Justices unconvinced of arguments against FDA's flavored vape ban

Health Care

The Big Story

Justices unconvinced of arguments against FDA's flavored vape ban

Supreme Court justices appeared unswayed by arguments advanced by companies seeking to overturn the Food and Drug Administration's ban on flavored vapes, which the agency says are too risky for young people.

The suit filed by Triton and Vapetasia LLC claimed the FDA had essentially moved the goalpost in the midst of its review of the companies’ products.

These included vapes with names like “Jimmy The Juice Man Strawberry Astronaut” and “Suicide Bunny Mother’s Milk and Cookies,” coming in flavors of sour grape, pink lemonade and creme brulee.

Several lower courts all ruled in favor of the FDA, but the ultra-conservative U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit agreed with the plaintiffs, claiming the companies were told the agency required certain studies but then changed its mind and required different studies.

Conservative Supreme Court justices on Monday focused in on this same issue, but a majority of the bench was unsympathetic to the argument.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh pushed back at the vaping company attorney, joining the liberal justices in noting that the FDA had been clear from the outset it was making decisions based on whether the products appealed to young people.

“FDA has been pretty upfront about this,” Justice Elena Kagan told the companies’ lawyer, Eric Heyer.

“There’s just not a lot of mystery here about what FDA was doing. You might disagree with that. But you can’t say FDA hasn’t told you all about what it was thinking,” she added.

But looming over the case is the future of the FDA’s approach to vaping. President-elect Trump has vowed to “save vaping,” though his administration in 2020 attempted to restrict flavored vaping products.

Welcome to The Hill’s Health Care newsletter, we’re Nathaniel Weixel, Joseph Choi and Alejandra O'Connell-Domenech — every week we follow the latest moves on how Washington impacts your health.

Did someone forward you this newsletter? Subscribe here.

Essential Reads

How policy will be impacting the health care sector this week and beyond:

Supreme Court grapples with flavored vape ban: Key takeaways

The Supreme Court on Monday heard arguments about the federal regulation of flavored e-cigarettes, in a case pitting the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) against two vaping companies. Justices weighed whether the agency acted lawfully when it denied the applications of the companies to market fruity and dessert-flavored liquids for their electronic nicotine products. FDA deemed the flavors were too appealing to young people …

Full Story

Supreme Court weighs FDA ban on flavored vapes

Supreme Court justices grappled Monday with arguments about the Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA) regulation of flavored electronic cigarettes — and whether the agency acted unfairly in its decision to bar two companies from marketing their products with flavors the agency deemed were a risk to young people. The justices examined whether the FDA acted in an “arbitrary and capricious” manner when it made the decision …

Full Story

READ: House COVID-19 pandemic panel’s final report

The House Oversight and Accountability Committee’s COVID-19 panel issued its final report on Monday ahead of a hearing this week. The report yields five points of bipartisan consensus and seven findings. The report addresses the origins of the virus; U.S. funding for the lab in Wuhan, China, from which the report states the virus almost certainly leaked; mask mandates and lockdowns; Operation Warp Speed’s vaccine development, …

Full Story

On Our Radar

Upcoming news themes and events we're watching:

The House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic will hold a markup of its final report on Wednesday.
The Senate HELP Committee holds a Thursday hearing on FDA and the "diabetes and obesity epidemics.”

In Other News

Branch out with a different read:

Biden decries ‘stigma’ and ‘misinformation’ on World AIDS Day

President Biden called for a fight against “stigma” and “misinformation” on World AIDS Day in remarks at the White House. “We stand united in the fight against this epidemic,” Biden said Sunday. “It matters, it matters. … I remember as senator, when this epidemic was raging, the stigma, the misinformation, the government failing to act and acknowledge the dignity of [LGBTQ] lives and the seriousness of the AIDS epidemic.” During …

Full Story

Around the Nation

Local and state headlines on health care:

Who gets obesity drugs covered by health insurance? In North Carolina, it helps if you’re on Medicaid (KFF Health News)
California birth centers are shutting down. A lawmaker has a new plan to help them (Cal Matters)
Arizona vaccine skeptic Jeff Zink shortlisted for a job under RFK Jr. (Arizona Republic)

What We're Reading

Health news we've flagged from other outlets:

Scientists confront a mystery: why have U.S. bird flu cases been so mild? (STAT)
Potential conflicts of interest may haunt Dr. Oz’s confirmation to run Medicare, Medicaid (The Washington Post)
Long a ‘crown jewel’ of government, NIH is now a target (The New York Times)

What Others are Reading

Most read stories on The Hill right now:

Multiple Democrats slam Biden pardon of Hunter

President Biden’s decision to pardon his son Hunter Biden is further bruising a party that was already reeling from blistering electoral losses, with … Read more

Biden’s pardon of his son Hunter rattles the political world

President Biden’s announcement that he had pardoned his son, Hunter Biden, rattled the political world late Sunday. The president argued in a statement … Read more

What People Think

Opinions related to health submitted to The Hill:

You're all caught up. See you tomorrow!

Check out The Hill's Health Care page for the latest coverage.

Like this newsletter? Take a moment to view our other topical products here 📩

Topics

Supreme Court weighs FDA ban on flavored vapes

Supreme Court justices grappled Monday with arguments about the Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA) regulation of flavored electronic cigarettes — and whether the agency acted unfairly in its ...
The Hill - 1d
Supreme Court divided over FDA block on kid-friendly flavored vapes

With e-cigarette sales booming, the Supreme Court heard arguments over whether the FDA unlawfully blocked approval of more than a million new flavored nicotine products.
ABC News - 1d
Supreme Court Hears Case on FDA’s Rejection of Flavored Vapes

The question for the justices was whether the Food and Drug Administration had acted lawfully in rejecting applications from makers of flavored liquids used in e-cigarettes.
The New York Times - 1d
Supreme Court grapples with flavored vape ban: Key takeaways

The Supreme Court on Monday heard arguments about the federal regulation of flavored e-cigarettes, in a case pitting the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) against two vaping companies. Justices ...
The Hill - 1d
Supreme Court hears arguments over FDA’s refusal to approve flavored e-cigarettes

Makers of flavored e-cigarettes brought various cases challenging the FDA’s decision to refuse approval and alleged the agency changed its standards of evaluation on short notice. NBC News’ ...
NBC News - 18h
Hunter Biden pardon fuels Trump's 'weaponization' arguments

Trump's team was pointed to Biden's pardon of his son, Hunter, saying it showed that ending "the weaponization of our justice system needs to happen."
NBC News - 1d
Inside the Supreme Court Justices’ Ethics Debate

In private meetings and memos, the justices made new rules for themselves — then split on whether they could, or should, be enforced.
The New York Times - 16h