McConnell says Congress has the power to vote by proxy
Senate GOP leader Mitch McConnell is defending Congress’ ability to permit voting by “proxy” when members are absent, a practice adopted by House Democrats at the height of the Covid pandemic despite intense opposition from Republicans.
In a brief filed Friday in federal court — authored by former Attorney General William Barr — McConnell says that despite his personal opposition to proxy voting, the House and Senate have total constitutional authority to determine the way they conduct business.
“Despite his fierce opposition to proxy voting, Senator McConnell believes it critical that courts nevertheless respect each house of Congress’ power to ‘determine the rules of its proceedings,’” Barr wrote on McConnell’s behalf.
McConnell’s position puts him at odds with the vast majority of House Republicans, who spent years fighting a losing battle in court to overturn the practice, which was initiated in 2020 by then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi. The House GOP leader at the time, Kevin McCarthy, sued to block the practice but was dealt defeats by two federal courts before the Supreme Court declined to take up the issue.
However, in February, a federal district court judge in Texas ruled that the House’s use of proxy voting violated the Constitution, contending that it requires a majority of members to be physically present to conduct business. The ruling, if upheld by appellate courts, threatens to unravel large and complicated legislative packages adopted with decisive votes cast by absent members.
McConnell says the ruling is particularly problematic because it presumes courts have a role in judging Congress’ internal procedures. The district court judge — Trump appointee James Hendrix — never defined what it means to be “physically present” to cast votes, McConnell noted, and said establishing such an “ironclad” restriction would be “debilitating” for Congress.
McConnell argues that the ruling “threatens Congress’s ability to conduct business on a day-to-day basis” and would remove “necessary flexibility,” noting that there may be other national emergencies that could require voting remotely. He said it could particularly devastate common Senate practices like voice votes and seeking unanimous consent.
The matter is pending before the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals, a conservative court that has at times pushed legal boundaries only to be reined in by the Supreme Court.
McConnell isn’t alone: Homeland security leaders from multiple administrations and advocacy groups who depended on programs funded during the height of the Covid pandemic are also urging the appeals court to overturn the lower court’s ruling.
Date: |
-
BBC News - Top stories
Data centres as vital as NHS and power grid, government says
Critical national infrastructure status means they will get extra government support during emergencies.1 hour ago -
ABC News - World
South Korea says North Korea has fired a ballistic missile toward the North’s eastern waters
South Korea says North Korea has fired a ballistic missile toward the North’s eastern waters1 hour ago - North Korea -
NBC News - Top stories
Conservative Swifties say her endorsement of Harris won't affect their vote or their love of her music
Swift’s post to Instagram on Tuesday explained that she decided to back Harris “because she fights for the rights and causes I believe need a warrior to champion them.”3 hours ago -
CBS News - Top stories
Mike Johnson's funding bill vote collapses in Congress
House Speaker Mike Johnson says a vote will not take place Wednesday on a stopgap measure to fund the government. CBS News congressional correspondent Scott MacFarlane reports from Capitol Hill.6 hours ago -
Financial Times - Business
AC Milan owner says private equity investment has ‘massively inflated’ sports valuations
RedBird Capital Gerry Cardinale criticised his rivals saying sector has been ‘bad for ecosystem’10 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
GOP race to replace McConnell heats up
The leadership race to replace retiring Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell (Ky.) is heating up as Senate Republican Whip John Thune (S.D.) announced Tuesday that he will transfer $4 million ...14 hours ago -
NBC News - Top stories
Hurricane Francine downgraded to Category 1 after making landfall in Louisiana
Louisiana official says 'time to evacuate has now passed' as Hurricane Francine approaches14 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
Family of US activist shot dead by Israeli forces says Biden has not called
Secretary of state and defence secretary decry fatal shooting of Ayşenur Ezgi Eygi in West Bank. The family of the American activist Ayşenur Ezgi Eygi said on Tuesday that neither the White House ...22 hours ago - Joe Biden
More from Politico
-
Politico - Politics
Lawmakers search for Plan B on spending
2 hours ago -
Politico - Politics
Senate Dems balk at Johnson's spending bill, but wait to release their own plan
Yesterday -
Politico - Politics
Democrats press oil executives on Trump's $1B ask
Yesterday - Donald Trump -
Politico - Politics
House Republicans set to gather as six-month funding patch roadblocks grow
Yesterday - Republican Party -
Politico - Politics
New York’s ousted governor to spar with House lawmakers over Covid response
The former New York governor will be grilled by a House panel over his pandemic response — just as he mulls a potential return to politics.Yesterday - Covid