Kamala Harris must protect Palestinians with an arms embargo
In her recent speech to the Democratic National Convention accepting the party’s nomination for president, Vice President Kamala Harris drew one of her most thunderous applause lines when she called for an end to the violence and suffering Israel is inflicting in Gaza and for the long-denied fulfillment of Palestinian rights to dignity, security, freedom and self-determination.
This enthusiastic reception, evinced by tens of thousands of die-hard Democrats at Chicago’s United Center, was a faithful reflection of where the base of the party stands on Palestinian-Israeli issues.
A May 2024 public opinion poll conducted by Data for Progress and Zeteo found that 83 percent of Democrats support the U.S. brokering a permanent ceasefire. A March 2024 Gallup poll found more Democrats sympathetic toward Palestinians than toward Israelis by a 10-point margin (43 percent to 35 percent) as Israel continues killing Palestinians in Gaza.
While Harris’s rhetorical commitment to Palestinian freedom and self-determination is noteworthy, these will be yet more empty words unless they are accompanied by a commitment to tangible policy change. Most importantly, this means following U.S. law and ending weapons transfers to Israel. No other policy step would have as much of an impact in generating a permanent ceasefire and advancing Palestinian freedom.
For decades, Israel has denied Palestinians their freedom under a brutal system of apartheid and military rule, backed by the munificent support of U.S. taxpayers, who have provided Israel with more than $100 billion in weapons.
As Israel’s violence against Palestinians over the past 10 months has increased, so too has the amount of weaponry the U.S. is providing to Israel. The Biden administration has circumvented congressional oversight to rush to Israel the delivery of more than $6 billion in weapons, and the Pentagon recently notified Congress of $20 billion in potential new sales, which will undoubtedly be financed by U.S. taxpayers.
From fighter jets to missiles, bombs, tank shells and mortars, U.S. weapons to Israel make us complicit in the war crimes and potential crimes against humanity Israel is inflicting on Palestinians in Gaza, as the death toll eclipses 40,000 people, including more than 16,500 children.
In her acceptance speech, Harris committed to “hold sacred” the principle of the rule of law. If elected president, her most immediate test of fidelity to this principle will emerge from her decision on whether to send additional weapons to Israel.
U.S. law is clear: no country can receive U.S. weapons to commit human rights abuses. The Foreign Assistance Act prevents the U.S. from furnishing any support to a country with a “consistent pattern of gross violations of internationally recognized human rights.” The Arms Export Control Act mandates that U.S. weapons be used “solely for internal security, for legitimate self-defense,” and for a few other scenarios not relevant to Israel’s attacks on Palestinians in Gaza. No sales or deliveries of any weapons are permitted to a country in “substantial violation” of these limitations.
In addition, current White House guidelines, embodied in its Conventional Arms Transfer policy, prohibit weapons deliveries to a country when it is “more likely than not that the arms to be transferred will be used by the recipient to commit, facilitate the recipients’ commission of, or to aggravate risks that the recipient will commit: genocide; crimes against humanity; grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions of 1949, including attacks intentionally directed against civilian objects or civilians protected as such; or other serious violations of international humanitarian or human rights law, including serious acts of gender‑based violence or serious acts of violence against children.”
As attested to by myriad Palestinian and international human rights organizations, as well as United Nations agencies and judicial bodies, Israel is brazenly violating every single clause of the Conventional Arms Transfer policy, which is supposed to prevent U.S. complicity in atrocities.
Not only should Harris commit to ending weapons transfers to Israel because U.S. law and policy mandate she do so if elected president, stopping weapons to Israel is also a smart electoral strategy to adopt. A March 2024 public opinion poll conducted by the Center for Economic and Policy Research found that 62 percent of Biden 2020 voters support halting weapons shipments to Israel, whereas only 14 percent oppose.
In addition, an August 2024 public opinion poll of voters in the critical swing states of Pennsylvania, Arizona and Georgia, conducted by the IMEU Policy Project, found that Democratic and independent voters would be more likely to cast their ballot for Harris if she were to support an arms embargo on Israel. Thirty-nine percent of Georgians would be more likely to vote for Harris in this scenario, whereas only 5 percent of voters would be less likely to vote for her, with similar results obtained in Arizona (35 percent to 5 percent) and in Pennsylvania (34 percent to 7 percent).
Unfortunately, Harris appears wedded to Biden’s failed strategy of providing Israel with weapons. As she put it in an interview with CNN, she would not withhold weapons.
