The Hill
-
Sullivan presses Netanyahu for a more focused military campaign in Gaza
White House national security adviser Jake Sullivan reiterated Biden administration pressure on Israel to limit its military operation in Gaza during a visit to the country on Sunday. Sullivan is on a combined trip to Israel and Saudi Arabia as ...The Hill - Politics - Israel -
Vance doubles down on praise for Viktor Orban's crackdown on universities in Hungary
Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio) stood by previous comments praising Hungarian President Viktor Orban for a regulatory crackdown on the country’s universities on Sunday, saying the U.S. should embrace a similar mindset. Orban, as part of anti-democratic ...The Hill - Politics -
Biden on Trump’s next Supreme Court pick: ‘Do you think he’ll put anybody who has a brain?’
President Biden asked the audience at an NAACP Detroit chapter dinner to consider whether they think former President Trump, if elected for a second term in the White House, would fill hypothetical vacancies at the Supreme Court with “anybody who ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
US to pull troops out of Niger by mid-September: Pentagon
The U.S. military will pull all of its assets out of Niger by mid-September, the Pentagon announced Sunday, after days of talks with the country’s military junta finalized a timeline. A group of military leaders executed a coup in Niger last year, ...The Hill - Politics -
Elon Musk debuts Starlink satellite internet service in Indonesia
Elon Musk traveled to Bali this weekend to officially launch Starlink, the SpaceX satellite internet service, in Indonesia this Sunday. At a launch event with ministers in a health clinic in Indonesia, Musk stressed the significance of providing ...The Hill - Politics - Elon Musk