Israel's next move can disarm Tehran or upend a fragile global detente
Last week, we celebrated the 82nd anniversary of the “Doolittle Raid.” A handful of U.S. Army Air Force B-25s operating from a base President Franklin Roosevelt called Shangri-La, bombed Tokyo in the first direct American attack on the Japanese mainland after Pearl Harbor.
Little damage was done, but the psychological effect on the Japanese was a powerful warning to the public that it was no longer safe from attack.
After Iran’s massive drone and missile strike on Israel, the question of what if anything Israel would do loomed like a damoclean sword over the region. Last Friday, Israel launched a modest strike against targets in Isfahan; a city well inside Iran, not unlike in scope to the Doolittle. The critical question now is whether that will end the crisis or merely make it a starting point for escalation.
Some Israeli domestic factions as well as other supporters abroad believe Iran’s attack created the opportunity and rationale to destroy Iran’s nuclear infrastructure once and for all. That would be catastrophic. But suppose such an option was still under consideration.
Iran’s nuclear infrastructure, including personnel, is spread out over vast areas and in some places deeply buried underground. An attack plan that would use unmanned air-breathing missiles and drones and manned aircraft would have to fly over Syria and/or Iraq and Saudi Arabia. The distances to targets are not trivial. And no matter how formidable the Israel Defense Forces may be, it is unlikely that it has the numerical and qualitative capacity as well as tankers and supporting forces to disable those facilities for a substantial period.
In this regard, Israel must answer two questions. First, will the “shadow war” in place lead to further escalation and a “real” war? Thus, is Israel prepared to go to war if it decides further retaliation is essential? Iran has already stated that any attack on its nuclear facilities would be equivalent to an act of war by Israel.
Second, if the Israeli aim were to destroy these facilities, if not permanently but for a very extended period, the only means to accomplish this task would be nuclear weapons. Even if Israel had enough so-called “conventional bunker busters” with several tons of explosive power, delivering them to a large number of targets is almost certainly beyond the IDF’s means. And despite the destructive power of nuclear weapons, the chance of near-permanent elimination of all of Iran’s nuclear weapons potential is very unlikely.
Why? During the October 1962 Cuban Missile Crisis, one option presented to President John F. Kennedy was U.S. air strikes against these facilities. Recall that the missiles were land-based and had no protective shelters, making them easy targets. However, Kennedy was told that the complete destruction of the missiles and associated logistics and launching equipment could not be guaranteed.
For a military planner, not just destroying, but also incapacitating Iran’s nuclear weapons programs presents a nearly impossible scenario.
If Israel were to employ nuclear weapons — and this would not be one or two but probably tens — collateral damage would be vast. Minimizing casualties and using nuclear weapons is the ultimate contradiction. And what about subsequent radiation? The trade winds blow east. And who lies east of Iran — Russia and China.
The use of nuclear and thermonuclear weapons has been deemed “unthinkable.” But on a number of occasions during the Cold War, both the U.S. and USSR came frighteningly close to making a catastrophic miscalculation. Exercise Able Archer is one such example.
Whether Prime Minister Benyamin Netanyahu and his war cabinet would even consider using nuclear weapons or not, surely, a scenario aimed at crippling some of Iran’s nuclear weapons programs must be on the table. This then gets back to first principles.
Is Israel prepared for an all-out war with Iran? If it is, would there be any limits on the range of actions it might or might not take? Would it consider using nuclear weapons or not? If the answer is yes, would Israel be capable of understanding the titanic consequences in short or long-term impact?
The possibility of further Israeli retaliation cannot be discounted. While President Joe Biden and other leaders do not have the power to force or prevent certain Israeli actions, at the least, the prime minister and his team must be starkly warned of the dire consequences of attacking Iran’s nuclear facilities.
April/May 2024 must not become August 1914.
Harlan Ullman Ph.D. is a senior advisor at the Atlantic Council and the prime author of the “shock and awe” military doctrine. His 12th book, “The Fifth Horseman and the New MAD: How Massive Attacks of Disruption Became the Looming Existential Danger to a Divided Nation and the World at Large,” is available on Amazon. He can be reached on Twitter @harlankullman.
