Judge lashes out at Trump admin over deportation flights
A federal judge lashed out at the Trump administration Monday for refusing to answer questions about flights deporting Venezuelan migrants under the Alien Enemies Act after he ordered them to turn around the planes.
It was a remarkable hearing in which a Justice Department attorney repeatedly declined to provide details about the flights that landed in El Salvador on Saturday evening, saying he was “not authorized” to do so, a rare instance of an attorney rebuffing a judge’s questions.
U.S. District Court Judge James Boasberg called the hearing after a Monday morning filing from the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) arguing the government may have violated a court order halting the flights — apparently refusing to turn them around after the judge barred them.
At Monday’s hearing, Deputy Associate Attorney General Abhishek Kambli contended the judge’s oral command wasn’t binding because the judge didn’t include the instruction about airborne flights in his written order.
“I memorialize it in shorthand, but you're telling me that very clear point, that you could disregard it, because it wasn’t in the written order?” pressed Boasberg, an appointee of former President Obama.
“Wouldn’t it have been a better course to return the planes around the United States as opposed to going forward and saying, ‘We don’t care, we’ll do what we want’?” Boasberg asked later in the hearing.
“Your Honor, that’s not the approach that we’ve taken in this argument,” Kambli responded.
The arguments from Kambli were in lockstep with assertions from the White House earlier in the afternoon.
“All of the planes subject to the written order of this judge departed U.S. soil, U.S. territory before the judge’s written order,” White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters.
She added the White House has "questions about whether a verbal order carries the same weight as a written order, and our lawyers are determined to ask and answer those questions in court."
Judges routinely give oral orders from the bench, and they are binding, just like written orders posted to a court’s docket.
The ACLU on Monday said Boasberg issued an oral order to turn around the planes at approximately 6:45 p.m. EDT. Those instructions were also posted to the court’s docket at 7:26 p.m. EDT.
The ACLU included flight information it received from the government, indicating the planes did not land in Honduras until 7:36 p.m. EDT and 8:02 p.m. EDT on Saturday. The group suggested the planes later took off again before ultimately landing in El Salvador, arriving hours after each of Boasberg’s orders.
The ACLU has also disputed the Justice Department’s insistence that none of the flights took off from the U.S. after Boasberg’s rulings, citing a media report.
At one point in the hearing, Boasberg questioned why the flights were arranged at all, noting that the government knew Saturday morning they would face a hearing on the legality of the flights at 5 p.m.
The Trump administration on Saturday invoked the Alien Enemies Act, which it said grants the power to deport without hearing any Venezuelan it deems to be a member of the Tren de Aragua gang.
El Salvador has agreed to house the 361 deported migrants removed on the flight, though 137 were deported under the Alien Enemies Act.
At various points during his exchange with Kambli, Boasberg expressed surprise at the refusal to answer questions or disclose the information to a jurist.
He noted if the flight information couldn't be shared publicly they could use the “husher” to block out sound when he approached the bench.
He also noted that Kambli did not seem to assert the information was classified, pointing to his background on the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, and offered the chance to share the information with him in a secure setting.
As the administration simultaneously seeks to appeal Boasberg’s ruling, it has looked to remove the judge from the case, saying he has employed “unusual and improper” procedures.
At the end of Monday’s hearing, the judge ordered the administration to provide information about the flight timelines, or provide justification for refusing to do so, by noon EDT on Tuesday.
“I’m going to detail this in a written order since apparently my oral orders don’t carry much weight,” the judge quipped.
