It’s time to end the Medicare-Medicaid merry-go-round
To appreciate one of the great snafus of American health care, consider the plight of people who are poor, elderly — often with a disability — and insured by both Medicare and Medicaid.
One might think having two insurers must be better than one. But these two programs were never meant to work together. Rather than cooperating, the programs follow rules that create incentives for each partner to shift costs to the other, while patients are stuck in the middle, without the care they need.
For dually eligible Americans, bureaucratic nightmares are their daily realities.
A woman in her mid-30s with spina bifida relied on her electric wheelchair to get around. But when it failed in the middle of a busy New York City street, Medicaid required that she first ask Medicare to replace the wheelchair, knowing full well that the program wouldn’t cover it. It was only once Medicare denied the request that Medicaid began to consider her pleas for a replacement. The whole process took 20 months — so long that she resorted to a makeshift chair that left her with pressure sores and back aches.
In another case, an older man lost his dentures when coverage problems caused him to switch rehab centers multiple times, forcing him to eat only soft foods for years while Medicare and Medicaid refused to pay for replacements.
And a woman with a stroke struggled to receive needed rehabilitation while getting threatened with massive Medicare copays that Medicaid should cover. Then she was told she would lose her Medicaid coverage unless she produced five years of income documentation and re-registered within 13 days. Even her niece, a former top policy strategist at the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation – the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services regulator – was stymied by the maze of requirements.
If CMS’s top leaders struggle to navigate the system, who can?
These accounts are emblematic of the problems that plague the nearly 13 million dually eligible individuals with disabilities or are old enough to qualify for Medicare and poor enough to get Medicaid. Nearly all make less than $20,000 a year. They are arguably sicker than any other group enrolled in Medicare or Medicaid, with lifespans that are a decade shorter than other patients. And they cost the government a cool half a trillion dollars a year — a sum greater than any other group and one that will surely rise as the country ages.
It's not that Medicare and Medicaid fail to provide good coverage. The problem is that the two programs operate independently. At best, they fail to integrate coverage and coordinate care across the two plans.
The New Yorker’s wheelchair woes were created by the fact that federal law requires Medicaid to pay last and only when other payers don’t cover the service, and by Medicare’s detailed, but often outdated, rules that pay for wheelchairs only for inside use. The result should not be surprising, because it is the predictable results of the policies that we have allowed to persist.
As the challenges of navigating Medicare and Medicaid have grown in recent years, commercial companies offering Medicare plans have jumped to offer hundreds of “look-alike” plans that claim to be tailored to meet the needs of dually eligible individuals. In reality, these look-alike plans are designed for marketing appeal, not actual integration with Medicaid.
There has also been growth in integrated managed care products known as Special Needs Plans. These plans offer varying degrees of integration but only in some areas of the country. In some states, an influx of Special Needs Plans gives some beneficiaries dozens of integrated plans to choose from, while in other areas, the choice is limited to just one, or none at all.
To address the problems, a new bill has been introduced by a bipartisan group of senators, led by U.S. Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-La.), a physician who has treated dually eligible individuals and seen firsthand the challenges they face. The bill would have the federal government establish a list of integrated plans that states could choose from. To incentivize true coordination and limit the struggle over which plan pays for what, the bill requires integrated financial accounting between Medicare and Medicaid, and provides incentives to coordinate care by enabling states to share in savings that would otherwise go to Medicare. The measure has already garnered three Republican and three Democratic co-sponsors.
Meanwhile, a second measure, from U.S. Sen. Robert Casey (D-Pa.), was also introduced recently. This bill would give $300 million to CMS and the states to create their own integrated plans covering many of the same elements. It would spur integration by raising the federal matching funds that states receive to support administrative activities focused on integration to 80 percent, up from the customary 50 percent.
Here are three principles that should guide decisionmakers going forward:
- Design integrated coverage by first placing the experiences of the individuals who use these plans at the center and including all the services — medical and non-medical supports — that are needed to thrive. A consumer-informed approach is sorely lacking currently.
- Align financial incentives across Medicare and Medicaid so that a single entity receives unified payment, and responsibility, for providing care. This will eliminate two perverse incentives we see in the system today: first, one payor avoiding paying for prevention today because the other payer will bear the costs tomorrow, and second, all the back-and-forth currently required to determine which entity provides primary coverage for a given service.
- Provide real, informed choice to everyone who is dually eligible. That doesn’t mean providing dozens of options that overload the brain and lead individuals to choose plans that are not in their financial interest. It means eliminating poor choices and providing consumers with options across a small but meaningful number of integrated plans that are easy to compare, and supporting those choices with good decision aids.
