Many US cities are eager to welcome migrants. We need to make it easier for them to do so.
The supplemental border bill’s spectacular failure in Congress has wrought many devastating consequences. Among them is the U.S. government’s inability to effectively move migrants away from the overwhelmed larger cities to other parts of the country that would happily receive them. Non-governmental organizations and the government must work together to send migrants to such cities, ensuring adequate resettlement and employment options while saving taxpayer dollars.
For years, millions of taxpayer dollars have been spent transferring migrants to select locations. Between April 2022 and November 2023, Texas alone spent $86.1 million to bus 66,200 migrants and asylum seekers from the border to these six cities: Los Angeles, Denver, Chicago, New York City, Philadelphia and Washington, D.C (four of which rank among the most expensive in the country). Arizona spent $5.7 million to transport 26,513 asylum seekers to these same cities between January and November 2023, and Florida allocated $12 million to do so in FY2022-23.
Due to overcrowding and high housing prices, these six cities are often not even the final destination. After their arrival, more money is spent transporting migrants elsewhere — sometimes even back to the same state they came from. In 2023, Denver spent $4.3 million to help migrants and asylum seekers travel to their final destination — which, for several hundred individuals, was Texas. New York City opened a Reticketing Center to provide free plane tickets for travel to any location, including back to Florida and Texas.
Sending people to only six U.S. cities with some of the highest cost of living is logistically and fiscally unsustainable.
We can curb this wasteful trend by relocating migrants and asylum seekers to a broader range of locations. This can be facilitated by an increase in federal funding. The most recent “dead on arrival” supplemental bill proposed that $933 million be transferred to the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) Shelter and Services Program, one of FEMA’s grant programs for managing migration. Through the Shelter and Services Program, grants can be awarded to entities providing shelter and services, including transportation, to migrants and asylum seekers released from DHS custody at the southern border. Funds can be used for various types of transportation assistance to migrants as they arrive or after they have been initially resettled in a city to travel to their final destination.
But without purposeful coordination, migrants will continue to be thoughtlessly shuffled throughout the country. Many mid-size and more affordable cities indicate they would welcome the arrival of migrants. Salt Lake City, for example, is a Certified Welcoming City that has created policies and programs fostering immigrant inclusion in civic, social and economic life. Utah established two public-private funds to support refugee resettlement in the state: the Afghan Community Fund, founded in 2021 to support the resettlement of Afghans, and the Refugee Services Fund, which helps refugees access “family-sustaining” employment in the state.
In February 2023, Utah Gov. Spencer Cox joined Indiana Gov. Eric Holcomb in saying that declining birth rates and earlier retirements will amplify the job gap crisis and that immigrants, refugees and asylees are necessary to “help build strong communities,” underscoring the economic case for welcoming new community residents arriving through asylum, refugee resettlement and other immigration pathways.
Topeka, Kan., a city of about 125,000 people, is also developing economic incentives to entice Latinos and other immigrants. The Choose Topeka program provides work-authorized individuals with up to $15,000 if they rent or buy homes in the city and are employed by local businesses that partner with the program. Many of these business partners are recruiting Hispanic workers. For example, the Greater Topeka Partnership economic development group has launched marketing campaigns to attract immigrants, specifically Spanish speakers.
The Office of Global Michigan was formed to grow the state’s economy by investing in and recruiting foreigners with valuable skills. Two of its programs, the Refugee and Humanitarian Parolee Resettlement Fund and the Newcomer Rental Subsidy support refugees and humanitarian parolees with essential social services and employment access. Other states with Rust Belt cities, like Dayton, Erie and Pittsburgh, are similarly working to attract migrants and foreign talent to address their falling population. St. Louis is also considering taking migrants from Chicago to help address its declining population and spur economic growth.
Cities across the country indicate they want and need to grow; for this, welcoming work-authorized people to live, work and raise families in their cities is vital. Meanwhile, the largest U.S. cities are struggling under the weight of too much migration and are spending millions of dollars annually in ultimately misguided strategies to alleviate the problem. With some thoughtful planning and coordination, we can help overwhelmed cities, answer the demands of smaller cities looking to attract new residents and help migrants seeking a better life in a welcoming community.
