Laugh out loud: Harris is held to an unfair standard compared to Trump?
Want to hear something funny? Atlantic editor-in-chief Jeffery Goldberg and National Public Radio senior political editor Domenico Montanaro believe Democratic presidential nominee Kamala Harris is unfairly held to a higher standard than her opponent, Republican nominee Donald Trump.
Yet even in advancing this argument, they proved the opposite.
“I want to talk about, I'll call it plainly, a double standard that we have in this campaign,” said Goldberg. “We’re sitting here, parsing, as we should, what the Democratic nominee for president says in an interview, how she answers questions about a whole range of subjects.”
He then played a video wherein Trump riffed about the inefficiency of green energy, including wind, and the correlation between clean energy mandates and the cost of groceries, including bacon. The point was completely lost on Goldberg.
“I’ll make this observation,” he said. “I’ll own it. If Kamala Harris went from bacon to wind in her interview with [CNN’s] Dana Bash, she would, this morning, not be — the next morning, she would not be the nominee of the Democratic Party.”
Goldberg seemed oddly baffled by the idea that any candidate would discuss how inefficient, artificially expensive energy alternatives drive up the cost of essential goods and services.
“That would have been a very, very strange — people would have been like, what is going on?” he said. “Do we just have an absurdly low standard now for the things that Donald Trump says and does?”
Responded Montanaro, “[T]here is definitely a double standard, and I think part of it is how each side’s voters interpret their candidate.”
“[F]rom a reporter’s standpoint,” he added, “we do have to be careful about how we — what level we hold both of them to.”
Of all things to cite as a contrast between Harris and Trump, they chose public speaking. Have they not heard Harris speak?
To hear journalists compare Trump’s rambling, nonsensical speaking style with Harris’s, as if there were any clear daylight between the two, is flat-out funny. Trump is infamously inarticulate and incomprehensible, especially if you don’t follow him from start to finish. He fills each sentence with so many tangents and digressions as to make himself almost unquotable.
But if there’s anyone who comes close to being as unintelligible and all-over-the-place as Trump, it's Harris.
Try this Harris wisdom on for size: "[W]e will work together and continue to work together to address these issues, to tackle these challenges, and to work together as we continue to work, operating from the new norms, rules and agreements that we will convene to work together on to galvanize global action."
Or this: "It is time for us to do what we have been doing. And that time is every day."
Also, this: "Culture is a reflection of our moment and our time, right? And present culture is the way we express how we're feeling about the moment, and we should always find times to express how we feel about the moment that is a reflection of joy because, you know — it comes in the morning."
Yet here we are, with two ostensibly well-educated writers and editors suggesting that, when it comes to public speaking, voters hold Harris to a higher standard than Trump.
“When I fact-checked Donald Trump’s hour press conference,” NPR’s Montanaro said to Goldberg, “he told 162 lies and distortions within that time period, 2.5 a minute, compared to Kamala Harris’s DNC acceptance speech, where she had 12 statements that I found were contextually misleading or needed more.”
About that 162 lies “fact-check.” In a word, it’s absurd. Montanaro and his colleagues arrived at that number only by juicing the stats. They devalued what would have been a straightforward news report by applying standards that no serious reporter would ever use on any other candidate.
“[President Joe Biden is] a very angry man right now,” Trump said during his Aug. 8 presser. “I can tell you that. He’s not happy with Obama, and he’s not happy with Nancy Pelosi. Crazy Nancy, she is crazy, too.”
NPR's “fact-check” found multiple lies in this statement of opinion. “Trump can’t speak to Biden’s state of mind," it stated. "[A]ll evidence is that Nancy Pelosi is perfectly sane — see her recent multiple rounds of interviews about her book, including with NPR.”
Trump also said of Harris, who has mostly avoided the press since winning her party’s nomination: “She can't do an interview. She's barely competent, and she can't do an interview.”
NPR responded with this unintentionally hilarious paragraph: "Harris hasn’t done interviews since getting into the campaign, but she has done them in the past, so saying ‘she can’t do’ one or that she is ‘barely competent’ are just insults. Trump tends to revert to questioning the intelligence of Black women who challenge him."
Said Trump, “And we’re very close to a world war. In my opinion, we’re very close to a world war.”
Responded NPR: “No serious person thinks that the U.S., Russia and China are about to start a world war.” That's interesting because in January, NPR published several panicky stories announcing that the so-called doomsday clock had moved closer to midnight, signaling “existential threats of nuclear war.”
“[Harris is] the border czar,” Trump said. “By the way, she was the border czar, 100 percent. And all of a sudden, for the last few weeks, she's not the border czar anymore, like nobody ever said it.”
NPR’s fact-check responded, “Harris was never appointed ‘border czar.’ That’s a phrase that was used incorrectly by some media outlets.”
This is a lie. When President Biden tapped Harris for the role, the vice president assumed all the duties (and then some) of former ambassador to Mexico Roberta S. Jacobson, who had been known then as the “border czar.” It was only after Harris’s mishandling of the matter proved politically disadvantageous that certain journalists decided to re-write history and claim she was never the border czar, but merely the “root causes” czar.
Trump also said at his presser, “Rasmussen came out today. We're substantially leading.”
NPR found this to be a lie. “Trump is not substantially leading, and Rasmussen is viewed as one of the least credible pollsters in the country."
