Judges reject GOP overseas ballot challenges in Michigan, North Carolina
State judges in Michigan and North Carolina on Monday rejected the Republican National Committee’s (RNC) separate challenges to certain overseas ballots in the key swing states.
The RNC alleged the two states were improperly accepting overseas ballots from people who never lived in their jurisdictions.
In two separate rulings handed down Monday, judges rejected the RNC’s requests that could’ve called thousands of ballots into question.
Overseas voting has become the latest battleground in Republicans’ election lawsuits this cycle. The voting bloc is viewed as increasingly Democratic as it now primarily comprises U.S. citizens living abroad, rather than uniformed service members.
The RNC challenged how the states accept ballots from citizens living abroad who never lived there, as long as their parents were eligible to vote in the state before moving overseas. Michigan also extends the protections to spouses.
In Michigan, Judge Sima Patel ruled that the RNC waited too long to bring its case, writing that it would be “extremely difficult or impossible” to set aside the challenged ballots so close to Election Day. The state’s guidance about who could submit an overseas ballot was legal anyway, Patel ruled.
“A challenge could have been raised at any time after 2017, and should have at least been brought earlier in the year leading up to the general election, not 28 days before,” Patel wrote in the ruling.
Though she sided with state officials, Patel declined their request to sanction the plaintiffs, which comprised the RNC, the Michigan Republican Party and a local clerk.
In North Carolina, Judge John Smith refused the RNC’s request for an injunction in advance of the upcoming election, finding the RNC was unlikely to succeed in its lawsuit. Smith ruled that the RNC had “not presented any evidence” that fraud occurred.
“This court has weighed the hypothetical possibility of harm to plaintiffs against the rights of the defendants and finds that on balance the equitable discretion of this court should not be invoked to treat an entire group of citizens differently based upon unsupported and speculative allegations for which there is not even a scintilla of substantive evidence,” Smith wrote in his ruling.
That suit was joined by the North Carolina Republican Party and two Republican voters.
Another lawsuit challenging overseas ballots in Pennsylvania remains pending.
The RNC is not involved in that case, which was filed by six Republican congressmen from the state claiming election officials aren’t meeting federal verification requirements for overseas ballots. State officials there contend the congressmen are misreading federal election law and the steps are not required.
A hearing on the lawmakers' request for an injunction was held Friday, and the judge could rule anytime.
Date: |
Topics
-
Top stories - CBS News
Michigan judge rebuffs GOP bid to block some overseas, military family ballots
5 hours ago -
Top stories - NBC News
As North Carolina begins voting, hurricane devastation complicates casting ballots
4 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
More than 350,000 ballots cast as early voting opens in North Carolina
3 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
More than 1 million voters cast early ballots in North Carolina
Yesterday -
Top stories - NBC News
Asheville schools to reopen a month after Helene hit, but challenges remain
5 days ago -
Top stories - NBC News
Major challenges remain in North Carolina more than two weeks after Hurricane Helene
5 days ago -
World - The Guardian
Harris and Cheney talk economy, women’s health and Trump in Michigan campaign event – US elections live
1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Republicans head to court in expanding battle about overseas ballots
Yesterday - Republican Party -
Top stories - ABC News
GOP lawsuit against overseas votes draws ire from military families
10 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Biden says 'a woman can do anything a man can do, and then some'
1 hour ago - Joe Biden -
Politics - The Hill
Researchers say Arkansas may have 19M tons of lithium critical for battery power
2 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Austin makes political message in Ukraine trip
2 hours ago - Ukraine -
Politics - The Hill
The White House's plan to boost contraception access
3 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Walz grills Trump for McDonald's 'cosplaying'
3 hours ago - Donald Trump
Latest in Politics
-
Politics - The Hill
Biden says 'a woman can do anything a man can do, and then some'
1 hour ago - Joe Biden -
Politics - The Hill
Researchers say Arkansas may have 19M tons of lithium critical for battery power
2 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Austin makes political message in Ukraine trip
2 hours ago - Ukraine -
Politics - NBC News
Trump campaigns in North Carolina as race tightens
2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - NBC News
Harris barnstorms in three crucial swing states
2 hours ago