-
Judge blocks deportations under 1798 law, orders flights turned around
A federal judge has blocked the Trump administration from deporting any noncitizens pursuant to the president's recent proclamation invoking the Alien Enemies Act.ABC News - 2d -
Trump administration says deportation flights were over international waters before judge's order
The Trump administration over the weekend deported hundreds of immigrants to El Salvador under the Alien Enemies Act despite a judge ordering them not to. CBS News immigration and politics reporter ...CBS News - 10h -
Judge blocks Trump admin from deporting 5 Venezuelans amid plans to invoke Alien Enemies Act
A federal judge on Saturday preemptively blocked the Trump administration's reported efforts to quickly deport five Venezuelan nationals under the Alien Enemies Act (AEA) of 1798. The move from ...The Hill - 2d -
White House questions authority of judge's verbal order on Venezuelan deportation flights
The White House on Monday cast doubt on the authority of a verbal order from a judge directing the administration to turn around planes carrying Venezuelan migrants out of the country. White House ...The Hill - 10h -
Timeline of Trump’s Deportation Flights, From Alien Enemies Act to Judge’s Order
A New York Times review of flight data showed that at the time of a federal judge’s order, two flights were in the air, and one had not yet taken off.The New York Times - 3h -
A judge limits Trump's ability to deport people under the 18th century Alien Enemies Act
A federal judge on Saturday blocked the Trump administration from using an 18th century law known as the Alien Enemies Act to deport five Venezuelans, kicking off a blizzard of litigation over the ...NBC News - 2d -
Judge orders hearing over Trump deportations under Alien Enemies Act despite court ruling
A federal judge has scheduled a hearing for Monday afternoon on whether the Trump administration violated a court order against using a law passed in 1798 to deport hundreds of undocumented ...CBS News - 9h -
White House touts deportations under Alien Enemies Act after judge block efforts
The Trump administration announced deportations of hundreds of immigrants it alleges are members of a Venezuelan gang to El Salvador under the Alien Enemies Act.NBC News - 1d -
White House touts deportations under Alien Enemies Act after judge blocks efforts
The Trump administration announced deportations of hundreds of immigrants it alleges are members of a Venezuelan gang to El Salvador under the Alien Enemies Act.NBC News - 1d
More from The Hill
-
Former NASA astronaut: 'We're a good 15 years away from going to Mars'
Former NASA astronaut José Hernández said Monday that travel to Mars is “a good 15 years away.” “As I've always said … space travel is not trivial, and so what we need to do next is, we're going to ...The Hill - 1h -
New York Post says Musk is 'way out of his lane' in calling for impeachment of Judge Boasberg
The editorial board of The New York Post went after tech billionaire Elon Musk on Sunday, stating that he is “way out of his lane” in calling for the impeachment of a judge who temporarily blocked ...The Hill - 2h -
Trump displays Declaration of Independence copy in the Oval Office
President Trump is displaying a copy of the Declaration of Independence in the Oval Office after requesting it from the National Archives, according to a photograph he shared on Monday. “The ...The Hill - 4h -
Trump taps Bryan Bedford to head FAA
President Trump has tapped Bryan Bedford, the president and CEO of Republic Airways, to head the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). “Brian brings over three decades of experience in Aviation ...The Hill - 5h -
The Memo: Trump ratchets up confrontation with judiciary
President Trump and his administration ramped up their confrontation with the judiciary to extraordinary heights Monday, demanding that a judge whose ruling had incurred their disfavor should be ...The Hill - 5h
More in Politics
-
Former NASA astronaut: 'We're a good 15 years away from going to Mars'
Former NASA astronaut José Hernández said Monday that travel to Mars is “a good 15 years away.” “As I've always said … space travel is not trivial, and so what we need to do next is, we're going to ...The Hill - 1h -
Houthi militia unsuccessfully retaliates after it said U.S. strikes on Yemen killed 53
President Trump ordered airstrikes on the Houthi-held areas in Yemen, killing more than 50 people. NBC News' Matt Bradley has the latest on the rising tension in the Middle East.NBC News - 1h -
Law professor speaks on legality of deportations under Trump invoking Alien Enemies Act
Professor of law at Georgetown University David Super speaks with NBC News' Gadi Schwartz about President Trump's invoking of the Alien Enemies Act and the legality of the deportations used under it.NBC News - 1h -
Trump launches new military operation against Houthis
Aaron David Miller, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace and an advisor to many secretaries of state, spoke with NBC News' Gadi Schwartz about the Houthi rebels' attackNBC News - 1h -
New York Post says Musk is 'way out of his lane' in calling for impeachment of Judge Boasberg
The editorial board of The New York Post went after tech billionaire Elon Musk on Sunday, stating that he is “way out of his lane” in calling for the impeachment of a judge who temporarily blocked ...The Hill - 2h