Lee Zeldin should trash EPA’s national recycling plan
Like other Cabinet members in the Trump administration, new Environmental Protection Agency chief Lee Zeldin has hit the ground running, canceling ideology-driven contracts for diversity, equity and “environmental justice.”
But it’s not just these progressive favorites through which the agency has strayed far from its mandate to clean the environment.
One of its less controversial core goals — and one popular with municipalities and corporations across the country — is the vehicle for spreading environmental damage across the world. To reverse that trend, Zeldin should roll back an EPA edict aimed at every city and town in the country: the national recycling goal.
Instead of putting plastic in those blue bins, we should establish systems to recover valuable “e-waste,” the rare earth elements and metals found in cellphones and other electronics — in other words, the very same things the Trump administration is working to get from Ukraine.
Per the EPA, the goal is to increase trash recycling to 50 percent of solid waste by 2030, with the aim of “managing materials more sustainably.” Think here of the plastic, glass and paper piled in the ubiquitous blue bins found on curbsides. It sounds like an admirable goal — but what seems like an unobjectionable practice turns out to be both uneconomical and damaging.
The picture of just how that works is painted brilliantly in Alexander Clapp’s forthcoming new book, “Waste Wars.” Based on astounding on-the-ground reporting across the globe, "Waste Wars" shines a spotlight on how plastic travels from rich countries to poor, where it is not recycled but dumped or burned.
Clapp lifts the veil on the “wishcycling” ongoing across the U.S. “The waste that travels across the globe and often inflicts irreversible environmental damage is not the trash that — to much chagrin — goes into the garbage bin and then into the local landfill. It’s the stuff that you place in the recycling bin in the conviction that doing so is helping the planet.”
That’s because the installed capacity to recycle those plastic bottles and other containers is both limited and domestically unprofitable.
There is no current realistic market for recycled plastic. It’s simply far less expensive to make new plastic than to refine existing stock. “Virgin plastics” are made from byproducts of oil and gas refining, which occurs anyway, and are of higher quality. Markets tend to reward products that are cheaper and better. Only 9 percent of U.S. plastic is nominally recycled at all.
Internationally, where the rate is higher, this eco-friendly practice relies on the lowest paid workers to do the required cleaning and sorting. U.S. plastic, long shipped to China before it closed its doors in 2017, is likely to wind up in what Clapp describes as a shadowy, informal market of those paid to send “recyclables” in shipping containers bound for countries such as Ghana. It’s what increasingly passes for industry in poor nations.
This is the environmentally damaging supply chain, which the EPA’s national recycling goal is helping to stock, by pressuring local municipalities to divert plastic to those blue bins and not to send it to dumps or incinerators. As hard as it is to believe, absent a breakthrough in technology and markets, localities would be doing the environment a favor by sending plastic to sanitary landfills or burning it.
As I have described in my report on trends in recycling for the American Enterprise Institute, a new generation of “waste-to-energy” incinerators holds the promise of mining the ash produced for valuable rare earth elements found in electronics, which are not separated at curbside, despite their high value. A February 2020 analysis by Purdue University of the e-waste stream finds 56 elements in electronic devices are routinely sent to dumps.
The current system which the EPA’s broadbrush national goal encourages also does damage to local government finances. It is costly to run separate trucks to pick up what’s in those blue bins — especially when the contents may well have to be sent to landfills anyway, for lack of an existing market. This is not to say that everything placed in the curbside bins is done so foolishly. Per the EPA, some 80 percent of paper and cardboard is actually recycled. This points toward how a pragmatic EPA can lead — encouraging municipalities to separate and sell those materials for which there is a market, while disposing of those for which there is not.
Those who believe they are saving the earth by not sending plastic to the landfill are currently doing the opposite, as rogue shippers dump “microplastics,” some of which wind up in the water, poison sea life and pollute beaches. Nor is shipping plastic to Third World landfills, far less likely to be safely managed, an act of environmentalism. Just as we should strive to reshore some manufacturing, so should we do so with the disposal of all those Coke and water bottles.
Memo to Lee Zeldin: drop the misleading recycling goal.
Howard Husock is a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.
