Judge tells health agencies to restore website data

Health Care

The Big Story

Judge tells health agencies to restore website data

A federal judge directed health agencies to restore webpages and online datasets that were recently removed in response to an executive order from President Trump.

U.S. District Judge John Bates issued a temporary restraining order on behalf of Doctors for America, a left-leaning physicians advocacy group, which recently sued a handful of federal agencies for scrubbing their websites of data they regularly use.

The physicians group argued the removal of the once publicly available data made it harder for them to treat patients and violated federal law.

After Trump signed executive orders aimed at “gender ideology” and diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) efforts, federal health agencies began to scrub their websites to comply with the orders.

Several health agencies including the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention went almost completely dark as a result. Some of that data has been restored already, like CDC resources for tracking and preventing HIV.

But most of what has been removed is still missing, including recommendations for treating sexually transmitted infections and guidelines on prescribing contraception.

Judge Bates, a George W. Bush appointee, concluded that the removal of data likely violated a provision requiring federal agencies to provide “adequate notice or reasoned explanation.”

“This opinion has documented the harm DFA members have suffered and will continue to suffer absent intervention, but the harm extends beyond them,” Bates wrote in his ruling, referring to members of the advocacy group.

“DFA has also supplied declarations from doctors around the country who, although not DFA members themselves, are representative of the widespread disruption that defendants’ abrupt removal of these critical healthcare materials has caused,” he continued.

Health care workers routinely use such guidelines to determine how best to treat patients, making their removal harmful to doctors and the people they care for, according to Zachary Shelley, an attorney representing the physicians group.

“You can’t put the toothpaste back in the tube that has already come out,” Shelley said. “You can stop it from flowing out going forward. Every day that this goes on, there’s harm to the doctors and their patients and public health.”

Read more about the lawsuit from The Hill’s Zach Schonfeld.

Welcome to The Hill’s Health Care newsletter, we’re Nathaniel Weixel, Joseph Choi and Alejandra O'Connell-Domenech — every week we follow the latest moves on how Washington impacts your health.

Did someone forward you this newsletter? Subscribe here.

Essential Reads

How policy will be impacting the health care sector this week and beyond:

GOP leaders downplay Medicaid cuts as they seek $2T in savings

House Republican leaders on Tuesday downplayed the possibility of cuts to Medicaid benefits as they seek a reconciliation bill with up to $2 trillion in savings. Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) and Majority Leader Steve Scalise (R-La.) sought to reassure the public — and potential jittery members of their own caucus — that the Medicaid changes under discussion include work requirements and fraud reduction, not drastic cuts …

Full Story

Federal judge pauses NIH research cuts nationwide

A federal judge in Boston has ordered a temporary pause nationwide on plans by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) to substantially reduce “indirect” research payments to universities, medical centers and other recipients. Judge Angel Kelley of the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts granted the temporary restraining order in response to a lawsuit filed by associations representing teaching …

Full Story

Canned tuna sold at Walmart, Trader Joe’s, Costco recalled in multiple states

(WJW) – The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has announced a recall of canned tuna products sold at multiple major retailers, including Walmart, Trader Joe’s, Kroger and Costco. According to the alert, Tri-Union Seafoods is voluntarily recalling some canned tuna products after learning about a manufacturing defect involving the “easy open” pull tab lid that may compromise the can’s seal and cause it to leak …

Full Story

In Other News

Branch out with a different read from The Hill:

Democrats unveil legislation in bid to halt USAID elimination

A group of House Democrats have introduced legislation in a bid to stop the Trump administration from dismantling the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID).

Full Story

Around the Nation

Local and state headlines on health care:

New York City nonprofit hospital draws backlash for Super Bowl ad (Axios)
Flu deaths surpass COVID deaths in California for first time since start of pandemic (The Mercury News)
‘Personhood’ bill moves to Montana house floor (Daily Montanan)

What We're Reading

Health news we've flagged from other outlets:

A leading pediatrician was already worried about the future of vaccines. Then RFK Jr. came along (The LA Times)
RFK Jr. says vaccines aren’t tested enough. Experts say that’s baseless (Washington Post).
Flu cases on the rise amid new concerns about government health data (Scripps News)

What Others are Reading

Most read stories on The Hill right now:

Musk defends DOGE alongside Trump in striking Oval Office moment

Elon Musk on Tuesday defended the work of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) alongside President Trump, who invited Musk to speak and sat … Read more

6 hidden messages in Kendrick Lamar’s Super Bowl performance

Kendrick Lamar’s Super Bowl halftime performance is growing in viewership hours after the big game, gaining more 11 million views since it aired Sunday … Read more

What People Think

Opinions related to health submitted to The Hill:

You're all caught up. See you tomorrow!

Check out The Hill's Health Care page for the latest coverage.

Like this newsletter? Take a moment to view our other topical products here 📩

Topics

Judge orders HHS, CDC, FDA to restore deleted webpages with health information

The NGO Doctors for America argued that HHS, CDC and FDA violated federal law in removing medical information from public-facing websites.
CBS News - 8h
Judge orders HHS, CDC, FDA to restore deleted webpages with health information

The NGO Doctors for America argued that HHS, CDC and FDA violated federal law in removing medical information from public-facing websites.
CBS News - 8h
Judge orders health agencies to restore data scrubbed by Trump administration

A judge ordered federal health agencies Tuesday to restore online datasets taken down after President Trump issued an executive order prohibiting the government from promoting “gender ideology.” ...
The Hill - 8h
Trump administration ordered to lift payment block on health agency

Federal judge tells White House to unlock billions in funding for clean energy projects earmarked under Inflation Reduction Act
Financial Times - 1d
Trump ordered by judge to immediately restore frozen funding

John McConnell says administration had defied earlier order to resume disbursement of billions of dollars. A federal judge said on Monday that the Trump administration had defied his order to ...
The Guardian - 1d
Who Are the Acting Heads of Federal Health Agencies?

This is a MedPage Today story. As President Donald Trump's picks to lead federal health agencies await confirmation hearings, there are now acting directors in place at HHS and its key ...
ABC News - 2d
Scientists, researchers work to archive federal health data purged by Trump administration

Scientists, researchers and private health organizations scrambled to preserve as much federal public health data and guidelines as possible last week after news reached them that the Trump ...
The Hill - 3d
Major cancer research group calls on Trump administration to restore data access

The American Cancer Society is calling on the Trump administration to restore access to comprehensive scientific data.
ABC News - 3d
Physician Group Sues Trump Health Agencies Over Scrubbed Sites, Data

This is a MedPage Today story. Physicians have launched a legal challenge against the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) and federal health agencies for removing webpages from health-related ...
ABC News - 6d