License to compete: Regulators must step in to even the cloud playing field
After more than a decade of delay, regulators in three of Microsoft’s major cloud markets — the U.S., the United Kingdom and the European Union — may finally be taking steps to hold the tech giant accountable for its anticompetitive behavior.
It is imperative that each of them act decisively, and soon. Given Microsoft’s long history of anticompetitive behavior, regulatory intervention is the only way to prevent the company from continuing to abuse its market power to lock in customers across the globe.
Without intervention, Microsoft is certain to continue running the playbook it has used since its Azure cloud platform was launched 14 years ago. This involves leveraging unfair and unjustified licensing practices to force Microsoft application customers onto Azure and, when regulatory scrutiny heats up in a given market, making the narrowest possible one-off deals with small regional competitors to evade regulatory action. These deals are the very definition of "too little, too late." They don’t support true competition, and they instead enable Microsoft to forestall broader antitrust scrutiny while continuing to amass cloud market share.
In 2022, Microsoft dodged regulatory scrutiny in the EU by relaxing a set of licensing restrictions for an extremely narrow group of small- and medium-sized cloud providers. The move ostracized Amazon Web Services and Google Cloud customers, forcing them either to switch to Azure or pay a 400 percent premium to use ubiquitous Microsoft productivity software like Word in the cloud environment of their choice.
Fast-forward to this July, and Microsoft got the Cloud Infrastructure Service Providers in Europe to withdraw its antitrust complaint before the European Commission through a $22 million settlement that includes a two-year moratorium on Microsoft software audits for the organization's members. These terms might have fail to address the broader anticompetitive concerns and consumer harms the group raised in the first place.
It’s a disheartening reality that, even when smaller companies band together to stand up to Microsoft’s anticompetitive behavior, they are no match for the company’s resources. Now, instead of creating a more open and competitive marketplace, customers in Europe are faced with one of two options: go with Azure and/or one of the smaller Cloud Infrastructure Service Providers in Europe member companies that are now effectively Microsoft resellers, or choose AWS or Google Cloud and suffer “a price increase of up to 300 percent for customers choosing non-Azure cloud infrastructure.”
This is precisely the scenario that competition policy is supposed to prevent, but it’s the scenario we’re living in.
Look no further for why regulators must address Microsoft’s anticompetitive efforts in the cloud on a much broader basis; unchecked, why should its behavior stop there? Microsoft surely sees the space to leverage a software monopoly and expanding cloud business to aim for excessive market power in AI, degrading consumer choice further in the next generation of cloud service technologies.
Microsoft’s largest competitors and other industry advocates are stepping up to the plate to help make sure this doesn’t happen. Google Cloud, for example, has filed an antitrust complaint with the European Commission. Elsewhere, a class-action lawsuit in the U.K. on behalf of thousands of Microsoft customers is being readied against the company’s licensing practices that have allegedly inflated prices exorbitantly.
But private action is likely to have little consequence unless regulators act. Without market-wide remedies, Microsoft has shown that it will continue to pick off complainants or simply ignore the problem.
Microsoft is in an enviable position and no doubt wants to stay there. For instance, Microsoft effectively picks and chooses who it competes with and how by enforcing “Listed Provider” designation. This penalizes customers who bring certain on-premise software to competitors like AWS, Google Cloud or Alibaba Cloud, charging them significantly more to do so than they would on Azure.
The Listed Provider designation also allows Microsoft to impose arbitrary requirements on enterprise-level customers to force the adoption of Azure. Microsoft has not ever officially offered a transparent explanation for this “listed” designation, most likely because there is no explanation other than to impede competition. Eliminating the designation would be an immediate boon to global cloud competition, and benefit millions of customers.
Regulators should also consider taking action to curb Microsoft's runaway cloud bundling and tying practices, which disincentivize customers, especially those at the enterprise level, from even considering competitors' products. Indeed, recent research categorizes and puts numbers to the ways in which Microsoft’s bundling practices in the cloud harm customers, limiting choice and innovation, and prevent customers from seeking best-in-class cloud technologies.
Regulators also need to be more proactive and widen their aperture to consider the ways Microsoft’s bundling practices threaten nascent markets, like cybersecurity or generative AI, to prevent the same from happening to them.
Regulators need to press for a better and fuller solution to the cloud competition challenge right now, to support broad economic growth and innovation instead of the bottom line of a single company. The longer the delay, the more entrenched the monopolistic behaviors become and the harder the problem is to solve.
