Judge signals toward granting Dem challenge to OMB freeze after order rescinded
A federal judge said Wednesday he plans to grant a group of Democratic attorneys general's request to block President Trump’s freeze on federal aid, even though the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) memo was rescinded amid confusion earlier in the day.
At the end of a 35-minute virtual hearing, U.S. District Judge John McConnell signaled he agreed the OMB's rescission of its Monday night announcement did not moot the motion filed by 22 states and Washington, D.C.
“The inappropriate effects that the state has put forward, I think the state has convinced me are going to continue. And that hasn't changed based on comments by the president's press secretary,” McConnell said.
The freeze has sparked widespread confusion, even after the OMB memo was tossed earlier in the day. White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt in a post to social platform X cautioned the administration was only rescinding the memo itself, not the funding freeze.
“And so I'm inclined to grant the restraining order,” McConnell said, “though I'm struggling with how it would be worded, and what effect it would have.”
The judge ordered the states to propose new language for the order before he signs off on it. Once the states file their proposal, the judge said he’ll provide the Justice Department with 24 hours to respond.
The case is one of two major lawsuits filed in response to this week’s announcement. In response to a separate challenge from private organizations, a federal judge in D.C. issued an order Tuesday temporarily blocking the administration from moving forward with its plans, at least until next week.
At Wednesday’s hearing, the government contended the Democratic attorneys general's motion was no longer a live controversy and they would need to separately file claims if they want to directly contest Trump’s flurry of executive orders.
“The motion is directed against the OMB memo,” Justice Department attorney Daniel Schwei said. “And I think it is a fundamentally different thing for them to seek relief against the potential effect of an executive order on an agency.”
The judge, who was appointed by former President Obama, at the start of the hearing signaled the motion may be moot. But ultimately, the states won him over by stressing the White House press secretary’s comments.
“The policy has not changed,” said Sarah Rice, representing Rhode Island. “And that policy, to sum it up, is 'Freeze first, ask questions later.' That's the gravamen of our complaint; that is the source of our harm.”
The judge later expressed sympathy that the Democratic-led states and their citizens will still face irreparable harm despite the rescinded memo.
“I fear, Mr. Schwei, that that the administration is acting with a distinction without a difference,” McConnell said.
“Ms. Rice, I think, has convinced me that that while the piece of paper may not exist, that there's sufficient evidence that the defendants collectively are acting consistent with that directive,” he continued.
Updated at 4:30 p.m. EST
Topics
-
Judge signals he will block Trump administration from freezing funding
A federal judge signaled he will issue a temporary restraining order barring the Trump administration from freezing federal loans and grants.ABC News - 2h -
Chaos Continues as Trump Administration Rescinds Memo Freezing Federal Grants and Loans, But Says Freeze Will Continue
Here’s where things stand with funding for SBA loans, federal contracts, and other programs.Inc. - 20h -
White House says Trump funding freeze remains in effect despite rescinding OMB memo
The OMB memo had directed federal agencies to pause grants and loans pending a review of compliance with the agenda of President Donald Trump.CNBC - 21h -
Trump defends aid federal funding freeze after White House says it rescinds order
President Donald Trump defended the federal aid spending freeze, saying it “in no way affected” Social Security, Medicare or Medicaid. The administration rescinded the order that froze federal ...NBC News - 22h -
White House rescinds memo on freezing federal grants and loans
The freeze on hundreds of billions of dollars of federal grants had been temporarily halted by a judge on Tuesday.BBC News - 22h -
White House rescinds spending freeze on federal loans and grants
Press secretary insists administration isn’t backing down on fight to curb what they consider government waste. US politics live – latest updates A US judge granted a restraining order to stop ...The Guardian - 23h -
Dem states signal imminent legal action against Trump administration over federal grant freeze
Several Democratic states have signaled imminent legal action to block a Trump administration order directing federal agencies to pause the disbursement of loans and grants while the government ...The Hill - 2d -
Judge reverses order, grants Oath Keepers access to Capitol after Trump clemency
A judge had ordered the Oath Keeper members convicted of crimes related to the Capitol riot on Jan. 6, 2021, to be barred from entering the U.S. Capitol court permission.CBS News - 2d
More from The Hill
-
A permanent Medicare telehealth expansion is an easy bipartisan victory
There’s no better model of efficiency — the very platform of the Trump administration — than telehealth, which has proven to be a cost-effective solution.The Hill - 15m -
Protecting small farmers during a time of radical transformation
High land prices and a rise in institutional investing in farmland are making it difficult for small farmers to compete.The Hill - 45m -
OpenAI's Sam Altman downplays impact of DeepSeek: 'Wildly overstated'
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman downplayed the significance of a new artificial intelligence (AI) model released by Chinese startup DeepSeek on Thursday, saying it did a “couple of nice things” but has been ...The Hill - 1h -
OpenAI to partner with US National Laboratories to boost national security
OpenAI announced Thursday it is partnering with the Los Alamos National Laboratory to install its newest artificial intelligence models onto the lab's supercomputer for national security research. ...The Hill - 1h -
House Republican: 'Let’s hold off on all the finger-pointing' on DC plane crash
Rep. Tim Burchett (R-Tenn.), who sits on the House’s Transportation Committee, said he would caution people and conservative Republicans on finger-pointing in the aftermath of the plane crash ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
A permanent Medicare telehealth expansion is an easy bipartisan victory
There’s no better model of efficiency — the very platform of the Trump administration — than telehealth, which has proven to be a cost-effective solution.The Hill - 15m -
Protecting small farmers during a time of radical transformation
High land prices and a rise in institutional investing in farmland are making it difficult for small farmers to compete.The Hill - 45m -
Senators on both sides press Gabbard on if she thinks Edward Snowden is 'a traitor'
Sen. James Lankford, R-Okla., and Sen. Michael Bennet, D-Colo., both pressed Tulsi Gabbard about if she viewed Edward Snowden as a traitor or not during her confirmation hearing to serve as the ...NBC News - 56m -
OpenAI's Sam Altman downplays impact of DeepSeek: 'Wildly overstated'
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman downplayed the significance of a new artificial intelligence (AI) model released by Chinese startup DeepSeek on Thursday, saying it did a “couple of nice things” but has been ...The Hill - 1h -
OpenAI to partner with US National Laboratories to boost national security
OpenAI announced Thursday it is partnering with the Los Alamos National Laboratory to install its newest artificial intelligence models onto the lab's supercomputer for national security research. ...The Hill - 1h