Lawmakers play high-stakes game of chicken in fight over California fire aid
The battle over wildfire aid for Los Angeles is quickly evolving into a game of high-stakes chicken.
Many Republicans are demanding conditions on any new emergency funding, blaming Democratic leaders in California for exacerbating the crisis.
Democrats are rejecting conditions outright, accusing Republicans of exploiting the disaster to score political points.
And both sides appear ready to stand firm, gambling that the other side will face the brunt of the public backlash if a partisan clash delays aid to victims of what is shaping up to be among the most damaging — and most expensive — natural disasters in the country’s history.
“It does set up this clash,” said Rep. Rep. Gregory Meeks (D-N.Y.). “But sometimes you've got to have principles and morals for what you're standing for. And I think the people will see who's playing a game.”
Republicans contend that the real game is happening in California, where Democratic leaders have mismanaged their fire-prevention programs and shouldn’t be given a blank check from Washington, even amid the disaster.
“It’s gotta be more than paid for, they’ve gotta own it,” said Rep. Ralph Norman (R-S.C.). “We cannot borrow money we don’t have to pay for something that is really the fault of the legislation, fault of the governor.”
What specific conditions on emergency funding GOP leaders will demand — if any — remains unclear. But different factions of the House Republican Conference are making their preferences known.
Some GOP lawmakers want any new aid to be coupled with a debt ceiling hike. Others, including leaders of the far-right House Freedom Caucus, want the cost to be offset by changes elsewhere in the budget. And still others say new funding must be paired with specific changes related to California’s fire-mitigation policies, which they blame for compounding the scope of the damage.
Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.), who supports some conditions on aid, is entertaining all of those options, although he has not committed to any specific demands.
“There are natural disasters, of course, but if they are made much worse by human error and deliberate policy — policy choices that were unwise and were stated as such at the time — then I think that that's something that needs to be carefully regarded,” Johnson said.
If Republicans insist on conditions in any form, Democratic leaders are already vowing to oppose the measure in no uncertain terms, setting the stage for one of the early partisan battles under incoming President Trump.
"Members of the California delegation have been very vocal on this matter and have made clear it is a complete and total nonstarter,” House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.) said Wednesday, rejecting any conditions on wildfire aid. “This Congress, in our nation's 248-year history, has never conditioned disaster assistance to everyday Americans whose lives have been upended by extreme weather events.
“Never has happened — and it should never happen."
Which side would bear the brunt of the blame for an impasse, of course, remains to be seen. But the voters’ verdict, in such an event, could have broad repercussions not only in Sacramento — where Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom is thought to have presidential ambitions — but in Washington, as well.
California is a Democratic stronghold. The party controls the Statehouse, both seats in the U.S. Senate and 43 out of 52 seats in the House. But a number of those House seats represent true battleground districts, where both sides vie every two years to gain an advantage in the lower chamber.
If voters side with GOP lawmakers in blaming Newsom, Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass — a former member of the U.S. House — and other Democratic leaders in the Golden State, Republicans could be in a position to benefit politically.
A long stalemate over conditions on aid, however, could also backfire on the GOP if voters shift the blame on Republicans for any delay — a scenario that’s not without precedent.
In 2013, conservatives scoffed at a federal emergency aid package in response to Hurricane Sandy, which struck the Northeast in late 2012. The deficit hawks said the package must be paid for by other changes to the budget — a stipulation that infuriated Republicans from New York and New Jersey, where the storm was most damaging, and triggered an internal fight within the GOP that benefited Democrats politically.
This time around, deficit hawks like Norman are voicing the same concerns about the budget impact of assistance to California. Rep. Andy Harris (R-Md.), head of the Freedom Caucus, said any emergency aid package must be offset “in full,” while new policy conditions should be imposed on California.
“Absolutely,” Harris said.
Rep. Tom McClintock (R-Calif.) is another vocal proponent of new fire-mitigation policies, advocating for “policy reforms to assure that the land-management practices that minimize these fires will be put back in place.”
Rep. Doug LaMalfa, another California Republican, sought to distinguish between the immediate needs in Southern California, including efforts to extinguish fires that are still raging out of control, and longer-term aid. That early help, he said, should not have conditions.
But any future federal assistance to help with rebuilding and other longer-term projects, he said, should come not only with fire-mitigation reforms at the state level, but also an examination of federal laws like the Endangered Species Act, which he said is “being manipulated” to prevent proper water storage and forest management.
“It's continuing to be weaponized,” LaMalfa said. “But it's not unheard of to have conditions — post-fire, post-emergency — on how the money's going to be used. Because my colleagues from other states, they're not excited about just giving California money.”
The threat that any form of emergency funding will be held up over partisan demands is already prompting a backlash from some other California Republicans, who are urging their GOP colleagues to resist the temptation to demand attachments to an aid package.