Steve Weber is a professor at the Graduate School, UC Berkeley School of Information. He has published numerous books, including “The Success of Open Source” and, most recently, “Bloc by Bloc: How to Build a Global Enterprise for the New Regional Order.” He has worked with and received research funding from a number of technology firms, including Google and Microsoft.
Date: |
Topics
-
Sports - ABC News
Russian Olympic Committee president to step down. Neutral athletes competed at Paris Games
The president of the suspended Russian Olympic Committee plans to step down after six years in charge5 days ago - Russia -
Sports - ESPN
Fields: No Steelers QB debate if I play better
Justin Fields says if he had played better, there wouldn't be a question about whether he or Russell Wilson should start.3 days ago - NFL -
Business - Financial Times
Social media must do more to tackle payment fraud, says UK regulator
Ministers urged to consider levy on tech groups to compensate victims of online scams6 days ago - United Kingdom -
Sports - Yahoo Sports
Justin Fields on Steelers' looming Week 7 QB decision: 'I don't think I played good enough'
Russell Wilson is finally healthy and could start Sunday night against the Jets.3 days ago - NFL -
Sports - ABC News
Justin Fields says he hasn't played well enough for Steelers to not consider Russell Wilson at QB
Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Justin Fields seems to be at peace with the idea of getting benched in favor of Russell Wilson3 days ago - NFL -
Sports - ABC News
Texas apologizes to Georgia players, staff, SEC and game officials after fans throw trash on field
Texas has apologized after fans littered the field with water bottles and other trash after an interception for the top-ranked Longhorns against No. 5 Georgia was initially wiped out by a ...3 hours ago -
Sports - ABC News
Brandon McManus' field goal on the final play gives Packers a 24-22 victory over Texans
Brandon McManus kicked a 45-yard field goal as time expired in his debut with Green Bay to lift the Packers past the Houston Texans 24-2215 minutes ago - NFL -
Science - The New York Times
Astronomers Find Evidence of an Exomoon Spewing a Volcanic Cloud
Astronomers have yet to confirm the existence of exomoons, but a molecular signal around a far away star offers some of the best evidence yet.5 days ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Here's what to do if you lose an absentee ballot before Election Day
While misplacing a ballot can be stressful, there are still ways to make sure your vote is counted.55 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Republicans head to court in expanding battle about overseas ballots
Overseas voting has become the latest battlefront in Republicans’ legal challenges leading up to the election. Judges in two crucial battleground states, Michigan and Pennsylvania, this week heard ...58 minutes ago - Republican Party -
Politics - The Hill
Lawler: Rhetoric about Trump-related fascism 'needs to stop'
Rep. Mike Lawler (R-N.Y.) said the rhetoric about former President Trump and fascism hurts other Republicans and “needs to stop.” Lawler joined CBS News's “Face the Nation” on Sunday morning to ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Michigan secretary of state says she expects election results to be certified day after Nov. 5
Michigan Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson (D) said she expects her state’s election results to be certified the day after the Nov. 5 general election. “In 2020 we had the results of our highest ...2 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Youngkin criticizes DOJ suit against Virginia: 'This is not a purge'
Virginia Gov. Glenn Youngkin (R) criticized a Department of Justice (DOJ) suit against his state over the purging of voter rolls Sunday. “To be clear, this is not a purge,” Youngkin said on “Fox ...2 hours ago
Latest in Politics
-
Politics - The Hill
Here's what to do if you lose an absentee ballot before Election Day
While misplacing a ballot can be stressful, there are still ways to make sure your vote is counted.55 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Republicans head to court in expanding battle about overseas ballots
Overseas voting has become the latest battlefront in Republicans’ legal challenges leading up to the election. Judges in two crucial battleground states, Michigan and Pennsylvania, this week heard ...58 minutes ago - Republican Party -
Politics - NBC News
'What kind of country do we want to live in?' Harris asks congregation
During remarks at New Birth Missionary Baptist Church in Stonecrest, Ga., Vice President Kamala Harris encouraged congregants to vote.1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
Lawler: Rhetoric about Trump-related fascism 'needs to stop'
Rep. Mike Lawler (R-N.Y.) said the rhetoric about former President Trump and fascism hurts other Republicans and “needs to stop.” Lawler joined CBS News's “Face the Nation” on Sunday morning to ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - CBS News
Trump works drive-thru at Bucks County McDonald's before town hall in Lancaster
Former President Donald Trump is hosting a town hall in Lancaster Sunday night, and Vice President Kamala Harris will be back in Chester County on Monday.2 hours ago - Donald Trump