It’s not about antisemitism: The real reason Trump is going after Columbia University
The Trump administration recently announced its intention to pull $400 million in federal funding from Columbia University. Details have yet to be provided, but it is anticipated that funding will be taken from multiple departments, including funds for ongoing scientific and medical research.
Nine other universities are also under investigation. Columbia, however, was the only university under investigation by three separate government agencies: the Departments of Justice, Education and Health and Human Services.
The ostensible justification for the withdrawal of funds is Columbia’s failure to adequately address antisemitism and to protect Jewish students and faculty in the wake of pro-Palestinian and pro-Hamas demonstrations on campus sparked by the Gaza War.
Already on Oct. 7, 2023 — the day of the Hamas massacres in southern Israel — Columbia’s campus was beset with chants of “From the river to sea.” Students and professors alike spoke out in praise of Hamas. Months of protests ensued. Columbia’s main quads were occupied, as was venerable Hamilton Hall, the site of student takeovers in the 1960s, protesting the Vietnam War. Commencement ceremonies in May 2024 were cancelled due to the protests. More recently, the library at Barnard College (a Columbia affiliate) was occupied by pro-Palestinian demonstrators.
It is beyond dispute that Jewish students were harassed last year at Columbia, many made to feel unsafe and unwelcome. Similar sentiments were expressed by those who lived in the university’s Morningside Heights neighborhood. It is also beyond dispute that the protestors were supported by outside organizations and that many in the protest encampments were not Columbia students.
Claims of “outside agitators” are eerily reminiscent of opponents of the Civil Rights movement. But the reported evidence is that significant numbers of people arrested at campus protests were not connected to the university. At Columbia, the New York Police Department estimated that 29 percent of those arrested during the protests were not affiliated with the school, and at the City College of New York the figure was 60 percent.
Sanctioning Columbia or other schools for a spineless response to antisemitism is subterfuge — and must be seen as such. The Trump administration’s actions are part of a concerted assault on key institutions critical to the functioning of government and democracy — and, without being hyperbolic, what had been an American way of life. From the National Park Service to the Veterans Administration to the National Institutes of Health to the FBI to the Centers for Disease Control to the intelligence community to siding with Putin over NATO, Columbia is an another incident in the Trump administration’s rapid-fire offensive against American institutions.
Antisemitism at Columbia — and elsewhere — is real, but let us recall that Trump dined at Mar-a-Lago with the prominent Holocaust denier and antisemite Nick Fuentes, who was a guest of Kanye West, a self-professed Nazi who recently sold T-shirts emblazoned with a swastika.
Jewish students — and Muslim students — at Columbia are entitled to attend school without fear and harassment. At the same time, all students are entitled to protest lawfully without harassing or being harassed, and without disrupting the functioning of the university. All students are entitled to attend classes without disruption and harassment. Further, residents of the area must also be free to live without fear of the protests and the protesters. On many of these points, Columbia failed last year.
But the university took its obligations seriously. Columbia examined its responses to antisemitism and published two substantial reports on them, which included finding “an urgent need to reshape everyday social norms across the campuses of Columbia University” and that “the problems we found are serious and pervasive.”
So what is the real motive here? Is this a precursor to defund universities for teaching evolutionary biology? Or for teaching climate science? Or to defund a university because its hospital center performed an abortion to save the life of a mother? Or to defund a university because of protests against the Trump administration — a thought that is clearly not beyond the pale?
This is the proverbial slippery slope. So I say to all who are pleased about the Columbia sanctions, be careful what you wish for — because it will come back around in ways you cannot even imagine.
Today it is ostensibly to combat antisemitism. Tomorrow it may be to combat science or even the right to protest. Beware.
Jonathan D. Strum is an international lawyer and businessman based in Washington and the Middle East. From 1991 to 2005, he was an adjunct professor of Israeli law at Georgetown University Law Center. From 2015 to 2020, he was general counsel to a graduate school focused on national security in Washington.
