Kamala Harris should embrace her biracial heritage as a campaign strategy
The legendary Janet Jackson has added herself to a growing list of people focused on Vice President Kamala Harris’s race, falsely echoing earlier claims by Former President Donald Trump that Harris is somehow not Black.
The one person who has been conspicuously absent from the ongoing discourse about Harris’s racial identity is Harris herself.
Harris has generally avoided conversations about her race. In response to Trump’s comments that she only recently "turned Black," she simply said, "Same old, tired playbook." She did not mention her race once in her acceptance speech at the Democratic National Convention.
On Monday, that changed.
Harris appeared on “All the Smoke,” a podcast hosted by former NBA players, and finally spoke openly about her race, saying, “I’m clear about who I am. ... My mother was very clear. She was raising two Black girls to be two proud Black women. It was never a question.”
Of course Harris is Black — her father was Jamaican — but she is also Indian American. As a psychology professor who studies how people think about social groups, my research suggests that Harris would be judged most positively if she defined herself by her full identity as Black and Indian American.
Although race is a social construct, human psychology leads people to believe race is both inherent and essential. Somewhat surprisingly, these views extend to how we think about biracial identity. People — even those who are biracial themselves — conceptualize biracial identity as a “mixture” of identities that cannot be separated. Therefore, biracial people who claim just one race, or who identify flexibly based on context, are judged as duplicitous.
So it is not surprising that social media is aflame when Harris engages in the common practice of "code switching" — that is, changing the ways that she speaks across context, such as using a “Black accent” in Detroit and a Standard American English accent in Pittsburgh when discussing the importance of unions.
Ongoing research from my lab at University of California, Santa Barbara, shows this scientifically. My colleagues, Dr. Brenda Major and doctoral student Elizabeth Quinn-Jensen, and I surveyed 371 white American adults, asking them questions about a biracial person who initially claimed to be biracial and later claimed to be (only) Black.
Participants said that someone who made this shift was misrepresenting their identity and was untrustworthy. Importantly, participants positively evaluated biracial people who consistently claimed their full identity. A second survey found the same pattern in a diverse sample of 215 non-white American adults, about half of whom were Black.
But why did people judge identity shifting?
When Trump called Harris a racial chameleon and Republican vice presidential candidate, JD Vance hopped on the bandwagon, telling CNN that Harris was a “fundamentally fake person,” their supporters on X chimed in, eagerly noting they don’t care that Harris is Black, they just don’t like that she changes her identity to gain an (unfair) advantage.
In our survey, we asked this question head-on: How much do “unfair” advantages matter? To test this, we randomly assigned people to read about the same identity shift (from biracial to only Black), taking place on either a scholarship application or on an anonymous survey. Participants believed there would be no benefit to switching identities on an anonymous survey.
Despite this, a biracial person who claimed a Black identity on an anonymous survey was rated as untrustworthy as a biracial person who shifted their identity to gain a scholarship. Again, this pattern held for both white and non-white Americans.
The impact of identity switching, or not claiming her full identity, may be particularly problematic for Harris. Since becoming the Democratic presidential nominee, Harris has faced accusations of flip-flopping from all sides (think: immigration and fracking). She has moved to the center since her failed 2020 presidential run and is struggling to defend her record as vice president while differentiating herself from Joe Biden. Her racial identity may be interpreted as another means of flip-flopping.
Cultivating a reputation as trustworthy is particularly important as Election Day ticks nearer, with the outcome a true toss-up. Undecided voters will have a big impact on the final outcome. But undecided voters are less engaged with politics and rely more on likeability than issues. Trustworthiness is a key component of likeability, so Harris cannot afford to look untrustworthy.
Of course, Harris is not the only one in the race. Trump easily loses the battle for appearing trustworthy, consistently makes false claims ranging from big issues (that the 2020 election was “stolen”) to seemingly meaningless ones (crowd sizes at Harris’s rallies). At this point, Trump is a household name and people know what he is about. He doesn’t care to court voters with niceties, and his main strategy for dealing with personal critiques is to lob even harsher critiques at others.