Meaningful change in improving care will require proceeding with caution: there are hundreds of billions of dollars at stake and policymakers will need to be on guard against profit seeking at the expense of quality care. Policymakers and implementers will also need to avoid disrupting successful patient-provider relationships for vulnerable people.
As a physician and a health economist, I know there are monumental barriers to providing comprehensive, high-quality, patient-centered care for dually eligible patients. But we are compelled to try. The good news is that there is remarkable consensus across the country and across the aisle in Congress on the problems and the potential solutions. We can fix this together.
Rachel M. Werner, MD, Ph.D., is executive director of the Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics at the University of Pennsylvania, where she is professor of medicine and the Robert D. Eilers Professor of Health Care Management and Economics. She is also a physician at the Philadelphia VA.
Date: |
Topics
Filter
-
Treasury yields end higher for first time in four sessions
Rates on U.S. government debt closed higher on Thursday, with 10- and 30-year yields bouncing off their lowest levels since early April, after a fresh round of data.MarketWatch - Business -
Oil scores weekly gains, with U.S. prices ending above $80 for first time this month
Oil futures climbed Friday, contributing to gains for the week and prompting U.S. benchmark prices to settle above $80 a barrel for the first time this month, as some economic data from the U.S. and China raised hopes for stronger crude demand.MarketWatch - Business -
Scottie Scheffler's 41-round par-or-better streak ends with substitute caddie on bag at 2024 PGA Championship
The world's top-ranked golfer was without a crucial member of his team on Saturday in LouisvilleCBS Sports - Sports -
The Medicare Bubble Has Burst
The government health insurance program had been a gold mine for private insurers until recently.The Wall Street Journal - World -
‘I put his matchstick men in the bin’: Lowry’s lost sketches go on display for first time
When on holiday in Berwick the artist often gave his work away. Now a new exhibition reveals the value of drawings that survived in a shoebox . A 1958 drawing of a family with their dogs by LS Lowry from one of his many holidays in ...The Guardian - World -
What's next for the Thunder? OKC was punished for patience vs. Mavericks, and now it's time to go for it
The Thunder are flexible enough to make major improvements this offseasonCBS Sports - Sports -
2024 PGA Championship tee times, pairings: Complete schedule on TV, groups in Round 1 on Thursday at Valhalla
A number of star-studded groups will be featured throughout the first round of the 106th PGA Championship in LouisvilleCBS Sports - Sports -
2024 PGA Championship tee times, pairings: Complete schedule on TV, groups for Round 2 on Friday at Valhalla
Golfers will look to position themselves for the weekend after Valhalla played well through the first 18 holesCBS Sports - Sports -
2024 PGA Championship tee times, pairings: Complete schedule on TV, groups for Round 3 on Friday at Valhalla
Golfers will look to position themselves for the weekend after Valhalla played well through the first 36 holesCBS Sports - Sports -
2024 NHL Playoffs bracket: Stanley Cup Playoffs schedule, scores, start times for Saturday's Round 2 games
The conference finals matchups are nearly setCBS Sports - Sports - NHL
More from The Hill
-
Sullivan presses Netanyahu for a more focused military campaign in Gaza
White House national security adviser Jake Sullivan reiterated Biden administration pressure on Israel to limit its military operation in Gaza during a visit to the country on Sunday. Sullivan is on a combined trip to Israel and Saudi Arabia as ...The Hill - Politics - Israel -
Vance doubles down on praise for Viktor Orban's crackdown on universities in Hungary
Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio) stood by previous comments praising Hungarian President Viktor Orban for a regulatory crackdown on the country’s universities on Sunday, saying the U.S. should embrace a similar mindset. Orban, as part of anti-democratic ...The Hill - Politics -
Biden on Trump’s next Supreme Court pick: ‘Do you think he’ll put anybody who has a brain?’
President Biden asked the audience at an NAACP Detroit chapter dinner to consider whether they think former President Trump, if elected for a second term in the White House, would fill hypothetical vacancies at the Supreme Court with “anybody who ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
US to pull troops out of Niger by mid-September: Pentagon
The U.S. military will pull all of its assets out of Niger by mid-September, the Pentagon announced Sunday, after days of talks with the country’s military junta finalized a timeline. A group of military leaders executed a coup in Niger last year, ...The Hill - Politics -
Elon Musk debuts Starlink satellite internet service in Indonesia
Elon Musk traveled to Bali this weekend to officially launch Starlink, the SpaceX satellite internet service, in Indonesia this Sunday. At a launch event with ministers in a health clinic in Indonesia, Musk stressed the significance of providing ...The Hill - Politics - Elon Musk