Kristie De Pena is senior vice president for policy and director of immigration policy at the Niskanen Center. Claire Holba is immigration policy analyst at he Niskanen Center.
Date: |
Filter
-
Apple Makes It Easier to Stare at Your Phone in the Car
Plus: Sony Music tries to keep its catalog out of the clutches of AI, there’s a towering new Lord of the Rings Lego set, and Google’s new AI features march onto the web.Wired - Tech - Apple -
This is how we do it: ‘We’ll put on our sex playlist and change the lights to purple. It ignites a fire inside us’
After sexless marriages, Jasper and Ellen discovered what they’d been missing out on. How do you do it? Share the story of your sex life, anonymouslyI’ve been through an awakening. I think sex makes me a happier person, especially to feel so ...The Guardian - World -
Whoopi Goldberg on Harrison Butker remarks: 'These are his beliefs and he’s welcome to them'
"The View" co-host Whoopi Goldberg defended Kansas City Chiefs kicker Harrison Butker, who is under fire for suggesting women should prioritize being a homemaker over their career ambitions. “These are his beliefs and he’s welcome to them," ...The Hill - Politics -
As Teen Employee Numbers Rise, So Do Risks of Harassment on the Job
The throng of Gen Z youth new to the workplace face increased risks of sexual harassment at work--a crime officials and prosecutors are warning employers to address.Inc. - Business -
RFK Jr. Voters Span MAGA to Liberal---Making Them an Election Wildcard
In swing state Arizona, the independent’s candidacy could change whether Trump or Biden wins.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Countries wooing corporate digital nomads hope to make them stay
Nearly 60 countries are offering remote visas, many with an eye to making visitors permanent residentsFinancial Times - Business -
'The City Needs to Live.' Inside Ukraine's Second City as Russia Closes In.
With Russian troops 20 miles away and advancing, defiant Ukrainian residents carry on as normally as they can.The Wall Street Journal - World - Ukraine -
The number of child migrants arriving in an Italian city has more than doubled, a report says
An aid group says that the number of unaccompanied children who arrived in the northern Italian city of Trieste through the Balkan migratory route has more than doubled last yearABC News - World -
A City With a Medieval History of Killing Cats Now Celebrates Them at the Kattenstoet Parade
Cat lovers from around the world gathered for Kattenstoet, a cat parade in Iepers, Belgium.The New York Times - Lifestyle -
Do dogs need sunscreen? Here’s what vets say
Dog sunscreen protects pets from sunburn, skin cancer and sun damage. What kind of sunscreen is best for dogs, according to vets? Can I put human sunscreen on my dog?NBC News - Top stories
More from The Hill
-
Diddy admits to assaulting Cassie in 2016 video, apologizes for 'inexcusable' actions
Sean "Diddy" Combs on Sunday apologized for brutally assaulting his former girlfriend, R&B singer Cassie, in a hotel in 2016 after a video of the alleged incident was unsurfaced by CNN last week. “It’s so difficult to reflect on the darkest times ...The Hill - Politics -
Who's afraid of cultivated meat? Why Florida should embrace, not ban it
Florida has the chance to lead in this area, to embrace the future rather than cling to the past. Let's not be the generation that bans the future. Let's be the ones who welcomed it, nurtured it and thrived from it.The Hill - Politics - Florida -
House Dem says cutting federal funds for Harvard 'needs to be on the table'
Rep. Jake Auchincloss (D-Mass.) on Sunday said cutting federal funds for Harvard University and other schools should be an option "on the table" over their handling of campus antisemitism. Auchincloss, who is an alum of Harvard, visited the Ivy ...The Hill - Politics -
Trump 'does not like to surround himself with yes people,' says Ben Carson
Ben Carson, who served as the secretary of Housing and Urban Development under former President Trump, said his ex-boss "does not like to surround himself with yes people" when asked about his stance on abortion laws. CNN's Jake Tapper pressed ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Ukraine ups pressure on US to allow strikes in Russia: ‘This is insane’
Ukraine’s struggle to fend off Russia’s massive offensive in the Kharkiv region has underscored a pressing issue that Kyiv has long tried to overturn: a ban on firing U.S. weapons to hit inside of Russia. Russia launched its Kharkiv offensive ...The Hill - Politics - Ukraine