“Right now, what we need in California is federal aid as soon as possible. Worry about those, whatever the conditions or whatever, late,” said Rep. Young Kim (R-Calif.).
“Right now it’s not time to play politics here,” she added. “Just get us the support that we need.”
Mychael Schnell contributed.
Topics
-
Germany's Scholz under fire over funding for Ukraine aid package
Yahoo News - 5h -
A pink powder is being used to fight California fires. It's getting everywhere
The bright substance blanketing areas of Los Angeles County has long been used to stop wildfires from spreading.BBC News - 2d -
Barrasso predicts 'strings attached to money' for California fire aid
Senate Majority Whip John Barrasso (R-Wyo.) predicted Sunday “that there will be strings attached to money that is ultimately approved” for Los Angeles-area fire aid. “Do you expect, though, that ...The Hill - 4d -
Fact-checking criticism of California Democrats over fires
The US president-elect has criticised a top California Democrat for challenges fighting the blazes in Los Angeles.BBC News - 4d -
GOP rep suggests California relief aid should be withheld over state policies
Rep. Warren Davidson (R-Ohio) said he believes Congress should withhold disaster relief funds from California in the wake of Los Angeles wildfires until environmental policy changes are made by the ...The Hill - 4d -
Best Strategy Games To Play Over And Over Again In 2025
One of the earliest video game genres was strategy games. There's a long and cherished history of strategy games in the industry dating back to the 1970s with the creation of Risk and other games ...GameSpot - 5d -
With Stakes High, Lebanese Lawmakers to Try Again to Choose a President
Despite pressure by the United States and others to elect a president in order to receive financial support, a consensus candidate has yet to emerge who can clearly end Lebanon’s political gridlock.The New York Times - Jan. 8 -
Lawmakers play the market
Welcome to The Hill's Business & Economy newsletter {beacon} Business & Economy Business & Economy The Big Story Dozens of lawmakers beat stock market: report More than two dozen lawmakers once ...The Hill - Jan. 8 -
CALIFORNIA’S FENTANYL FIGHT: Lawmakers V. Grieving Parents
One of the hardest-fought political battles in 2024 happened inside California's Capitol between a group of grieving parents who lost their kids to fentanyl… and a handful of powerful California ...CBS News - Dec. 30
More from The Hill
-
Trump taps Voigt, Gibson and Stallone as 'special envoys' to Hollywood
President-elect Trump is leaning on some of his famous friends to influence Hollywood, tapping actors Jon Voight, Mel Gibson and Sylvester Stallone to serve as "special ambassadors" to the ...The Hill - 26m -
Watch live: Biden gives final address at Defense Department farewell ceremony
President Biden, poised to leave office in just days, will give remarks Thursday afternoon at a Department of Defense commander in chief farewell ceremony. His comments come on the heels of a ...The Hill - 27m -
Kash Patel’s challenge: reforming the FBI while winning its trust
Patel’s real test will be outlining and communicating his vision for the FBI, not just as an institution but as a community of dedicated law enforcement professionals with a unique culture and ethos.The Hill - 34m -
Conan O’Brien to receive Mark Twain Prize at Kennedy Center
Comedian Conan O’Brien is set to receive the Mark Twain Prize for American Humor at the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, the Kennedy Center said in a press release Thursday. O’Brien, ...The Hill - 45m -
Live Updates: DeSantis names Rubio successor; Bessent, Burgum appear before Senate panels
Thursday marks another busy day of hearings for President-elect Trump's Cabinet nominees as his inauguration approaches. The day will feature Lee Zeldin, the nominee to run the Environmental ...The Hill - 48m
More in Politics
-
Trump taps Voigt, Gibson and Stallone as 'special envoys' to Hollywood
President-elect Trump is leaning on some of his famous friends to influence Hollywood, tapping actors Jon Voight, Mel Gibson and Sylvester Stallone to serve as "special ambassadors" to the ...The Hill - 26m -
Watch live: Biden gives final address at Defense Department farewell ceremony
President Biden, poised to leave office in just days, will give remarks Thursday afternoon at a Department of Defense commander in chief farewell ceremony. His comments come on the heels of a ...The Hill - 27m -
Kash Patel’s challenge: reforming the FBI while winning its trust
Patel’s real test will be outlining and communicating his vision for the FBI, not just as an institution but as a community of dedicated law enforcement professionals with a unique culture and ethos.The Hill - 34m -
Conan O’Brien to receive Mark Twain Prize at Kennedy Center
Comedian Conan O’Brien is set to receive the Mark Twain Prize for American Humor at the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, the Kennedy Center said in a press release Thursday. O’Brien, ...The Hill - 45m -
Live Updates: DeSantis names Rubio successor; Bessent, Burgum appear before Senate panels
Thursday marks another busy day of hearings for President-elect Trump's Cabinet nominees as his inauguration approaches. The day will feature Lee Zeldin, the nominee to run the Environmental ...The Hill - 48m