Matt Gaetz can run, but can he hide?
Two days before Christmas, and not long after former Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.) withdrew as President-elect Donald Trump’s nominee for attorney general, the bipartisan House Ethics Committee released the report of its investigation into the former congressman’s conduct.
The committee found “substantial evidence” that Gaetz paid many women to have sex with him; committed statutory rape of a 17-year-old girl; frequently used illegal drugs, including cocaine and ecstasy; accepted gifts greater than the amount allowed by the House from an individual connected to the medical marijuana industry; failed to disclose purchases and sales of stocks and cryptocurrencies; enlisted his chief of staff to help a woman with whom he had a sexual relationship obtain a passport by falsely claiming she was his constituent; and obstructed the committee’s investigation by failing to respond to subpoena, written questions or producing relevant documents.
The committee did not investigate allegations that Gaetz shared inappropriate images and videos on the House floor; used campaign funds to pay personal expenses; and accepted a bribe.
Two Republicans and five Democrats on the committee voted to publish the report. While three Republicans concluded that doing so when the subject of the investigation was no longer a member of Congress constituted a “dangerous departure” from House practices, it is important to note that they did not challenge the committee’s findings.
In a democracy — where sunshine, the best disinfectant, is conducive to public morality — the Ethics Committee’s well-documented conclusions should command the wide attention. All the more so because Gaetz has hinted he might run for Marco Rubio’s Senate seat or for governor of Florida.
The Ethics Committee confirmed that Gaetz paid tens of thousands of dollars to 11 women with whom he had sex and/or used drugs between 2017 and 2020. Many of them were initially identified through a website that connects older men with younger women seeking “mutually beneficial relationships.” Gaetz distributed the money through PayPal, Venmo and Cash App; an account held under a pseudonymous email; cash; checks; and third parties.
Direct testimony and contemporaneous text messages indicated that Gaetz and the women understood “the transactional nature” of their arrangements. One woman recalled that “99 percent of the time that [Gaetz and I] were hanging out, there was sex involved.” Another said that after a sexual encounter, he gave her a $750 check with “tuition reimbursement” on the memo line. A third woman said, “it’s frustrating to know I lived the reality he denies.” Several women cited fear of retaliation as the reason they declined to testify.
Caught, so to speak, with his pants down, Gaetz acknowledged that he “probably partied, womanized, drank and smoked more than I should have earlier in life.” But he denied that he paid for sex: “Someone is trying to recategorize my generosity to ex-girlfriends as something more untoward.” “Giving funds to someone you are dating, that they didn’t ask for, and that isn’t ‘charged for,’” he fumed, “is now prostitution?”
Gaetz also insisted that the decision of Justice officials to end their investigation without filing charges meant he was “FULLY EXONERATED,” even though “they hated me.”
The decision not to indict Gaetz probably doesn’t mean investigators failed to find evidence of unethical or illegal behavior. After all, the most recent federal sex trafficking law, adopted in 1986, covers only allegations involving coercion, fraud or transporting a minor from one state to another or across international borders for sex. The alleged rape occurred in Florida — and the statute of limitations on that alleged crime has expired. The other sexual encounters were consensual. The Mann Act of 1910 is broader in scope, but the Department of Justice has tended to apply it only to situations in which victims were egregiously exploited.
Therefore, federal prosecutors may have concluded that the state of Florida — where unauthorized possession of controlled substances and soliciting the services of a person to engage in prostitution are criminal offenses, even if the sex is consensual — was the appropriate venue for an indictment.
Whatever their reasons, federal prosecutors undercut the MAGA mantra that “a weaponized” Biden administration Department of Justice conducted “sham witch hunts” against anyone who “ruffled the feathers of the Radical Left.” To date, Gaetz has made no attempt to explain why the department that he pledged to destroy if confirmed as attorney general gave him a free pass.
Will Gaetz run for political office again? Time will tell. That said, we don’t know whether time will heal all wounds — or wound all heels.
Glenn C. Altschuler is the Thomas and Dorothy Litwin Emeritus Professor of American Studies at Cornell University.
Topics
-
‘He ended up homeless and penniless’: My uncle conned my father into signing over their mother’s house. What can I do?
