Mace sued for defamation over allegations in stunning floor speech

A man Rep. Nancy Mace (R-S.C.) accused of being part of a group of “predators” in a stunning House floor speech is suing her for defamation.

The complaint, filed Friday in federal court, sets up a battle over the Constitution’s Speech and Debate Clause, which shields lawmakers against lawsuits for things they say and do as part of their legislative work. Mace’s office cited the protection in a press release about her floor remarks.

Brian Musgrave was one of four men Mace named in the February speech in which she made a series of allegations of sexual abuse and voyeurism, naming Musgrave, her ex-fiance, and two other South Carolina men. All of the men have denied wrongdoing.

“Now, it is with unbridled disgust that Brian Musgrave through this lawsuit is forced to utter the words: ‘I am not a rapist.’ ‘I am not a predator.’ ‘I am not a sex trafficker,’” the lawsuit states.

“Through this action, Brian Musgrave seeks to recover that which has been wrongfully taken from him – his good name and reputation,” it continues.

Mace claimed to have found a hidden camera on a property owned by her ex-fiance and Musgrave that had intimate photos of women that were taken without their knowledge or consent.

The complaint acknowledges Musgrave jointly owns the South Carolina condo with the congresswoman’s ex-fiance, who is described as Musgrave’s longtime friend. But the suit says Musgrave didn’t place the camera, never had access to it and was not present for any of what Mace has alleged.

Musgrave was not accused of the most serious offenses that Mace listed in the speech, such as being raped after having blacked out one night and believing she was “purposefully incapacitated.”

But she listed Musgrave along with the other three men and their photos on a sign she displayed on the House floor that said: “Predators.”

Filed in federal court in Charleston, S.C., the lawsuit names as defendants Mace and five unnamed people who are alleged to have conspired with her. The case was assigned to U.S. District Judge Richard Gergel, an appointee of former President Obama.

The lawsuit will be a major and uncommon test for the Speech and Debate protections given to lawmakers.

A press release from Mace’s about the speech at the time referenced that protection and defended the veracity of her allegations: “Any and all statements made by Members on the House Floor are quintessential ‘legislative acts,’ and protected by the Speech and Debate clause afforded under the Constitution of the United States. Her statements tonight are not conjecture, they are not allegations, they are facts based on information she uncovered and documents she accidentally discovered.”

Notably, Musgrave’s claims do not focus on Mace’s remarks on the House floor, instead taking aim at a prepared version she distributed to the press beforehand, her display of the poster outside her congressional office and a series of social media posts she made on the social platform X.

“While the speech and debate clause of the United States Constitution affords broad protection to members of Congress acting as part of its deliberative process, it does not transform the floor of Congress into a sanctuary for defamation, nor does it protect Congresswoman Mace’s extra-Congressional defamatory statements surrounding her speech,” the lawsuit states.

Mace’s congressional office did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the lawsuit.

Topics

Mace sued for defamation by man she accused of abuse in floor speech

The legal action seeks to carve out an exception from the speech or debate clause of the Constitution.
Politico - 6h
Noel Clarke says life 'smashed' by allegations

He is suing the Guardian's publisher over allegations of sexually inappropriate behaviour.
BBC News - 4d
Fortnite Is Being Sued Over Its Item Shop Again

Fortnite has been the subject of lawsuits and other regulatory action a number of times over the years regarding its FOMO-driven item shop practices, and now we've got another one for the pile. A ...
GameSpot - Mar. 7
Two men arrested in India over alleged rape of Israeli and local woman

The two women were said to have been stargazing with three male travellers when the incident took place. Two men have been arrested in India in connection with the alleged rape of an Israeli and a ...
The Guardian - 6d
Supreme Court Rejects an Effort to Block States From Suing Oil Giants

The justices declined to hear unusual arguments from Republican-led states that sought to end lawsuits against energy companies over their role in global warming.
The New York Times - 4d
Trump sued by 20 states to halt the 'dismantling' of Education Department

Democratic state attorneys general filed a lawsuit against President Donald Trump over his administration's termination of Education Department staffers.
CNBC - 1d
The pink protest at Trump’s speech shows the Democrats aren’t coming to save us

The general reaction is that this was yet another stunning example of how spineless and performative the Democrats are. Happy International Women’s Day (IWD), everyone! I’ve got some good news and ...
The Guardian - 6d
Cam Skattebo sued by former Arizona State teammate over injury on practice field

While former Arizona State running back Cam Skattebo has been at the Scouting Combine and preparing for pre-draft meetings with NFL teams, process servers have been trying to find him to serve him ...
Yahoo Sports - Mar. 7
Russia expels 2 British diplomats from embassy in Moscow over espionage claims

Russian said it is expelling two British diplomats over allegations of spying
ABC News - 4d