-
Trump says Zeldin plans to cut up to 65 percent of EPA staff
President Trump said Wednesday that Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Administrator Lee Zeldin has floated cutting the agency’s workforce by up to 65 percent. Speaking at the inaugural Cabinet ...The Hill - 4d -
Europe should hijack Trump’s revolutionary plans for the world
Liberal nationalists must respond with imagination to US policies rather than gripe at being cut out of Ukraine talksFinancial Times - 2d -
Nonprofit replaces foster kids' trash bags with luggage
Comfort Cases has provided more than 250,000 packs to children across the U.S.CBS News - 2d -
What are Trump’s USPS plans? He says the Postal Service is a ‘tremendous loser’ that should ‘operate a lot better.’
President Donald Trump on Friday said his administration is working on an overhaul of the U.S. Postal Service and indicated that multiple options were under consideration.MarketWatch - Feb. 21 -
UN talks end in Rome with nations backing $200 billion a year plan to protect nature
Yahoo News - 2d -
The World Is in a Polyester Crisis. One Company Is Trying to Recycle a Way Out
The European company Reju may have developed the polyester recycling technology the textile industry needs. The question is whether the world is ready for it.Wired - Feb. 21 -
Public nuisance lawsuits over plastics recycling lack legal foundation
Public nuisance is regularly being claimed as an unlimited vessel to load a wish list of policy preferences through litigation that have not and likely could not be achieved through legislation or ...The Hill - 4d -
Latest news on Trump's alarming EPA cuts remarks
The White House says President Trump mispoke when he alluded to deep staff cuts at the Environmental Protection Agency. This comes as a new budget plan passed in the House and fears remain about ...CBS News - 3d -
Lee's 25 lead Princeton past Harvard 76-71
Led by Xaivian Lee's 25 points, the Princeton Tigers defeated the Harvard Crimson 76-71ABC News - Feb. 21
More from The Hill
-
No, DOGE can’t fix the deficit. Here’s why.
Elon Musk and Donald Trump's Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) has made some cuts, but these amount to only 1.25 percent to 3 percent of the federal budget deficit, and are unlikely to ...The Hill - 27m -
Starmer unveils 4-step Ukraine plan: ‘We are at a crossroads in history’
United Kingdom Prime Minister Keir Starmer unveiled a 4-step plan for Ukraine. “We are at a crossroads in history,” Starmer said. His remarks come just days after Ukrainian President Volodymyr ...The Hill - 31m -
Gabbard: Zelensky’s ‘immediate escalation’ during WH meeting created ‘huge rift’ in relationship
Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard said Ukrainian President Zelensky’s “immediate escalation” during the White House meeting with President Trump created a “huge rift” in the ...The Hill - 41m -
House budget resolution is ‘screw America bill,’ House Democrat says
Rep. Steven Horsford (D-Nev.) on Sunday called a budget resolution that was recently adopted by House Republicans a “screw America bill.” “It's the screw America bill, and let me tell you why,” ...The Hill - 50m -
White House backs Israel blocking aid to Gaza
The White House is backing its ally Israel in its decision to block aid to Gaza amid Hamas’s refusal to agree to a second ceasefire deal. “Israel has negotiated in good faith since the beginning of ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
No, DOGE can’t fix the deficit. Here’s why.
Elon Musk and Donald Trump's Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) has made some cuts, but these amount to only 1.25 percent to 3 percent of the federal budget deficit, and are unlikely to ...The Hill - 27m -
Starmer unveils 4-step Ukraine plan: ‘We are at a crossroads in history’
United Kingdom Prime Minister Keir Starmer unveiled a 4-step plan for Ukraine. “We are at a crossroads in history,” Starmer said. His remarks come just days after Ukrainian President Volodymyr ...The Hill - 31m -
Gabbard: Zelensky’s ‘immediate escalation’ during WH meeting created ‘huge rift’ in relationship
Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard said Ukrainian President Zelensky’s “immediate escalation” during the White House meeting with President Trump created a “huge rift” in the ...The Hill - 41m -
House budget resolution is ‘screw America bill,’ House Democrat says
Rep. Steven Horsford (D-Nev.) on Sunday called a budget resolution that was recently adopted by House Republicans a “screw America bill.” “It's the screw America bill, and let me tell you why,” ...The Hill - 50m -
White House backs Israel blocking aid to Gaza
The White House is backing its ally Israel in its decision to block aid to Gaza amid Hamas’s refusal to agree to a second ceasefire deal. “Israel has negotiated in good faith since the beginning of ...The Hill - 1h