More than 75 years ago, in November 1947, as the U.N. debated partitioning Palestine against the wishes of its majority indigenous inhabitants, the Truman administration imposed an arms embargo on all sides in Palestine for the commonsense reason, in the subsequent words of Secretary of State George Marshall, that to “permit American arms to go to Palestine and neighboring states would facilitate acts of violence and the further shedding of blood and thus render still more difficult the task of maintaining law and order.”
The Truman administration maintained its arms embargo against Israel after its establishment in May 1948, despite fierce lobbying from members of Congress, Zionist organizations in the U.S. and the Israeli government. Israel engaged in massive ethnic cleansing, driving more than 80 percent of Palestinians from their homes in what became Israel and turning them into refugees. But at least U.S. weapons did not contribute to this atrocity.
Today, as Israel continues its horrendous violence against Palestinians, which is in some respects even more deadly than the catastrophe of 1948, the obverse is true. The U.S. is profoundly complicit in Israel’s mass killing of Palestinians.
Because of her stated commitment to the rule of law, a permanent ceasefire and Palestinian freedom, Harris must now end U.S. complicity by backing a renewed arms embargo against Israel.
Josh Ruebner is policy director of the Institute for Middle East Understanding Policy Project.
Date: | |
Tag: | Kamala Harris |
Topics
-
The Wall Street Journal - World
Kamala Harris's Down-Payment Boost Isn't for Buying Houses
The logic is political.9 hours ago - Kamala Harris -
Yahoo News - World
Four Palestinians killed in Gaza, Israel hits another former school
8 hours ago - Israel -
Politico - Politics
House Dem campaign arm is touting its post-Biden ground game
September 3 - Joe Biden -
The New York Times - Top stories
Second Assassination Attempt Raises New Questions About Secret Service
That a gunman got close to former President Trump for the second time in about two months intensified questions about the agency’s broader protective capabilities.4 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Texas Republican says 'whoever wins' 2024 election, the public must 'support the president'
Rep. Tony Gonzales (R-Texas) stressed the importance of maintaining confidence in the 2024 election results and supporting “whoever wins” the presidency this November. “Whoever wins, I view myself ...13 hours ago -
CBS Sports - Sports
Bengals' Cam Taylor-Britt makes must-see, one-handed interception of Patrick Mahomes
Taylor-Britt made what may go down as the interception of the year5 hours ago - NFL -
CBS News - Top stories
Gary Cohn: Tariffs are "important instrument" for a president but warns of inflationary impact
Gary Cohn, who served as the head of the National Economic Council in the Trump administration, tells "Face the Nation with Margaret Brennan" said that tariffs such as the one proposed by the GOP ...12 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
Trump shooting attempt: Secret Service will have ‘every resource’ to protect Trump, says Biden, after apparent assassination bid – live
A suspect is in custody after the incident, which occurred at Trump International Golf Club in West Palm Beach, Florida. Armed suspect arrested in Florida after ‘attempted assassination’ of ...23 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Wall Street Journal - World
When Harris Defied Democracy
She refused to defend a California ballot measure that rejected same-sex marriage.9 hours ago - Kamala Harris
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Over half of Americans say Harris won debate against Trump: Poll
More than half of Americans believe Vice President Harris won last week's presidential debate against former President Trump, according to a new poll. An ABC/Ipsos poll, released Sunday, found 58 ...1 hour ago - Kamala Harris -
The Hill - Politics
John Leguizamo makes Emmys call for greater representation in Hollywood
John Leguizamo says he's a "DEI hire," as he made an appeal at the Emmy Awards for greater diversity and representation in Hollywood. "I'm John Leguizamo and I'm one of Hollywood's DEI hires," ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
FBI investigates second Trump assassination attempt: Five things to know
Former President Trump was the target of another apparent assassination attempt while golfing in Florida on Sunday, marking the second attempt on his life in as many months. The incident adds to ...2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
DeSantis says FL will conduct its own investigation of assassination attempt
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) said the state will conduct its own investigation into the apparent assassination attempt against former President Trump at his golf club Sunday in West Palm Beach. ...3 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Trump apparent assassination suspect identified: Reports
The man accused of pointing an AK-style rifle through the fence at Trump International Golf Club, where former President Trump was playing, has been identified as Ryan Wesley Routh, multiple media ...4 hours ago - Donald Trump