But, when it comes to trust and the likeability game, if Harris is playing to win, she can take notes from “All the Smoke” co-host Matt Barnes, who notes he is proud of both his Italian and Black heritage. Kamala Harris’s candidacy is historic: she should openly define herself as the first Indian American and Black woman to seek our nation’s highest office as a major-party nominee.
Zoe Liberman is a professor of psychological and brain sciences at University of California, Santa Barbara, and a public voices fellow of The OpEd Project.
Date: | |
Tag: | Kamala Harris |
Topics
-
Top stories - CBS News
Liz Cheney to join Kamala Harris at campaign event
Former Congresswoman Liz Cheney will appear alongside Vice President Kamala Harris Wednesday at a campaign event in Ripon, Wisconsin, the birthplace of the Republican Party. CBS News campaign ...Yesterday - Kamala Harris -
Top stories - CBS News
Liz Cheney campaigns with Kamala Harris for first time
Vice President Kamala Harris and former Rep. Liz Cheney will appear in Ripon, Wisconsin, the birthplace of the Republican party.Yesterday - Kamala Harris -
Top stories - CBS News
Behind the Kamala Harris, Liz Cheney campaign event
Vice President Kamala Harris and former Rep. Liz Cheney will make their cross-party partnership official at an event in Wisconsin. CBS News' Shawna Mizelle has more on the Harris campaign effort to ...Yesterday - Kamala Harris -
Politics - NBC News
Harris will campaign in Wisconsin, part of her efforts to shore up the ‘blue wall’
Trump to rally in Michigan, Harris in neighboring WisconsinYesterday -
Top stories - The New York Times
Liz Cheney Campaigns With Harris and Calls on Her Party to Reject Trump
The former congresswoman and Republican exile stumped for Kamala Harris in Ripon, Wis., the birthplace of the G.O.P., calling on conservatives to shun Donald Trump’s “depraved cruelty.”16 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - NBC News
Harris is playing it safe. Some Democrats worry that could doom her campaign.
Even as polling shows the presidential race is a tossup, Vice President Kamala Harris has been running with a measure of risk aversion that some Democratic strategists and activists worry has ...10 hours ago -
World - The Guardian
Harris and Cheney blast Trump over January 6 as they make pitch to Republican voters – US politics live
Vice-president and Liz Cheney attack former president for 2020 election lies at Wisconsin campaign event. In a new Truth Social tirade on Thursday morning, Donald Trump accused Joe Biden and ...17 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - CBS News
Eye Opener: Vice President Kamala Harris campaigns with former Rep. Liz Cheney
Former Congresswoman Liz Cheney joins Vice President Kamala Harris on the campaign trail. Also, a mixed verdict in Tennessee for officers charged in the beating death of Tyre Nichols. All that and ...6 hours ago - Kamala Harris
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: Trump, Kemp tour Hurricane Helene damage in Georgia
Former President Trump is taking time off the campaign trail Friday morning, linking up with Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp (R) to survey the damage left by Hurricane Helene in the battleground state. The ...18 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
California regroups after Newsom veto
The Hill's weekly technology news digest. {beacon} Friday, October 4, 2024 LEADING THE DAY Newsom AI veto likely to stand Image © AP California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) this week vetoed perhaps ...18 minutes ago - California -
Politics - The Hill
Flu vaccine efficacy against hospitalization may be lower this season: CDC
Early estimates on the effectiveness of this year's flu vaccines indicate they may be less effective at preventing hospitalization than in years past, based on data from South America, where the ...20 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Biden: 'I don't know' if Netanyahu trying to influence election
President Biden on Friday said he wasn't aware of whether Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was trying to influence the U.S. election, while noting that no administration has been a ...26 minutes ago - Joe Biden -
Politics - The Hill
Independent panel calls for removal of Homeland Security watchdog
An independent group of investigators called on President Biden to remove the government watchdog at the Department of Homeland Security, finding Inspector General Joseph Cuffari misled Congress, ...46 minutes ago