LA County tries to stop Catalina Island plans to shoot down invasive deer via helicopters
A proposal from California's Catalina Island to shoot down invasive mule deer via helicopter has met with a scathing response from Los Angeles County leadership.
The Catalina Island Conservancy, which manages 88 percent of the unincorporated territory's land, submitted a plan last August to the Department of Fish and Wildlife to eradicate the population, due to its negative impact on island wildlife.
But since that initial submission, members of the public have blasted the plans — leading the region's county supervisor, Janice Hahn, to send a letter last week to Fish and Wildlife, calling for the rejection of these plans with the unanimous support of the other four supervisors.
"Eradicating Catalina Island's entire population of more than 1,770 mule deer through aerial shooting from helicopters is inhumane and drastic, and potentially dangerous to the public," Hahn wrote, in the April 23 letter. "Less extreme measures to control the deer population that do not pose risks to public safety should be considered and employed."
The Catalina Island Conservancy plan examines various methodologies for mitigating the mule deer population, which was introduced to the island in the early 1930s as a game species.
"As an invasive animal, the mule deer destroy native and endemic vegetation only found on Catalina Island, which evolved without defense mechanisms against mule deer and outside threats," the group said. "The deer have no natural predators, so their population goes through extreme boom and bust cycles."
That population can range from 500 to more than 1,800 animals depending on rainfall, according to the Conservancy. At eight to 10 times the density of populations on the mainland, Catalina's deer are on one hand stripping the island of its native vegetation but on the other hand suffering starvation, the group argued.
The Conservancy explored six different types of mitigation methodologies, such as mass sterilization, through contraceptives or surgeries. Accessing sufficient deer across 70 square miles would be difficult, while contraceptive treatment could take years to work adequately, the group argued.
Relocation, meanwhile, would mean engaging in a capture process that sometimes causes the animals to die from stress-induced kidney or heart failure, the group noted. There is also no guarantee that the deer would easily adapt to a new environment, the report added.
The introduction of natural predators could cause further ecosystem issues, while also posing a threat to humans, according to the Conservancy. Tasking recreational hunters with eliminating the deer could be "effective when combined with other methods," but could end up dangerous, time-consuming and cost-prohibitive, the group found.
Assessing the possibility of fencing off the deer to physically isolate them, the writers found that doing so would be challenging due to the island's rugged landscape, while also impeding the population's access to life-sustaining natural resources.
On the other hand, the Conservancy characterized sharpshooting from helicopters as "an effective and efficient method for removing large numbers of deer over a relatively short period of time." This approach could occur "in a controlled and organized manner" and would not be limited by topographical obstacles, the group found.
In Hahn's letter to the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, she cited the "intense public outcry" and "significant community opposition" that led the supervisors to call for a rejection of the permit application.
“I understand the Conservancy’s concerns with the impact of the deer population, but I disagree that massacring hundreds of animals from helicopters is the right solution,” Hahn said in an accompanying statement.
As of last week, she noted that two petitions to stop the eradication plans had accrued almost 90,000 signatures.
“This plan is extreme and I have heard from my constituents both on and off the island who oppose it," Hahn continued. "I am asking the Conservancy to put this plan on hold and reconsider several alternative proposals they had previously dismissed."
When asked about the county's letter, the Conservancy said in a statement, “Although disappointed, we remain dedicated to finding a path forward with the County Supervisor’s office to make Catalina a safer, more self-sustaining, and resilient island for generations to come.”
The Hill has reached out to the California Department of Fish and Wildlife for comment.
Date: |
Filter
-
As it happened: William Lai sworn in as Taiwan's new president
William Lai faces an aggressive Beijing, a divided parliament and a disgruntled youth in his first term.BBC News - Top stories -
‘He was not radical’: Slovakia tries to make sense of Fico shooting
Friends in town of Levice say 71-year-old showed no signs of planning attack, while Slovakian president says climate of hate is collective work. Mile L’udovit, like other residents of the unassuming grey apartment block on the outskirts of the ...The Guardian - World -
French police shoot and kill man who tried to set fire to synagogue
Yahoo News - World -
No matter how I tried, I couldn’t get my stepchildren to accept me. So I stopped | Lucretia Grindle Lutyens
Being left out of family events, sending gifts that went unacknowledged – I took it all so personally, until I realised it wasn’t my problem. I was older when I married – 38. Well, it seemed like “older” then. I had never particularly wanted kids. ...The Guardian - World -
NFL shoots down another Taylor Swift conspiracy theory
The Bills host the Chiefs on Nov. 17 in Orchard Park. Swift is scheduled to perform six concerts in Toronto, on Nov. 14, 15 and 16 before the Buffalo game and again on Nov. 21, 22 and 23 afterward.Yahoo Sports - Sports - NFL -
Crypto Lender Genesis Global Gets Wind-Down Plan Approved
A bankruptcy judge approved a chapter 11 wind-down plan for Genesis that will pay back creditors about 77% of the same digital assets that they lent to the cryptocurrency lender before its bankruptcy filing.The Wall Street Journal - World - Crypto -
This financial adviser breaks down taxes and estate planning into 3 simple charts
These images can help you wrap your head around how to manage your money.MarketWatch - Business -
Mavs defense stops OKC, Celtics advance + offseason plans for Cavs, Hawks & Lakers | No Cap Room
Jake Fischer and Dan Devine discuss how the Dallas Mavericks won game 5 in Oklahoma City and talk about the offseason rumors swirling at the NBA Draft Combine.Yahoo Sports - Sports - NBA -
Yemen's Houthi rebels claim shooting down another US MQ-9 Predator drone
Yemen’s Houthi rebels have claimed the shooting-down of an American drone, hours after footage circulated online of what appeared to be the wreckage of an MQ-9 Reaper droneABC News - Top stories -
NBA picks, odds, best bets for Mavericks vs. Thunder: Why Game 6 will come down to 3-point shooting
Lean on an off-shooting night from Mavericks' P.J. WashingtonCBS Sports - Sports - NBA
More from The Hill
-
Biden: Trump’s rhetoric ‘not America’s’ after he shared video referencing ‘unified Reich’
President Biden said that former President Trump’s language isn’t representative of the United States after the former president shared a video on social media referencing a “unified Reich.” Biden’s reelection campaign released a video that ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
California bill to help Arizona abortion seekers heads to Newsom
A California bill that aims to help Arizonans seeking an abortion is back on Gov. Gavin Newsom’s (D) desk, just about a month after he introduced the legislation. The bill, Senate Bill 233, allows Arizona abortion providers to be quickly approved ...The Hill - Politics - California -
Unions bash Trump tax cuts
Welcome to The Hill's Business & Economy newsletter {beacon} Business & Economy Business & Economy The Big Story Labor unions have had enough of Trump’s tax cuts Top U.S. labor unions are calling for the repeal of former President Trump's ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Prosecutors, defense hash out jury instructions ahead of Trump trial closing
Hours after former President Trump’s defense rested its case-in-chief, the prosecution and defense returned to the courtroom to hash out specifics for jury instruction and other outstanding legalities. The proceedings in the Manhattan courtroom ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Boeing extends condolences after 777 hits severe turbulence, leaving 1 man dead
Boeing on Tuesday offered its "deepest condolences" after a flight heading for Singapore experienced "severe turbulence," killing one passenger and injuring others. A Singapore Airlines flight was traveling on a Boeing 777-300ER from London on ...The Hill - Politics