-
Trump Officials Warn 60 Colleges of Possible Antisemitism Penalties
The administration’s warning came just after it pulled hundreds of millions of dollars from Columbia University.The New York Times - 1d -
Trump is using antisemitism as a pretext for a war on the first amendment | Judith Levine
The Trump administration is not interested in combating antisemitism. It just wants to silence its opponents instead. On Saturday night, agents of the Department of Homeland Security arrested and ...The Guardian - 9h -
What to know about pro-Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil's arrest
More protests are expected Tuesday over the Trump administration's attempt to deport pro-Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil. Khalil is accused of antisemitic activity for his role in helping lead ...CBS News - 1d -
Wife of Columbia graduate student detained by Ice speaks out about his arrest
Mahmoud Khalil was detained by Ice agents on Saturday, part of Trump’s crackdown on pro-Palestinian campus protesters. Mahmoud Khalil’s wife, who is now eight months pregnant, issued a statement on ...The Guardian - 7h -
Trump cancels $400 million in federal funds to Columbia University
The Trump administration announced Friday that it is canceling $400 million in federal grants to Columbia University, saying the school is not doing enough to protect its Jewish students against ...NBC News - 4d -
Protests grow over Columbia University pro-Palestinian activist's arrest
A judge is slamming the brakes on the Trump administration's attempt to deport a pro-Palestinian activist who helped lead Columbia University's 2024 student encampment protests.CBS News - 1d -
US colleges warned of ‘enforcement actions’ over antisemitism allegations
Warning comes after cancellation of $400m in funding to Columbia and detention of student activist Mahmoud Khalil. The US education department’s civil rights office issued warnings on Monday to ...The Guardian - 1d -
Border czar on Columbia arrest: 'Absolutely we can' deport a legal immigrant
Tom Homan, President Trump’s border czar, said Monday that federal authorities “absolutely can” deport a legal immigrant after U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) arrested a Columbia ...The Hill - 2d -
Education Department says 60 universities under investigation for antisemitism
The Department of Education’s Office of Civil Rights (OCR) is investigating 60 universities for antisemitism, according to letters sent on Monday. The department said the 60 institutions are ...The Hill - 2d
More from The Hill
-
US puts Putin in hot seat with Ukraine ceasefire proposal
The United States has for the first time shifted the pressure to Russia in President Trump’s push for a ceasefire in Ukraine, after securing Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky’s support for a ...The Hill - 34m -
Watch live: NASA launches SpaceX mission to return Boeing Starliner crew from space station
NASA and SpaceX will launch the Crew-10 mission to retrieve astronauts Suni Williams and Butch Wilmore from the International Space Station on Wednesday evening. Williams and Wilmore, part of last ...The Hill - 40m -
Warren calls on Oz to sever financial ties to health care, pharmaceutical companies
Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) has written a letter to Mehmet Oz, asking him to make a series of commitments to avoid conflicts of interests ahead of his confirmation hearing Friday to lead the ...The Hill - 47m -
Ohio lawmakers push for NASA headquarters move to Cleveland
A group of Ohio lawmakers in Congress is pushing for NASA headquarters to be moved from Washington, D.C., to Cleveland. The lawmakers argued in a letter Tuesday to Vice President Vance, who is from ...The Hill - 54m -
Senate Democrats insist on voting on 30-day government funding bill
Senate Democrats say they will not vote for the House-passed six-month government funding package, which would boost defense spending and cut nondefense programs, unless they first get a vote on a ...The Hill - 55m
More in Politics
-
US puts Putin in hot seat with Ukraine ceasefire proposal
The United States has for the first time shifted the pressure to Russia in President Trump’s push for a ceasefire in Ukraine, after securing Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky’s support for a ...The Hill - 34m -
Watch live: NASA launches SpaceX mission to return Boeing Starliner crew from space station
NASA and SpaceX will launch the Crew-10 mission to retrieve astronauts Suni Williams and Butch Wilmore from the International Space Station on Wednesday evening. Williams and Wilmore, part of last ...The Hill - 40m -
Warren calls on Oz to sever financial ties to health care, pharmaceutical companies
Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) has written a letter to Mehmet Oz, asking him to make a series of commitments to avoid conflicts of interests ahead of his confirmation hearing Friday to lead the ...The Hill - 47m -
Ohio lawmakers push for NASA headquarters move to Cleveland
A group of Ohio lawmakers in Congress is pushing for NASA headquarters to be moved from Washington, D.C., to Cleveland. The lawmakers argued in a letter Tuesday to Vice President Vance, who is from ...The Hill - 54m -
Senate Democrats insist on voting on 30-day government funding bill
Senate Democrats say they will not vote for the House-passed six-month government funding package, which would boost defense spending and cut nondefense programs, unless they first get a vote on a ...The Hill - 55m