Date: | |
Tag: | Israel |
Filter
-
Apple vs. the world: Can the tech giant survive a global regulatory onslaught?
Apple has a strong track record fighting antitrust enforcers, but the global scope of its current fight is something new.MarketWatch - Business - Apple -
Bird flu outbreak in US cattle sparks fears over next global health crisis
While pandemic risk is low, scientists say urgent investigations into the virus are necessaryFinancial Times - Business -
UN ambassador condemns Gershkovich detention
United Nations Ambassador Linda Thomas-Greenfield condemned the detention of Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich, who has been in Russian prison for more than a year. “We gather here on the eve of World Press Freedom Day, an opportunity ...The Hill - Politics - United Nations -
Middle East Crisis: Trade and Diplomatic Moves Deepen Israel’s Isolation
Turkey’s decision to suspend trade with Israel came after some countries downgraded or cut ties. But key allies, including the U.S., remain supportive.The New York Times - World - Israel -
Top 20 Global Concert Tours from Pollstar
Top 20 Global Concert Tours from Pollstar from week 05/06/2024ABC News - Entertainment -
U.S. college protests inspire rise in pro-Palestinian demonstrations around the world
Pro-Palestinian demonstrations that have rocked college campuses in the United States are now gaining traction across the world as protesters join the movement globally.NBC News - Top stories -
Mass deportations, detention camps, troops on the street: Trump spells out migrant plan
Trump White House 2.0 would mean a vast, legally dubious roundup of up to 11 million people and pit state against state. Donald Trump is planning to unleash the biggest mass deportation of undocumented migrants in US history should he win ...The Guardian - World - Donald Trump -
Gambling-software company Games Global valued at about $2 billion in IPO
Games Global, which recently entered the U.S. market, has 40 exclusive studios, more than 1,300 proprietary games, and “some of the industry’s highest paying progressive jackpot network,” according to the company.MarketWatch - Business -
Venomous snakes likely to migrate en masse amid global heating, says study
Researchers find many countries unprepared for influx of new species and will be vulnerable to bites. Climate breakdown is likely to lead to the large-scale migration of venomous snake species into new regions and unprepared countries, according ...The Guardian - World -
The OECD said the global economy could suffer a significant setback if an escalation of conflict in the Middle East were to push oil prices sharply higher.
The OECD said the global economy could suffer a significant setback if an escalation of conflict in the Middle East were to push oil prices sharply higher.The Wall Street Journal - World
More from The Hill
-
Hope Hicks offers dramatic testimony in Trump trial: 5 takeaways
Former President Trump’s trial closed out the week in dramatic style as former aide Hope Hicks took the stand. Hicks, who served as press secretary in the early, ramshackle days of Trump’s first campaign for the presidency, went on to become his ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
International court pushes back on 'threats' as it weighs Israel-Hamas arrests
The International Criminal Court (ICC) pushed back against “threats” Friday as it faces intense pressure following reports of possible arrest warrants for Israeli and Hamas officials over their conduct in the Oct. 7 attack and war in Gaza that has ...The Hill - Politics - Israel -
Biden adds carveout to EV credit restrictions
Welcome to The Hill's Energy & Environment newsletter {beacon} Energy & Environment Energy & Environment The Big Story Biden issues flexible guidance for EV components The Biden administration granted leeway for qualifying for electric vehicle ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Biden awards Medal of Freedom to 19 recipients, including Pelosi, Clyburn
President Biden on Friday awarded the Medal of Freedom to 19 recipients, including top longtime Democratic congressional leaders, calling them “an incredible group of people.” “Nineteen incredible people whose relentless curiosity, inventiveness, ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Iowa will face lawsuit if it acts on immigration law, DOJ warns
The Department of Justice (DOJ) warned Iowa on Friday that the state will face a lawsuit if it implements an immigration law that forbids people from being in the state if they were previously denied entry into the United States. The DOJ informed ...The Hill - Politics