But at the time of Trump’s remarks, Rasmussen had him five points ahead of Harris. Doesn't that make his statement true? As for the rest of the “fact-check,” it isn’t even a fact-check, it’s just Democratic Party rapid response.
Trump exaggerates; he loves hyperbole. And yes, he lies. He lies a lot. There is no reason to bloat a Trump fact-check with filler. In theory, he provides all the material you would ever need.
But the way NPR fudged the numbers here evinces not just plain bias but also a political agenda. Anyone sufficiently motivated and willing to employ such incredible standards could just as easily find 162 "lies" in anyone's speech, including Harris's. For example, Harris said at her party's convention that she believes “everyone has a right to safety, to dignity and to justice.” The inmates her office tried to exploit for cheap labor when she was California's attorney general might have something to say about that.
Further, if NPR were to apply the full Trump standard to Harris, we would probably see fact-checks asserting that it's actually impossible to be "unburdened by what has been."
We don’t see such fact-checks, because NPR operates within a system of double standards. It believes in a second set of standards that contrive impossibly stringent “fact-checks” for Trump while publishing this paragraph in its meager fact-check of Harris’s convention speech: “It’s the role of the press to try and hold politicians to account for the accuracy of their statements in a good-faith way. The dozen Harris statements lacking in context are far less in comparison to 162 misstatements, exaggerations and outright lies that NPR found from Trump’s hour-long news conference Aug. 8.”
Goldberg and Montanaro are correct. There is a double standard in how these candidates are treated. It’s just not the double standard they think it is.
Becket Adams is a writer in Washington and program director for the National Journalism Center.
Date: |
Topics
-
The Hill - Politics
White House calls out Musk's Harris assassination 'joke' as 'irresponsible'
The White House called Elon Musk’s now-deleted “joke,” which questioned why “no one is even trying” to assassinate Vice President Harris, “irresponsible” in a statement Monday. “As President Biden ...4 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
Suspect charged as Trump accuses Biden and Harris of incitement
Ryan Wesley Routh charged with gun-related offenses after apparent assassination attempt against former president. Muddled politics and multiple arrests: who is the suspect? US politics live – ...3 hours ago - Joe Biden -
The New York Times - Business
Donald Trump Rolls Out World Liberty Financial, A New Crypto Venture
In a livestream, Mr. Trump formally introduced World Liberty Financial, a crypto venture led by a pair of digital currency enthusiasts with little experience running high-profile businesses.2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
NBC News - Politics
Suspect in apparent assassination attempt didn't have Trump in line of sight when he was shot at
The man arrested in connection with an apparent attempt to assassinate Donald Trump is a former supporter who turned against the former president in part for foreign policy reasons and later ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
CBS News - Top stories
Starter homes increasingly out of reach for American families
Americans are increasingly unable to afford starter homes in many cities across the U.S. Among the problems, there's a shortage of about 5 million homes for sale or rent, and that's driving up ...3 hours ago -
Yahoo Sports - Sports
Panthers sticking with Young despite another ugly outing
Bryce Young will continue to start for Carolina, rookie coach Dave Canales says. Is it the right decision for Young or the Panthers?Yesterday -
ESPN - Sports
Eagles' Brown expects to be out 'couple of weeks'
Star receiver A.J. Brown told ESPN reporter Lisa Salters on Monday night that he expects to miss "a couple of weeks" with his injured hamstring, but the Philadelphia Eagles veteran added that he ...49 minutes ago - NFL -
ABC News - Top stories
Teacher shot at Georgia high school speaks out in emotional statement
Georgia teacher David Phenix was in his classroom at Apalachee High School when he was struck by two bullets -- but he said he's "incredibly blessed."7 hours ago -
The New York Times - Lifestyle
Kenny Bednarek’s Headbands Help Him Stand Out Among Sprinters
Kenny Bednarek isn’t as flashy as some runners, but his Olympic medals, and a vast collection of anime-themed headbands, make him stand out.Yesterday -
NBC News - Top stories
NBC News investigation reveals Texas medical school leasing out body parts of unclaimed corpses
A Texas medical center has been studying and leasing out the body parts of unclaimed people without the consent of that person or any survivors. After an NBC News investigation exposed its ...4 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Hillary Clinton condemns 'terrible' Trump assassination attempt, but he should try to 'calm the waters'
Hillary Clinton says she reacted in "horror" to the second apparent assassination attempt against Donald Trump, calling it a "terrible thing," but denounced the former president for continuing to ...36 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
GOP lawmaker suggests Trump may need to look at private security
Rep. Russ Fulcher (R-Idaho) suggested on Monday former President Trump consider hiring private security following the second apparent assassination attempt in the last few months. “If I'm President ...49 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Sean 'Diddy' Combs arrested in New York: Reports
The hip-hop mogul is set to appear in federal court at 10 a.m. ET Tuesday, sources tell NewsNation.1 hour ago - New York -
The Hill - Politics
Trump says crypto is 'fledging' yet ‘massive business’ in project launch
Former President Trump and his sons unveiled new details about their new cryptocurrency platform World Liberty Financial on Monday night, marking the former president’s latest embrace of digital ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Trump recounts being on golf course during apparent assassination attempt
Former President Trump on Monday offered his first recollection of what he was doing when Secret Service engaged an alleged would-be-assassin along the perimeter of his Florida golf club a day ...2 hours ago - Donald Trump