Justice Jackson suggests Trump claims risk turning Oval Office into 'seat of criminality'
Supreme Court Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson seemed to reject arguments from former President Trump’s attorneys Thursday that the justices must distinguish between personal and official acts to determine whether a president could be prosecuted, warning that the claims threaten turning the Oval Office into a “seat of criminality.”
The court heard oral arguments Thursday for Trump’s immunity case, in which the former president claims he cannot be prosecuted for alleged crimes committed while he was in office, arguing that legal liability limits the president’s ability to act.
Jackson noted that presidents have access to “the best attorneys in the world” to determine whether any of their actions are lawful.
“Why would we have a situation in which we would say that the president should be making official acts without any responsibility for following the law?” she asked.
But she later said she was concerned by Trump’s arguments that a president might be “chilled” in office if they must fear prosecution after they leave.
“I think that we would have a really significant opposite problem if … someone with those kinds of powers, the most powerful person in the world with the greatest amount of authority, could go into office knowing that there would be no potential penalty for committing crimes,” Jackson said.
“I'm trying to understand what the disincentive is from turning the Oval Office into, you know, the seat of criminal activity in this country.”
The Supreme Court arguments come after a federal special counsel charged Trump with multiple felonies, alleging he assisted efforts to overturn the 2020 election results. Trump’s attorneys have claimed innocence, adding that the former president’s actions were also protected by the office.
Liberal justices appeared critical of the Trump argument Thursday, with Justice Sotomayor quizzing the former president’s attorneys over the legal liability if the president were to have someone killed while in office.
“That well could be an official act,” Trump attorney John Sauer said, referring to an assassination of a political rival.
Sotomayor said Trump’s attorneys were asking the court to allow the president to use the office for “total personal gain without facing criminal liability.”
Trump’s argument has previously been rejected by two lower courts. The case marks the first time the justices consider an appeal arising from one of Trump’s four criminal indictments, and their decision could dictate whether those not at trial ever reach a jury.
Date: | |
Tag: | Donald Trump |
Topics
Filter
-
The FTC said former Pioneer CEO Scott Sheffield attempted to collude with OPEC officials to raise oil prices and referred the allegation to the Justice Department for a potential criminal probe.
The FTC said former Pioneer CEO Scott Sheffield attempted to collude with OPEC officials to raise oil prices and referred the allegation to the Justice Department for a potential criminal probe.The Wall Street Journal - World -
'Trader justice': Ex-SocGen trader fired for risky bets claims he was made a 'scapegoat'
A former Societe Generale trader who was fired for unauthorized risky bets has lambasted the French bank for making him a "scapegoat."CNBC - Business -
Stormy Daniels’ former lawyer testifies in Trump’s New York criminal trial
Keith Davidson, Stormy Daniels’ former lawyer, testified about arranging a $130,000 payment from Trump’s former lawyer and fixer Michel Cohen to the adult film star to stay quiet about an alleged sexual encounter with Trump.CBS News - Top stories - New York -
Hope Hicks takes stand in Trump's New York criminal trial
Former Trump campaign press secretary and White House communications director Hope Hicks has taken the stand in Donald Trump's New York criminal trial where he's accused of falsifying business records of payments to cover up alleged sex scandals. ...CBS News - Top stories - New York -
Hope Hicks tells hush-money jury of Trump’s control over 2016 campaign
Ex-president’s former communications director says Access Hollywood tape ‘was a crisis’ for his campaign. Hope Hicks, Donald Trump’s 2016 campaign press secretary, broke into tears on Friday while testifying in the ex-president’s New York criminal ...The Guardian - World - Donald Trump -
Equal justice is under threat in Louisiana
Don’t look now, but there’s a power grab in Louisiana, putting public defense into the hands of a single person.The Hill - Politics -
The Phil Jackson-sized hole plaguing the Los Angeles Lakers
The Lakers will hire their seventh coach since 2011 as yet another summer of upheaval and searching begins. The question now is: Why does this keep happening?ESPN - Sports - NBA -
George Conway dismisses Trump claim about not sleeping in court
Conservative lawyer George Conway in an interview late Thursday dismissed former President Trump’s claims about not sleeping in court after reporters noticed Trump closing his eyes during the hush money case in New York. Conway, a frequent Trump ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Judge corrects Trump's claim that gag order prevents his testimony
The judge handling former President Trump's hush money case clarified Friday that Trump is allowed to testify during the trial, correcting the former president's assertion a day earlier that a gag order prevented him from doing so. Judge Juan ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump
More from The Hill
-
To prevent Georgia going down Putin’s path, sanction the country’s Russian puppets
Western governments have been far too passive for far too long, as Georgian Dream has moved the country in a nondemocratic direction closer to Russia.The Hill - Politics - Russia -
Former RNC Chair: Trump 'afraid of losing,' most important thing to him 'is his ego'
Former Republican National Committee (RNC) Chair Michael Steele sharply criticized former President Trump’s inability to admit he lost the last presidential election and said he’s afraid of losing the upcoming one in November because it will hit ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Dean Phillips becomes first Democrat to call for Cuellar to resign
Rep. Dean Phillips (D-Minn.) became the first Democrat to call for Rep. Henry Cuellar (D-Texas) to resign in light of the Justice Department (DOJ) indictment he and his wife were hit with on Friday. “While the bar for Federal indictment is high, ...The Hill - Politics -
Moral rot: How Hamas sympathizers took over American college campuses
The rot runs so deep on our college campuses that drastic changes will be required to protect Jewish students and restore high standards of academic and moral excellence to many U.S. universities.The Hill - Politics -
Ex-Rep. Santos asks former colleagues if they would draft expulsion resolution for Cuellar
Former Rep. George Santos (R-N.Y.) went after former House colleagues Saturday, asking if they would draft a resolution to expel Rep. Henry Cuellar (D-Texas). “Hey @RitchieTorres are you going to draft an expulsion resolution for Henry Cuellar? Or ...The Hill - Politics