Legal scholars accuse Utah of failing to curb the Great Salt Lake's decline
Three dozen law professors from across the country are demanding that a Utah district court hold the Beehive State responsible for the declining water levels in the Great Salt Lake.
The professors submitted an amicus brief on Friday in support of a lawsuit — launched by conservation groups in the fall — alleging that Utah has failed to ensure that enough water reaches the Great Salt Lake.
The writers also declared their opposition to motions to dismiss the case, which were filed by private water users, water conservancy districts, municipalities and state agencies.
"The Great Salt Lake’s precarious future is not beyond legal remedy," the professors stated.
Instituting conservation measures for the benefit of the Great Salt Lake is a complicated endeavor, due to the dictates of the water rights system that dominates much of the U.S. West.
The system, which dates to the mid-19th century Homestead Act, enabled users to divert water on a first-come, first-serve, priority basis — meaning that imposing usage cutbacks for the sake of the lake could infringe upon a higher-priority user's water rights.
But the conservation and community groups that sued the State of Utah in September argued that upstream diversions have led to a significant decrease in the Great Salt Lake's water — and that the state has a responsibility to protect this public resource.
“The Great Salt Lake belongs to the people of Utah,” Stu Gillespie, senior attorney with one of those conservation groups — Earthjustice — said in a statement. “It is time for the state to fulfill its obligation to protect this resource and address the unsustainable upstream water diversions that are putting it at risk.”
The path toward reversing the basin's declining water levels and ecological collapse involves harnessing what's known as the "public trust doctrine," the law professors wrote in the amicus brief.
Such doctrines require governments to hold natural resources in trust for the public, with such resources typically including navigable waters and their submerged lands, per the brief.
In Utah, the public trust doctrine dates at least back to the state's 1896 establishment and was enforced in its constitution — which recognized the doctrine's applicability to lands and water and the concept of "beneficial use" as the basis for fulfilling those rights, the professors noted.
Beneficial use refers to a rights holder's requirement to only use a diverted water allocation for predefined purposes, such as irrigation, hydropower, domestic, municipal, commercial or mining uses.
Regarding the public trust doctrine, the state legislature also has declared that all state waters belong to the people of Utah, the professors explained, noting that other Mountain West states have applied their own such doctrines to water bodies like the Great Salt Lake.
Demanding that the court correct "the state's shortsighted view of its trust obligations," the writers stressed the need to apply the public trust doctrine to water law — which they described as being "frozen in the 19th century."
"The state clearly has the authority to undertake water conservation measures necessary to restore the Lake," they stated, noting that such measures could include changes to surplus water management in wet years and requiring efficiency improvements.
The writers stressed that "no vested rights need be threatened," while emphasizing that these rights do not enable users "to divert a fixed quantity of water in perpetuity."
"All water rights in the state are subject to the public interest and must be used for beneficial purposes without waste," the professors stated.
"It is within the power of this Court to inform the state that the waste of the Great Salt Lake is neither in the public interest, nor is it a beneficial use," they concluded.
In response to the amicus brief, Joel Ferry, executive director of the Utah Department of Natural Resources, said in a statement that he and his colleagues received the document and “plan to oppose it.”
Ferry described the amicus brief as “largely duplicative” of the plaintiffs’ complaint, noting that “Utah’s district court rules do not authorize such filings.”
“We have been — and will continue to — work to protect the interests of the state of Utah,” he continued, noting that the agency’s divisions are all “mindful” of their individual responsibilities.
“Together, we are addressing the need to protect the Great Salt Lake,” Ferry added.
Date: |
Filter
-
A Legal Scholar Critiqued Elon Musk's Pay. Now He's Out of a Job.
Tesla threatened to fire a law firm over Charles Elson’s objections to the CEO’s proposed pay package, an email suggests.The Wall Street Journal - Business -
GameStop Shares Retreat on Declining Revenue, Stock Sale
The videogame retailer filed to sell up to 45 million more shares after projecting quarterly sales to drop.The Wall Street Journal - World -
GameStop Shares Retreat on Declining Revenue, Stock Sale
The videogame retailer filed to sell up to 45 million more shares after projecting quarterly sales to drop.The Wall Street Journal - Business -
The secret Italian lakes that most tourists don’t know about
Yahoo News - World -
An Economic Peace Plan for Gaza Is Bound to Fail
Unless it follows an unconditional surrender.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Higher education is failing — and our democracy is suffering
Educators must grapple anew with the question of how to teach democracy, so that students master both the theory and the hands-on practice of it.The Hill - Politics -
Rishi Sunak faces cabinet backlash over plans to curb foreign student visas
Education secretary Gillian Keegan, Jeremy Hunt and David Cameron oppose move, while university leaders warn of economic and cultural impact. Rishi Sunak is facing a cabinet revolt over plans to scrap a graduate visa scheme that allows overseas ...The Guardian - World -
Trump legal team hammers at Cohen's credibility in questioning
Prosecutors are nearing the end of their hush money case against former President Donald Trump as Michael Cohen's testimony wraps up.NBC News - Top stories - Donald Trump -
Radical change looms for Japanese legal sector
Advisers are braced for more domestic businesses to become targets for unsolicited takeoversFinancial Times - World - Japan -
Fifa to make legal assessment on Israel suspension
The Palestinian football federation calls for a vote at Fifa's congress to suspend Israel over the war in Gaza.BBC News - Top stories - Israel
More from The Hill
-
Diddy admits to assaulting Cassie in 2016 video, apologizes for 'inexcusable' actions
Sean "Diddy" Combs on Sunday apologized for brutally assaulting his former girlfriend, R&B singer Cassie, in a hotel in 2016 after a video of the alleged incident was unsurfaced by CNN last week. “It’s so difficult to reflect on the darkest times ...The Hill - Politics -
Who's afraid of cultivated meat? Why Florida should embrace, not ban it
Florida has the chance to lead in this area, to embrace the future rather than cling to the past. Let's not be the generation that bans the future. Let's be the ones who welcomed it, nurtured it and thrived from it.The Hill - Politics - Florida -
House Dem says cutting federal funds for Harvard 'needs to be on the table'
Rep. Jake Auchincloss (D-Mass.) on Sunday said cutting federal funds for Harvard University and other schools should be an option "on the table" over their handling of campus antisemitism. Auchincloss, who is an alum of Harvard, visited the Ivy ...The Hill - Politics -
Trump 'does not like to surround himself with yes people,' says Ben Carson
Ben Carson, who served as the secretary of Housing and Urban Development under former President Trump, said his ex-boss "does not like to surround himself with yes people" when asked about his stance on abortion laws. CNN's Jake Tapper pressed ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Ukraine ups pressure on US to allow strikes in Russia: ‘This is insane’
Ukraine’s struggle to fend off Russia’s massive offensive in the Kharkiv region has underscored a pressing issue that Kyiv has long tried to overturn: a ban on firing U.S. weapons to hit inside of Russia. Russia launched its Kharkiv offensive ...The Hill - Politics - Ukraine