“His brother went to the prison where my dad was incarcerated and had him sign over the house.”MarketWatch - 15h -
‘We’ve proved we can do anything’: the Syrian women who want a say in running the country
Women’s rights groups have been active throughout the years of war and turmoil Syria – and now they are calling on the new regime to recognise their worth. The feminist activist Ghalia Rahhal ...The Guardian - 1d -
‘He always managed to play golf’: My husband of 14 years never worked and now we’re divorcing. He wants half of my $1 million home. What can I do?
“I made all the mortgage payments, in addition to paying for health coverage for both of us.”MarketWatch - 2d -
Will Matt Gaetz Participate in the House Speaker Vote?
The Florida Republican, who resigned his House seat during his short-lived bid for attorney general, has publicly flirted with the idea of showing up in Congress on Friday.The New York Times - 3d -
Massie says he won't vote for Johnson: 'You can pull all my fingernails out'
Rep. Thomas Massie (R-Ky.) affirmed his decision to not support Rep. Mike Johnson (R-La.) in the Speaker’s race, even if his colleague Rep. Chip Roy (R-Texas) would land a top spot on the House ...The Hill - 3d -
Women: Can South Carolina again run the table in the SEC?
The Gamecocks' quest for a third straight undefeated league season starts Thursday when SEC play opens.ESPN - 4d -
Branded content you can trust
CBS News Brand Studio provides creative, narrative-driven branded content from a trusted, legacy brand with the SEO and social media power to deliver results.CBS News - 4d -
Hernández: Lakers go all-in on Austin Reaves and will learn whether he can become an all-star
The Lakers put their faith in Austin Reaves when they traded D'Angelo Russell, trusting the young shooter to help LeBron James and Anthony Davis.Yahoo Sports - 5d
More from The Hill
-
Dem Rep. Bera ready to meet Republicans '50-yard-line,' and even '40-yard-line' since they're in majority
Rep. Ami Bera (D-Calif.) said on Monday he is ready to meet Republicans “at the 50-yard-line” and even at “the 40-yard-line” due to them being “in the majority.” “So, the American public clearly ...The Hill - 1h -
Trump says he'll replace National Archives leader
President-elect Trump said on Monday that he’ll replace the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) leader. “We will [have a] new archivist,” Trump told conservative radio host Hugh ...The Hill - 2h -
Biden says 'New Orleans defines strength and resilience' at service for victims
President Biden offered his condolences to the victims of the New Orleans New Year's Day attack, calling the Louisiana city one with a tough spirit at an interfaith prayer service with victims’ ...The Hill - 4h -
A Gaza ceasefire agreement in next 2 weeks? The US is hopeful
Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story A Gaza ceasefire agreement in next 2 weeks? The US is hopeful The ...The Hill - 4h -
Musk asks his followers if the US 'should liberate the people of Britain from their tyrannical government'
Tech billionaire Elon Musk on Monday asked his followers on the social platform X, which he owns, if the U.S. “should liberate the people of Britain from their tyrannical government.” “America ...The Hill - 5h
More in Politics
-
California sheriff is Trump's blue-state ally
Riverside County, California, Sheriff Chad Bianco says he feels "very good" about President-elect Trump winning the election and calls Democrats' agenda "pro criminal." In the past, Bianco was a ...NBC News - 1h -
Dem Rep. Bera ready to meet Republicans '50-yard-line,' and even '40-yard-line' since they're in majority
Rep. Ami Bera (D-Calif.) said on Monday he is ready to meet Republicans “at the 50-yard-line” and even at “the 40-yard-line” due to them being “in the majority.” “So, the American public clearly ...The Hill - 1h -
Trump says he'll replace National Archives leader
President-elect Trump said on Monday that he’ll replace the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) leader. “We will [have a] new archivist,” Trump told conservative radio host Hugh ...The Hill - 2h -
Miami Proud Boys leader Enrique Tarrio asks for Jan. 6 Trump pardon
Enrique Tarrio is asking President-elect Donald Trump for a pardon.CBS News - 3h -
Biden says 'New Orleans defines strength and resilience' at service for victims
President Biden offered his condolences to the victims of the New Orleans New Year's Day attack, calling the Louisiana city one with a tough spirit at an interfaith prayer service with victims’ ...The Hill - 4h